Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I can only say Heather did it again!
I have loved this series with its quirky characters and fun as well as serious bits.
The relationship between Emily and Wendell is thrilling, loving and warm.
I loved the faery doors and folklore the story really sucks you in. Just sorry it had to end.
Also I loved the part the animal companions play. What can I say dogs, cats I'm hooked.
I also loved the conversations and banter throughout the whole series.
Can't wait to see what Heather does next.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

If you love light academia with a mix of humor, coziness, and adventure, the Emily Wilde series is an absolute must-read. Emily Wilde’s Compendium of Lost Tales is the third and final book in the series, and it wraps things up beautifully.

The world-building was incredible—so detailed and immersive. I’ll admit, it was a bit tricky to keep track of all the places Emily visited, but the descriptions were so vivid that I still felt completely transported. One of my favorite parts was seeing Wendell and Emily take back the kingdom while also figuring out their own wants and fears. Their communication wasn’t always the best, but they’re still one of my favorite book couples ever. I also loved the inclusion of Lilja and Margret, and of course, Poe making another appearance—he’s definitely a standout character.

Overall, this was such a magical read. Heather Fawcett has a real talent for crafting intricate, detailed worlds that feel so alive. It wasn’t quite a perfect read for me, but it came really close—solid 4 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Feburary 19th

as I write this I am with my fellow traveling companions on a rather bumpy ride but oh am I grateful for it is one, very warm here and two, I have just finished this series a mere hour ago. And what a delight it was!

Ever since stumbling about the first book I was enchanted with this world and especially with it‘s main characters and the form in which this series is written. As I have enjoyed the scientific lense of these books with it‘s constant footnotes referencing papers and talks in the field of dryadology, I was happy to find that this last book still revolved around this aspect of the world as well. I mean, venturing into Faerie is after all one big field study.

In this book we:
- get to know Wendells realm and deal with dangers and delights within
- meet old aquaintances! Some of the strands from the previous ends tie into this last one and we meet some of the characters and places again, which I was quite fond of
- still have a lot of the endearing banter of Emily and Wendell
- witness several changes of heart
- visit Trinity in Dublin
- spend time with one of the best literary dogs
- and with a vicious cat
- have a story about the truth in stories

Overall this was a good book and a neat end. I enjoyed most of it. I must say, a little less then book one and two, for I feel the neeer characters we were introduced to remained a bit shallow. But Emily‘s voice again was a favorite to read from!

So I close, stating that I would very much like to read more books approaching the Folk from an academic angle, and might go looking for them on this isle i have found myself on now!

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for an E-Arc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for providing me with the opportunity to read and review this prior to publication. The third instalment in the series draws things to a close, leaving Wendell and Emily in an unusual predicament. It felt slow at times, and the dramatic moments of the story fell a little flat as things were conveniently sorted out.
Having found their way back to Wendell’s kingdom it is now incumbent upon them to remove the threat to the throne and to try and restore the kingdom. Emily uses her scholarly research to help with key details, and we get the opportunity to see Wendell in what could best be described as his natural environment.
There’s the expected drama, but they always seem to manage to find a way to resolve issues before things become too awkward.

Was this review helpful?

FOR SOME REASON, REVIEW HAS BEEN DELETED!

Now that Emily has discovered the door into Wendell's kingdom, the two if them and their 'army' manage to put Wendell back on his faerie throne. However his stepmother is not done with them yet as she has left a curse behind. In order to life the curse, Emily and Wendell have to pool their talents - his faerie, Emily's research.
This is the third volume in a totally delightful series. It's not what I would normally read, I'm no fan of fantasy, magic, dark academia etc, but I picked up the first in the series due to its beautiful cover and I really loved it. The characters are still varying and interesting with Emily's mistakes and Wendell's apparent sunniness. The book bounces along and just ends up as a feel-good escape.

Was this review helpful?

I was lucky enough to receive the ARC for the first book in this series back in 2022, and I loved it so much that I didn't hesitate to request the third instalment when I saw it was available (I read the second book in my own time). Safe to say, I still adore this series!

In this book we see Emily and Wendell get established in his Faerie kingdom, watch Emily come to terms with being a scholar and now a faerie queen, and the couple deal with the looming threat of Wendall's step-mother, who is slowly poisoning the kingdom. The underlying danger throughout the book was gripping and 'that scene' nearly made me riot! The relationship between Emily and Wendell is still the sweetest (and at times funniest) thing, and we really get to see Wendall's final form as a loveable golden retriever-esque husband to Emily.

The only thing I found fault in was the final resolution at the end, which was a bit lacking and I expected a bit more of a fight from our BBEG.

