Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and Eleanor Goymer for providing me with an advance reader copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

While The Plot Twist had a somewhat gentle start, requiring a bit of patience, the payoff was well worth the initial investment. The narrative gradually drew me in, and once the central elements began to coalesce, I found myself thoroughly engaged. The latter half of the book, in particular, proved to be incredibly enjoyable, filled with moments that truly resonated. Eleanor Goymer masterfully builds the story, and while the initial pace might feel unhurried, it ultimately serves to enhance the impact of the later, more compelling developments. If you appreciate a story that takes its time to lay the groundwork before delivering a truly satisfying experience, then this is one to persevere with. The eventual unfolding of the plot and the well-crafted "best bits" make the initial slow burn worthwhile

3.5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨

This author is new to me, but I will be keeping an eye out for anything else they publish. I loved the story and the characters. The pacing of the story was great and the characters were relatable.

This one was a little drab for me, but I love a book about books so stuck it out.

Thanks to Netgalley for the free copy in exchange for an honest review. Rounded up from 2.75

4⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Okay. The Plot Twist by Eleonor Goymer? That title was not lying.
This book took me on a ride I did not see coming. What starts as a seemingly straightforward romance or drama (I won’t spoil how it opens!) quickly unravels into something deeper, darker, and so much more layered.

The pacing was on point—I flew through it in a couple of sittings. The writing is emotionally rich, and I really felt for the main character. But what makes this book stand out is exactly what it promises: that twist. I literally had to pause, go back, and re-read a chapter like, “Wait—did that just happen?!”

It’s clever without trying too hard, and if you’re someone who loves books that mess with your expectations and leave you thinking about it after… this is one to pick up.

4/5 stars – it gave drama, gave emotion, gave me trust issues. Would I recommend? Absolutely!!



❤️shaye.readss

I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

This was a fun concept that needed just a little more work.

Eleanor Goymer’s The Plot Twist offers a refreshing take on romance by focusing more on emotions, personal growth, and enduring relationships rather than just passion and lust. The story follows romcom author Allie Edwards and crime novelist Martin Clark, two writers struggling with writer’s block. Their unlikely partnership to swap genres not only sparks creativity but also forges a heartwarming bond that’s more familial than romantic.

The dynamic between Allie and Martin is undoubtedly the heart of the book. Their relationship, filled with mentorship and mutual support, blossoms into something beautiful, and it’s satisfying to see them help each other find direction in both writing and life. On the romance front, Allie’s relationship with Will, a charming caterer, is sweet and well-paced, although a few chapters from Will’s perspective could have made their connection feel more balanced.

While the story has its predictable moments, it remains thoroughly enjoyable and easy to read. The subplot about the publishing world is interesting but feels somewhat disconnected from the central romance. Additionally, some of Allie’s decisions are a bit frustrating, and Martin’s personal issues lack proper resolution. Despite these minor drawbacks, the novel’s lighthearted charm and focus on relationships make it a delightful read.

In the end, The Plot Twist is not groundbreaking in any way but is reminiscent of a feel-good romcom — fun, uplifting, and pleasantly comforting. It’s a perfect pick if you’re looking for a story that’s cozy and heartfelt. I’d rate it 3.5 out of 5 stars.

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This was a really fun book. I loved it so much that I've added it to my list of books to buy so I can read it again!

This was a cute romance without enough romance. Allie is a romance writer who has writer's block. She meets a curmudgeonly and famous detective writer who also has writer's block and they agree to help each other. That premise is actually a little hard to understand, because she gives him some ideas for his next book but she also helps him repair his relationship with his wife and uses that as fodder for her next novel. So I'm not exactly sure what he gives her but they develop a sweet friendship. Meanwhile she keeps encountering a handsome caterer who we know needs to be her love interest but that part of the story is just not developed enough to be satisfying. I wish this story just had a little more, the potential was certainly there.

