Skip to main content

Member Reviews

After several tries of reading this book, unfortunately I have to DNF. I think I was expecting this book to be more in the side of sci-fi instead of literature and although yes this was definitely a mix of both, the literature side took over and I was not a fan of the info-dumps at the beginning of the book.

I will try to pick up this book up again when I think I'll appreciate the literature side more. Thank you so much to Netgalley and the publisher for the e-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fascinating book, and a difficult one to review, since it's incredibly difficult to unpick the metatextual nature of the story from how it functions as a novel. Where this book really shines is in the light it casts on the commodification of #ownvoices and often complicated relationships between artists and fans. The most compelling parts, for me, are watching how Zelu reacts to other people's interpretations of her work, and how she tries to remain true to herself even while everyone else is determine to market her based on her identity. I think the genre hybrid elements actually work really well here; since what is science fiction if not a mirror to complicated human emotions we've historically consigned to lit fic.

The part that didn't work quite so well for me is that the robot story within a story is, frankly, not that engaging, and I often found myself skimming those sections. That would haven't been such a problem if the main plot didn't hinge so much on Zelu, as the author of said story, being shot into the stratosphere as a result of this supposedly genius work. But then again, a lot of other mediocre works hit the big time, so maybe that's the point?

Was this review helpful?

This was a complicated book to read and review, and it took me two attempts and several months to become interested in the book. It's clear that the author is a talented writer, with realistic and flawed characters. That said, I felt let down by how the book was marketed. It was labelled as science fiction, but in reality, it leans much more toward literary fiction, and it isn't something that I would normally reach for.

The core premise was promising. Zelu, the protagonist, becomes an overnight sensation after the release of her book 'Rusted Robots'. However, the book-within-the-book didn't work for me - the snippets we do see from Rusted Robots feel underdeveloped, which made it hard to understand why it caused such a stir. I also felt like the ending of the overall novel, while going in interesting directions, felt unsatisfying and too abrupt.

Thankyou to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A complex story, not one to review easily without giving too much away. Being a long-time reader of the author it is good to have a book which is officially available in the UK, to have in our store!

On the surface this is a story of Zelu, a struggling writer with mobility/health issues following a childhood accident, who finds in quick succession further rejection of a novel and dismissal from university teaching. Zelu sets out and writes something completely new, a SFF story which becomes wildly successful. This book has Zelu's story intercut with extracts from the story of her written book, As Zelu's life spirals into something new, for better and worse, there is a feeling that there are more links to emerge...

An excellent multi-layered book of Zelu's life, the family and other relationships, exploring the cultures and history of their backgrounds. Interspersed with this is the story of forms of robotic and AI life in a post-human world, with it's own conflicts and threats. Ultimately a story of personal strength, resilience and determination to follow and forge paths. It seems wrong to say 'against the odds' as that detracts from the personal drive and determination to live life as desired. Whilst the ending has other things to reveal, this 'desire' for life feels like the core of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Orion Publishing Group for the arc!

🌟🌟🌟✨/5

Oof, this one's tough to judge. This doesn't read like a sci-fi novel. It's a litfic novel about a sci-fi novel, and I think I liked it?

As someone who's recently been on a litfic streak, I enjoyed the narrative set in the 'real' world, set in the near future. Zelu is undoubtedly a complex, fleshed out character but also quite unlikable. There were moments where I resonated with her and moments where I was exasperated by her. It's not often you get to see a disabled protagonist and the author's perspective was refreshing. The family dynamics were definitely the highlight of the book. Nigerian culture is an integral part of the novel. The parts about the publishing industry, some of which reminded me of Yellowface, were fun to read.

The other part of the novel, Rusted Robots, was not my cup of tea. The chapters from Zelu's novel few and far between, with chapters from Zelu's POV dominating the book. While I was invested in Zelu's narrative, the sci-fi chapters felt like interruptions rather than something that merited attention as much as Zelu's POV. The worldbuilding just didn't have enough time to be developed. It didn't feel immersive at all. Only the final two chapters were excellent, which made me even more disappointed because of the wasted potential. In Zelu's chapters, it was mentioned that Rusted Robots was over 500 pages long, which makes sense considering the epic scope of the novel. The few extracts we get barely amount to a 100 pages.