Overall, 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

I ADORE this series so much, it has had my in a chokehold since book one and will continue to do so, I was a bit sad there seemed to be less of Wendell and Emily together in this one as I adore them together so much however the plot was well done, it had my heart strings firmly in it's grip, I was terrified of the ending but I'm happy with how everything wrapped up in the end!

Was this review helpful?

Emily Wilde

3.5⭐️

The final instalment in the trilogy and yet again it delivered all the cosy vibes. If you want whimsy Emily Wilde is for you, I think this is the most whimsy series I've ever read.

I love both Emily & Wendell and I love how much Wendell loves Emily and wants to do everything for her. He is the ultimate golden retriever boyfriend.

This book is definitely Emily's book and while I would have liked more Wendell, I totally get it for the story. A very fitting end of the series.

Was this review helpful?

Having eagerly followed Emily and Wendell's journey through the first two books, I was thrilled to dive into Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales. This third installment not only met but exceeded my expectations, delivering a satisfying and enchanting conclusion to the series.

In this adventure, Emily, now embracing her role as both a scholar and the fiancée of King Wendell, ventures into the heart of Faerie. Their mission to reclaim Wendell's throne is fraught with danger, especially with the looming threat of his malevolent stepmother's curse. Emily's unwavering dedication to her research and her evolving relationship with Wendell are beautifully portrayed, adding depth to her character and their bond.

Heather Fawcett's writing continues to captivate, blending academic intrigue with magical storytelling. The inclusion of scholarly footnotes and journal-style narration immerses readers in Emily's meticulous yet adventurous mind. The world-building is rich and vivid, making the realm of Faerie both enchanting and perilous.

What stood out to me was the balance between the overarching plot and the development of side characters. Reuniting with familiar faces and meeting new ones added layers to the narrative, creating a tapestry of interconnected stories that culminate in a heartfelt conclusion.

Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales is a testament to the power of storytelling, love, and resilience. It's a journey I was reluctant to see end, but the conclusion is both fitting and satisfying. For those who cherish tales of magic intertwined with scholarly pursuits and heartfelt relationships, this series is an absolute gem.

Was this review helpful?

as always a delightful time bringing much warmth to my heart in dark times. found the pace in this one very odd and at times not great, but pace was never the strongest quality of these books so it's fine. heather fawcett flexed her faerie muscles in this one with the kingdom's worldbuilding and i did enjoy the "flip" side of emily's usual human-looking-for-faerie narration as she is in faerie this time, even if i liked the construction of the narrative better in book 1 and 2. LOVED the side characters in this as always, i kind of need the homosexual spinoff... heather fawcett if you're reading this...... but yeah a fun time. not my favorite of the trilogy but a lovely conclusion and as always a beautiful love story. emily wilde you're an icon

Was this review helpful?

Told in the same journalistic/diary style as the first two books, the third (and possibly last) Emily Wilde novel more lives up to its predecessors. With more footnotes, more research and devious Faerie lore, more tea, and more romance, it’s easy to see how this was one of my most anticipated releases for 2025.
As always, i was completely blown away by how Heather Fawcett simultaneously crafts a cozy story, and the unsettling darkness of the Faerie world. Her interpretation of the meaning of Faeries is one of my favourite, for as much as i love the more recent Fae, the weird, dangerous, and terrifying folklore-based Faeries win every time for me.
Anyway, i was so happy to be back with Emily and Wendell. They’re one of my comfort couples, truly because they themselves are comforting, and also because they have that sweetness and connection to their relationship i find in many of my favourites. However different they may be from one another, i adore just how much they put each other first, and the little sweet things they (particularly Wendell) do for each other. Every time Wendell called Emily his dragon, or even just Em, i couldn’t hold myself back from smiling at the pages.
He truly reached a new level of adoration for her this book, and the letters he wrote were beyond adorable!
Emily was just as fierce as ever (if not more so). I love how she found a balance between life in Wendell’s court and her research and scholarly pursuits, without needing to give either of them up. She also may not have been as loud as Wendell with her shows of affection, but through her words you truly see just how much she cares for him. I adore them.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so much fun! I already loved the first two in the series so much, so I was so excited to get to read this one. I love how we follow Emily and Wendell into farie once more. The relationship between the two was so well deweloped and I loved to see more of them.

Was this review helpful?

An adorable but satisfying conclusion to the series.

Emily and Wendell are in full on love this time around and Wendell is a man who uses Acts of Service as a love language. He takes on all those little jobs and tasks that just make Emily's life easier. Would it have been even better with a bit more adventure? Yes. But it was well paced and the romance pace was in keeping with the story.

The portal system, collecting all the legends & stories was a great way to weave in some suspense and tie all of their adventures together. There are some old friends popping up here and there and the humour is gentle, not over the top and raucous.

