Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I was so excited when I saw a new addition to this series and wasn't disappointed when I read it. I enjoyed that Mummy-ji and Rumpi had their own mystery to solve. I did miss the India setting but not too much. Can't wait for the next book!

Was this review helpful?

While you obviously will get more out of each book, if you read the whole series – Hall doesn’t leave you floundering if you’ve never before picked up one of his previous offerings. It was interesting to see Vish’s take on London and our food. Given how fond he is of the spicier side of Indian cuisine, you won’t be surprised to find that most of our takeaway and fast food leaves him utterly underwhelmed. Nor is he all that impressed at the vegan recipes his host serves up. While there is never anything overly gory or too disturbing, Hall doesn’t flinch from exposing the corruption afflicting the Indian way of life so Vish’s preoccupation with food throughout the series helps to leaven some of the sharper aspects of these stories – a common trope in cosy crime.

Food aside, the case goes on getting ever twistier as even his very effective operatives back home seem to be hitting a brick wall. Once more, I loved the Indian setting and the sheer vibrancy of the scene setting achieved by Hall, who gives me not only a vivid description of the backdrop but the sounds and smells. And while we do spend time back there – I did miss seeing Puri in his natural environment. A major bonus is that Mummy-ji accompanies Vish to London. I love her character – and the final twist at the end of the story had me laughing aloud. All in all, this is another thoroughly entertaining and enjoyable addition to a wonderful series. The ebook arc copy of The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest opinion of the book.
9/10

Was this review helpful?

The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck was my first Vish Puri detective novel, although evidently the sixth in the series. This particular one came out after a long wait. Puri is India's answer to Hercule Peroit, with the same crime solving skills, but the same admiration of himself that Periot displays.

I found this series fun and easy to read. The book was not too long, which was a nice change after reading a couple of 400+ page novels.

Vish Puri learns he has won the coveted detective of the year award, which he will go to London to collect. He is taking his wife, but his Mummy decides to tag along, with or without an invitation. Mummy ji's resources are equal to those of her son, and she was my favorite character.

Once in London, Puri must track down a scammer who has separated many victims from their money. He must do this, however, without letting his wife or mother know he is working. Fun, murder, and mayhem ensue. There is an air of golden age mystery in Tarquin Hall's writing style even though the books are set in modern times.

This was a 3.75 read for me, but I'm rounding up to 4 for pure enjoyment.

Thank you to NetGalley, Tarquin Hall and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

There's no way I wouldn't recommend a Tarquin Hall mystery as I'm love with these stories, the humour, the smeel of Indian spices, Vish Puri and his family.
A story that mixes some very serious topics like biotech and the side effect of miracle drugs, lots of very funny witticism and crazi situations.
Loved it, highly entertaining
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

It’s been about six years since we last met Vish Puri, India’s most lovable portly food-loving private investigator created by author Tarquin Hall, so I was eager to accompany the detective on a jaunt to London, where he is to receive the International Detective of the Year award. But of course, how could Mr. Puri not get embroiled in a mystery case even when he’s not in his home court? He’s been asked to go undercover to track down an Indian pharmaceutical fraudster hiding in London who has been dubbed “Bombay Duck,” (hilarious, especially for those who know what a Bombay Duck is). In London he teams up with his old friend from Scotland Yard and his reluctant nephew Jags who becomes an assistant, while his team on the ground in New Delhi covers the India angle. The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck is yet another hilarious mystery romp with Vish Puri and his personal idiosyncrasies and cultural penchants that Tarquin Hall reflect so well, down to the use of the English language and unique phrasing that someone who has lived in India is familiar with and can capture - kudos to the author. I read the ARC of this book, so hopefully a couple of references I mention here have been fixed in the published edition - “typhoon off the Bay of Bengal” in chapter 5 should be “cyclone off the Bay of Bengal” - cyclones are what they’re called in that part of the world. Also, in the Glossary section, besides the spiced tamarind water mentioned, Golgappas must include a mixture of potato, chickpeas, onions, cucumbers and spices, otherwise it’s not a golgappa! Overall, this book kept me highly entertained with its storyline, characters, and dialogue. It was lovely to hang out once again with the irreplaceable Vish Puri. This was a solid 3.5 read, rounded up to 4. Many thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

While I thank the publisher for this ARC, this book was painful to get through. I just couldn’t find the excitement to even read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Another fantastic book in this series ! I cannot get enough of Vish Puri's authentic Indian-ness and his trademark wit and charm. Looking forward to the next book in the series!