At its heart, Death of the Author is a love letter to the art of storytelling. The discussions about the power of storytelling will be something that'll remain with me, even if I forget the rest of the plot. The final line was particularly impactful for me.

While this is being marketed everywhere as a sci-fi novel (and I'm pretty sure it'll end up as a Goodreads Choice sci-fi nominee) I would recommend this to litfic readers who enjoy complex family dynamics and discussions of tradition vs modernity. I've heard amazing things about Nnedi Okorafor's actual sci-fi novels and probably will read some this year!

Was this review helpful?

This was so close to being perfect for me, but there was just something that seemed to drag around halfway through, that made this harder going for me than the story either side.

I was initially so engaged with Zelu's rise to authorial fame that I was expecting some kind literal "death" of the author, and I'm still not entirely certain how much of the more conceptual meaning was actually in the text (I guess part of the point, or one of the layers of interpretation of Zelu's own writing). When it wasn't clear that this was happening, either literally or literary, I wasn't sure where the novel was heading next.

I also initially enjoyed the Rusted Robots chapters that were interspersed with the story, but the writing of them felt relatively poor (I suppose making it clear that Zelu and the author are different entities too), but it meant that I was then critiquing the writing and wondering how this became a bestselling novel.

I loved the writing of Zelu's family - she's clearly incredibly frustrated by them, but her family ties are essential, even when they aren't being supportive of her dreams (basically all of the time) but that's immaterial because they are family.

There is a twist though, and the twist is surprisingly unexpected, and certainly very brilliant. It makes you question yourself as a reader, and what role you are playing in the story. It nearly completely redeemed the part that had dragged for me, and it's just plain clever.

This was my first book by Nnedi Okorafor and I'll definitely be looking out for more.

Really, this was more like 4.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

A superb fantasy action adventure that will have you on the edge of the seat right from page one. A must read that is highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Yet another book to add to the list of 'something beautifully brand new'.

This story was an incredible experience to read that forced me to ask many questions of myself, and was left with many that I wanted the book to answer...but wasn't that what we were warned against throughout?!

Also, I want a full copy of Rusted Robots as well!

Was this review helpful?

dnf at 14%

Unfortunately, this book just wasn’t what I expected going into it and I found myself getting very bored while reading. I do, however, see myself picking up a different book by this author as I’ve heard amazing things.

Thank you to NetGalley and Gollancz for the advanced digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is another author who I’ve been meaning to check out for a while and this was certainly an interesting one to start with! I enjoyed the dual narrative with some of it being Zelu’s story and some of it being Ankara, the robot from her novel.

I can’t say how the representation of a paraplegic women was as I don’t have that life experience, but I did feel that Zelu was a very strong character who was given agency both by the other characters and the author, which is something I look out for with disabled characters. She receives cutting edge treatment during the book, but it is made clear that what she gets is mobility aids and not a cure. Her disability is integral to both the plot and character and it was really enlightening to see how she was treated, especially in Nigeria and by her family members. From a cultural aspect, I felt this was important.

I enjoyed the robot parts most. It makes me think that I would like Okorafor’s sci fi books a lot

Really glad I finally got around to reading this author and I can’t wait to read more of her stuff.

Was this review helpful?

Great novel, enjoyed reading this so much on a recent trip.

Thanks so much to NetGalley and the publishers for letting me access this book in exchange for my feedback.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for access to this ARC!

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and it's crazy combination of sci-si and lit-fic rolled into one. I found Zelu as a main character fascinating and her journey so interesting to follow, from it's beginnings to the insane conclusion. The sci-fi elements, while sparser than I expected, were a delight to read every time we got to another chapter about the robot adventures. I even found myself longing for the sequel Zelus fans were egging her on to write.

I also loved the commentary on personal independence, how art can turn into a product, the use of technology in society and how those in the public eye have to treat social media often like they are walking on eggshells. Zelus family playing a hug part in her story too added a layer of relatability that I cherished, coming from a similar family dynamic as hers.

I had a few issues with things like pacing and sometimes a lack of focus when it came to Zelus character journey, which knocked a star and a bit off my rating.

All in all I enjoyed this book and while I feel like it may not be for everyone, it for sure was for me.

3.75 stars rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Orion publishing and netgalley for providing this arc.

Unfortunately, after 10% I had to dnf this book, as it was nothing what was promised. I picked this one up as it was going to be (and think it was) illumicrate's new scifi box's first book. I was super interested, as good scifi books are amazing and I love all the technology advancements and stuff like that in scifi. Well, consider me very disappointed with this one.