My favourite line is when Wendell just states "Mine". (swooooon)

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars. Charming as ever, Emily Wild returns in the third (and final?) installment of the Heaher Fawcett's series about the researcher of Faeries. This time we spend more time in Faerie than ever before, but also have the least romance and stakes compared to the previous books in the series. I appreciated the cameos of characters we got to know throughout the series. No surprises on the plot or the writing, but in this reality Emily Wilde is the exact book we need to excape reality (or the hell of academia).

Was this review helpful?

Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales by Heather Fawcett is the perfect ending to this amazing cozy fantasy full of fae mythology and academic footnotes. We follow Emily and Wendell relationship in their wild adventures on the cusp of returning to Wendell’s kingdom to restore order after the murder of their former queen.

I absolutely loved the way the realm was described and Emily's scholarly knowledge of faerie tales used to save both her fiancé and the kingdom. However, i think Wendell & Emily’s relationship was lacking a bit of depth, but it was still well portrait throughout the book. The book was a bit darker than the previous ones which was quite good and the tone used by the author was great to setting the pace and the stage for the resolution of the story.

Overall, it was a great way to finish Emily's journey, it was sweet and cozy and while i wish a bit more depth to the story i really enjoyed this trilogy and this was a fantastic read and i'll forever be a fan of Emily's footnotes.

Was this review helpful?

honestly, the perfect way to end the trilogy, and I couldn't fault it. Do I wish there was more backstory in places? Yes. But I don't think it detracted from the story or the ending. Such a whimsical trilogy from start to finish!

Was this review helpful?

Ah, how lovely it is to return to Emily Wilde and her wild adventures with her fae fiancé, who also happens to be the monarch of his long-lost kingdom. After their previous trials & tribulations, Emily and Wendell are finally on the cusp of returning to Wendell’s kingdom to restore order following the murder of the former queen. But of course, things are not easy going as they discover that report of the queen’s death has been grossly exaggerated. And so Emily may need to wield (ha) her scholarly knowledge of faerie tales once more to save her fiancé and the kingdom.

Without spoiling the rest of the story, I have to say that this was the perfect ending to this cozy fantasy with fae mythology & scholarly footnotes (lots of them!). There are new Folk myths and misadventures where things come full circle towards the denouement of the trilogy. There is plenty of snarky humor & banter that made me fall in love with the series in the first place. There is (finally) enough time for Em & Wendell to be happy with one another!

This wasn’t perfect, of course. I wanted more backstory for the oíche sidhe Folk, especially since a side character introduced in this hinted at something more re: their mythology (alas, that is the Wilde curiosity in me speaking). And yes, there were convenient plot points which meant that ultimately this felt more low-stakes compared to the first book, but after everything Em & Wendell had to go through? I welcome the happy ending, frankly.

Was this review helpful?

Heather Fawcett comes back with the most romantic and faerie world-centered book! At first, it felt like reading a totally different story. I was missing the research aspect and chaotic scholar Emily. However, it was done with a point. Emily had to find herself in this new situation and stop acting like someone else. I really enjoyed what came after – the faerie court problems, secrets and all the stories!
However, sometimes the information they acquired seemed too convenient for the characters to appear so suddenly.
I couldn’t help falling even more in love with Emily and Wendell. Find yourself a partner who is so in love with you, that he sends you dramatic love letters full of yearning when you leave for a research trip.
I just want to say that Shadow deserves all the best.

Thanks to the publisher, author and NetGalley for sharing this book with me in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A warm thank you to Little, Brown Book Group, Orbit Books, and NetGalley for providing me with an Advanced Reader Copy of this book for an honest review.

Our cozy series comes to an end with one final journey, complete with smatterings of whimsy and light academia. Emily and Wendell are as endearing as ever in their final quest on our pages! They work unravel the former faerie queen’s plots to save Wendell’s kingdom from a polluting sickness.

While the stakes are comparatively much higher in this novel’s plot, unfortunately it felt a little shallower and haltingly paced when compared with the previous two books. I do wish there had been greater time and depth lent to exploration of Emily and Wendell’s relationship which, but for the occasional kiss, seemed to have developed little beyond their collegial friendship in “Encyclopaedia of Faeries”. Tension in the plot was also low, with Emily’s unwavering brilliance meaning that a trip to the library is the only diversion required to unravel a complication.

All this said, I have loved these characters, the setting, and Heather Fawcett’s brilliant writing! It’s sad to see this series come to an end, but I can’t wait to see what Fawcett will feed us with next!

Was this review helpful?

Thankyou to Netgalley and Heather Fawcett for the opportunity to read this in exchange for my honest review.

I am sadly unable to give feedback as the file did not work so I was unable to read or download a copy.

Was this review helpful?