Was this review helpful?

Vish Puri, India’s Most Private Detective, has to travel from his home in New Delhi to London to collect the International Detective of the Year award. He has promised his wife that their trip to London will be strictly a vacation, but a government official forces him to accept a mission. Puri has to track down the Bombay Duck, who has defrauded (and killed) people with a pharmaceutical scam. And he has to do this without his wife and mother catching on that he is working.

I rarely read cozy mysteries, but I’ve enjoyed this series. Puri and his family members are all extremely likable, the books have humor, the plots are interesting and they proceed at a fast pace (They really have to since the books are short.). In this case, the search for the Bombay Duck turns into a different sort of investigation with a twist. There is also a side plot that didn’t really interest me.

I listened to the audiobook. The narrator was excellent. He even did a good job with the female voices. However, the audiobook does not include the Glossary of terms used in the book. So if you want to know the meaning of such terms as “Bombay Duck”, “Achaar”, and “Goonda”, you need to get another book format.

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love these mysteries and this latest was no exception! This was an especially satisfying mystery since it took place in both India and the UK. The new character of Puri's young nephew was a wonderful addition to the amazing cast of recurring characters. I love how the author always weaves in real social problems. I would highly recommend this to all readers off cozy mysteries.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

It's been a long wait for this latest installment of the adventures of private investigator Vish Puri. I have missed the humor, the food, and the insider's look into life in India so much that I couldn't wait to get my hands on The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck. I'm thrilled to say that the chubby private investigator's London experiences do not disappoint.

There is plenty of humor to be found in Puri's trip to London. He finds that the food is not up to his high standards, although he might make an exception for Harrods Food Hall. He's also not a fan of London's DYI (Do It Yourself) culture; he likes having things done for him wherever possible. With the help of his employees in New Delhi, Puri soon finds clues to the wanted man's whereabouts, and his detective work just manages to fly beneath the radar of his wife and mother because they have a "case" of their own.

As much as I enjoy the mystery and the humor, I love Hall's insights into Indian culture, and this time it's Indian culture transported to England. If you're an armchair sleuthing foodie who likes strong mysteries filled with humor and the appreciation of other cultures, you will love Tarquin Hall's Vish Puri mysteries. Although it's not necessary to begin with the first book, don't be surprised if you read The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck and find yourself looking for all the others in this entertaining series.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars. I want to thank Netgalley and the publisher for the digital ARC for The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck by Taquin Hall. I had enjoyed all the earlier books featuring Private Detective Vish Puri, based in New Delhi. These books were cozy character-based mysteries, and filled with humour.

This book was more complex, with investigations in India and London, and numerous characters to follow in both locations. It lacked the laugh-out-loud humour in the previous books. I was pleased to follow the new adventures of Puri, his wife Rumpi, and his delightful, forthright, and interfering mother, Mummy-ji, an unofficial skilled detective.

When Puri learns that the International Federation of Detectives has chosen him as Private Detective of the Year, he is proud and thrilled to attend the award ceremony in London. He plans to stay in London for a week and take his wife on a sightseeing holiday. His mother has arranged to accompany them, although uninvited.