I read the 10% already back in February, and since then I have been wondering whether I should continue or not, but I've read the other reviews, and I know this book won't turn more scifi in the future, so why bother.

This book didn't hook me at all, and while I think the idea seems okayish, it wasn't what was promised, so that ultimately is the reason I won't be continuing.

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderfully unique book. It is told in two storylines - the tale of Zelu, her path from unknown author to successful author, and her journey. It also includes her story, a beautiful science fiction tale of humanity and struggle. Zelu is a flawed yet strong and determined main character, and I was cheering for her success throughout, although there were times when she made that challenging. She comes from a very successful family and is seen as the black sheep and looked down on by some for her lack of success and her disability.

I think this book needs to be read a couple of times to take in the story to its fullest potential.

Was this review helpful?

I’m really struggling with what to say about this book. For a large portion of it, I was not enjoying it at all. I never really warmed up to the main character, and the plot felt quite boring. That being said, the last 100 or so pages I liked a lot better, and I thought the ending worked really well! Anything more than 3 stars would feel disingenuous as I was very close to DNFing this at one point.

Was this review helpful?

The fact it took me over two months to finish this book says a lot about my experience of it. It is such a fantastic concept, but the execution is...rocky. So much of the writing is honestly just...not as good as it should be? So much narration that is both clunky and right on the nose, major characters who behave in ways that are clearly there to make plot happen rather than because they are fully-fledged people, and a main character who is weirdly prickly about some things and then totally blase about others and you can never guess which reaction she'll have because there's no rhyme or reason to it. I wanted to love it, and I will say that the ending won me over just a bit. Two and half stars. Richard Powers' agonizingly beautiful Playground tackles extremely similar themes with more craft, artistry and sophistication.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so mich more than I expected. Su much more than a literary fiction novel about an author becoming famous with her debit novel.
First, we have a lot of representation here. Zelu, our female main character, is an African-American disabled women. She has strong Nigerian roots, there is a lot of cultural representation due to her family and trips to Africa, which I loved to get a glimpse of and learn about. She sits in a wheelchair since an accident when she was 12 and it changed a lot how she is treated by her family and by strangers.
Second, there is Zelus Science-Fiction novel set in an apocalyptic world where humans are almost extinct and robots and AI took over. We get a lot of excerpts from her book "Rusted Robots" which I really enjoyed reading, because the characters were super interesting and the story intriguing.
And third, there is the technical part where Zelu gets the option to get an own exo skeleton to be able to walk again.

That an so much more is happening, but all in all it is a very character driven story - which I love.
I also loved the whole drama, the conflicts within and out of the family, the romance.
It was a fantastic read and a lot to think about with the choices Zelu made during the story. With the social criticism etc.
I can only recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

thank you netgalley for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

i bought “death of the author” thinking it was purely sci-fi, but before reading it i found reviews that said it was mostly contemporary literary fiction with a touch of sci-fi. i’m glad to have known that before reading it myself, so i was prepared and had the right expectations. ultimately it was an interesting combination of both genres and i think this is the perfect book for readers looking for an introduction to the sci-fi genre.

anyway, i really enjoyed this book. i don’t have many cohesive thoughts at the moment because the ending blew me away. the build-up was slow but so clever. this is the prime example of the “story within a story” trope done well.

Was this review helpful?

⤷ 4✩
“But true storytelling has always been one of the few great things humanity could produce that no automation could.”

I have to admit that I went into this book with the wrong expectations. It’s heavily focused on the literary fiction aspect, and the sci-fi elements are quite minor. So, if you prefer litfic and want to try something with a sci-fi twist, this might be the perfect book for you.

The pacing is consistent, the characters are well-developed, and the world-building is solid. However, there is a lot of family drama and mental health issues, which sometimes become a bit too overbearing to read.

Because of my skewed expectations toward sci-fi, I did feel a bit bored at times. I found myself waiting for the story to focus more on the sci-fi aspects. That said, the ending was absolutely great, and I really didn’t see it coming. There was a real payoff, even though the payoff was only about 20 pages long.

Was this review helpful?

The writing style just wasn’t for me. Maybe it’s the genre. I was just confused on what was going on.

Was this review helpful?