The Plot Twist is a sweet and funny story about writing, love, and unexpected friendships. Allie, a romcom writer, and Martin, a grumpy crime novelist, are both stuck with writer’s block and no pages to show their editors. When they meet at a party, they come up with a wild idea: to swap genres and help each other finish their books.

As they work together, Allie finds a new friend in Martin, and meets Will, a charming caterer who might be the perfect love interest for both her life and her novel.

This book is lighthearted and full of fun moments, with a little romance, a bit of chaos, and a lot of heart. Perfect for fans of books about books and stories about second chances.

This was a cute quick read, I don’t read a lot of contemporary romance but this was a nice change of pace from my usual dark romance. Overall I enjoyed it and would recommend to a friend. Very cute. 3.75/5 stars.

Surprisingly addictive…

We follow a burnout romance author in need of her next book, Allie, who sadly hasn’t written anything for months. Things are definitely not going well for her: a new and mean boss puts more pressure on her deadline and her love life is crumbling. One night, at an event, she meets a thriller author, Martin, and they end up coming up with a plan to write the books they need to submit. They decide to meet and switch plots. At the same time they are working together, Allie meets a cute events caterer, Will.

I loved the plot, how well Martin and Allie worked together and how the professional relationship develops into a genuine friendship. Will and Allie are also very cute and have chemistry.

All in all, I give this book a 5/5 stars. I would definitely buy it.

I’m not always a big fan of writer romances however I loved Homer’s last novel so decided to give this one a go. Unfortunately it didn’t work for me the slow burn was a little to slow (I forgot it was a romance at time). There were times where the story was a little over the top and made it hard to connect with our main characters. However if you are a fan of books about books I feel you would enjoy this one.

Amazing! I enjoyed this book so much!! Thank you so much to letting me read this arc!

I will be looking forward to reading more from this author

I struggled with this book. I fell in love with the premise and everything to do with the idea of this book but the execution unfortunately fell short for me. I think there was too much going on for this book with the romantic plot line but then also a somewhat mystery plot line with the agent and a seperate plot line with Martin. I kind of wish this book wasn’t a romance and only focused on the mentorship and friendship with Martin and leant more into the mystery element with the agent and made the stakes higher with that.

2/5 stars.

Good premise, but badly written and way too predictable. I definitely do not recommend this book.

This one was not for me. This is hardly a romance? That was the most disappointing part. The FMC is supposed to be in her 30s but reads so young. It was hard to like her and relate to her. It was also hard to follow along the pacing seemed weird.

First of all thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Unfortunately, while the book is well written and I do mostly like the characters, I've had to DNF at 40% because it is just a little too predictable for me. I've guessed the plot twist, mainly because I think it's a bit too obvious. It's kind of sapped my desire to read the book. I might go back and finish the book, but at the moment, this is a miss for me.

Not much to say other than that I had a lovely time with this book and would read anything Eleanor Goymer writes in the future. Sometimes that's all you need.

This delightful romcom is a love letter to storytelling, complete with writer’s block (relatable), plot swaps, and a touch of unexpected magic. When romance author Allie and grumpy crime novelist Martin team up to write each other’s books (it's giving Beach Read!!), it sparks not only creativity but a heartwarming friendship that becomes the soul of the story.

Allie is relatable, funny, and refreshingly self-aware, and watching her bond with Martin is just as satisfying as the romance itself. Their dynamic is full of wit and warmth — think odd couple meets creative soulmates. As she finds her footing again, Allie also meets Will, a swoon-worthy caterer who brings both heat and heart to her life (and manuscript). Their romance is light, flirty, and genuine, and adds just the right amount of spice.

This book beautifully blends humor, vulnerability, and the chaos of chasing a deadline, all while exploring what it means to write your own story—literally and figuratively. It’s about love, yes, but also about reinvention, creative courage, and the unexpected people who help you find your voice.

Funny, feel-good, and full of heart—this is the perfect read for fans of books about books and happily-ever-afters.

Clever and utterly charming! A love story for book lovers, full of meta moments and unexpected turns. Eleanor Goymer delivers a witty, page-turning romance with a twist you'll love.