A prominent Indian official, on learning of his upcoming London visit, orders him to look for a pharmaceutical manager wanted for deaths, and fraud for a diabetes medication. He is nicknamed the Bombay Duck, and is believed to have fled to England and is hiding in London. Scotland Yard has been unsuccessful in locating him.
Puri promised his wife he would not work on the trip and kept the assignment secret from his wife and mother. He tries to juggle the assignment with sightseeing. Fortunately, he has assistants in both countries. Puri relies on his intuition and reasoning; his helpers have technical skills. Since he lacks the time, he enlists his nephew, Jags, to investigate in London. Jags is a street-smart, clever young man, and a first generation Londoner. He is initially reluctant to help, but soon shows promising detective skills.

The case involving the elusive Bombay Duck becomes increasingly difficult. It included murders by poison using ingredients from India, disguises and possible involvement of Bombay Duck's wife in India.. Puri consults with an old friend in Scotland Yard. Suspects are trying to find and kill the fugitive. Both Scotland Yard and Puri are conflicted about the guilty party. The investigation becomes more complicated by cultural differences and misunderstandings. Can Puri and associates find the Bombay Duck?
Mummy-ji learns that a maid from India is being mistreated and locked in her room when she is not being overworked. The maid is denied the promised salary and benefits. Mummy-ji is anxious to help her.

Recommended for readers who enjoy complex mysteries. Fans of Detective Puri, his friends and relatives, will be pleased to follow their newest adventures. Publication is set for March 04/ 2025.

Was this review helpful?

I feel that the world has moved on from middle class westerners writing in the voice of other peoples. There is so much great literature including cosy crime available in translation that reading a British writer's humorous takes on someone else's culture feels I'm afraid a bit racist. I didn't get far in this book, and I'm sure at the end Vish Puri comes out on top, but I would rather read something more authentic.

Was this review helpful?

A light and amusing addition to the series that sees Vish Puri, our intrepid Indian detective, in London to receive an award, Oh and he's got to find the Bombay Duck, a criminally unscrupulous businessman who has fled India to avoid his debts and prosecution. Puri''s family, especially his mother, is critical to the tale as they are his team. There's nothing too twisty, the characters work, and it might well make you smile. Thanks to netgalley for the ARC. A good read.

Was this review helpful?

I been a fan of Tarquin Hall's most very private detective since the first book.
Hishave latest is just as delightful and just as fun as his previous books. However, there was nothing new in the characters. His operatives are still one dimensional, his Mummy still nosey and his poor neglected wife still forgotten and dismissed.
Although I liked the book and clever plot, I think I wanted more growth and development of the characters.

Was this review helpful?

The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck by Tarquin Hall is my first book by this author and did enjoy it. You don’t have to read the previous books. This series to get into this one. Here we have our Indian detective Vish based on New Delhi. People think of him as Indian Hercule Poirot. When something interesting happens in Vish’s professional life he gets asked to nab one of Indian’s most wanted fugitive. We have some enjoyable side characters including his meddling mother, his nephew that helps him the case and his wife that doesn’t want him to work on their long waited trip. This was enjoyable story abs I will continue this series.

Thanks to NetGalley and Severn House for the eARC. These thoughts are my own!

Was this review helpful?

This sweetly funny story of the world’s greatest detective, Delhi based Vish Puri, is so charming you will be completely drawn into his family and work life. As the book opens, he’s just been named “International Detective of the Year.” Unfortunately, the “secret” news has leaked out, and his office is deluged with congratulatory phone calls and sweets. Even worse, his mother calls and lets him know she’ll be accompanying he and his wife to London when they go for the award ceremony.

It comes with other minuses as well – an unwelcome associate has pledged to attend the ceremony, and Puri is summoned by a high up bureaucrat and instructed to find a notorious missing businessman who has fled to London with his millions, leaving in his wake victims of a medication that caused deaths rather than a cure. It seems like a lot to pile on, and what’s more, he’s instructed to investigate without the knowledge of the diplomats in London.

It’s with this on his mind that he boards the plane for London, his wife having to secretly drug him to overcome his fear of flying. When they land he’s irritated by the long line at customs and by the fact that he’ll apparently have to shlep his own luggage (a friend had warned him that the West is “DIY”). They arrive at a cousin’s where they are to stay and to Puri’s dismay, he discovers she’s not only vegan, she’s a terrible cook.

Puri, however, soldiers on and reaches out to an old friend at Scotland Yard to share information on the whereabouts of the missing man, dubbed by his friend the “Bombay Duck.” Puri also has operatives back in Delhi watching the wife, and they’re sure she’s planning to make a run for it. Meanwhile, Puri’s wife is delighted to be in London and wants to see all the sights there are to see. My favorite scene may have been high tea at the Savoy that Puri somehow ends up paying for the in the hopes of spotting his quarry.

As Puri works his investigation while also trying to accompany his wife when he can, he’s assisted in his task by his young cousin, who speaks and behaves like a Londoner but has some impressive tech skills and street smarts. Every character here is lovingly delineated – Hall obviously loves these people and if there were any kind of condescension on his part, it would have made the characters wooden on the page. Instead, they are fully alive, and while Puri can indeed be a bit ridiculous, he gets his man through some very smart investigating.

He’s also ably assisted by his mother who sees through him at every turn and is incredibly observant. Even his young cousin tells Puri to give her a break – she may irritate him (she’s his mother, after all) but she knows what she’s talking about. This concisely told tale was stuffed full of plot and wonderful characters. I didn’t mind starting with book six, but I now feel somewhat compelled to seek out the earlier books, with the worry that the delicious food described so vividly by Hall made me want to order up some Butter Chicken ASAP.

Was this review helpful?

I was a bit worried that I wouldn't enjoy this book, as I hadn't read the previous books in the series. Still, I am an avid mystery reader and thought I would give it a go.

This was a fun, enjoyable mystery with a colorful and entertaining cast of characters. It was a quick, delightful read and I would recommend it to anyone looking for a fun escapist mystery.

Was this review helpful?

3-3.5/5 Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC
I've enjoyed other books in this series in the past, and was happy to be able to read the newest instalment.
Vish Puri is getting a prestigious award and uses the occasion to take his wife and mother with him to London for an extended vacation.
Of course, it's not going to be simple, as he's enlisted by the Indian and British governements to help track down a dishonest billionaire with Indian connections who's currently in the UK.
There's lots of scenery streaming by the cab windows as Puri and his street-smart nephew try and track the bad guy, and some shenanigans with the team back in Delhi as well.
While I prefer the Indian adventures, this book is a must for Puri fans, and shows off London to good advantage.
Recommend for fans of cozy mysteries with an international flair.

Was this review helpful?

3.5

This is the first of Tarquin Hall's Vish Puri series that I've read (leaving me way behind everyone else I assume).

The story follows Puri as he heads to London, ostensibly to pick up a prestigious award but, as appears to be normal, taking on the case of Harilal Bhatt, a dodgy businessman who has - so far - eluded Scotland Yard. It's a wild ride with poisonings, chases and lots of disguises being the order coffee the day.

The character I really enjoyed was Puri's Mummy who, I gather, has just as much expertise in catching criminals as Puri himself. She's incredibly entertaining and far more forthright than Vish.

My scoring may seem a little mean but the writing felt a little unpolished to me and the dialogue somewhat clunky at times.

I did, however, enjoy the book and I'd suggest fans of Vaseem Khan or Richard Osman would also enjoy these books. I'll certainly read the previous ones in the series - for no other reason than to increase my enjoyment of Mummy.

Thankyou to Netgalley and Severn House for the advance review copy.

Was this review helpful?

Private detective Vish Puri travels to London to receive an award as the private detective of the year, with his wife Rumpi and his mother along for the ride. He receives a commission to undertake while there - to find an Indian pharmaceutical executive who has fled India to avoid prosecution. As he is carrying out the search in London, Rumpi and her mother-in-law undertake their own investigation into a family matter, and Puri's colleagues look into the missing executive's life back in India. An enjoyable read watching Puri carry out his investigation far from his usual setting. Thank you to Severn House and NetGalley for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?