What a brilliant read. Dare I say... magnificent!

The story begins with Yana, a young girl betrayed by her own family and exiled. This act of treachery becomes pivotal to the events that unfold later in the story. Fast forward 24 years: the Emperor is preparing to step down, and eight contenders, each representing one of the eight 'Guardians', are set to compete for the throne. We are then introduced to Neema, a High Scholar who is tasked with solving the murder of one of the contenders. She is unexpectedly appointed as a contender herself, taking the place of the deceased. As Neema digs deeper into the mystery, she discovers that the Empire itself is far from what it appears to be.

The writing is distinctive and sophisticated, yet remarkably easy to follow. The world-building is intricately detailed, drawing you into a richly imagined universe. The plot masterfully blends politics, treason, mystery, banter, a touch of romance... and plot twists. So many twists, in fact, that I found myself formulating endless theories, only for the story to constantly defy my expectations.

The characters are superbly crafted, each morally grey with dubious moments that are essential to the plot’s progression. I was on edge throughout, unsure whether to trust the characters or brace for betrayal. The non-human characters added much-needed humour, breaking the tension that builds relentlessly as the story unfolds.

The ending provides the perfect opening for a sequel, and I am eagerly anticipating the next instalment!

There are few thrills as a reader like picking up a book and knowing from the very first page that you’re going to love a book. I requested The Raven Scholar on a whim and oh my god it was the best decision I made in 2024. This book was incredible, it’s easily going to be one of the best fantasy books of 2025. I cannot stress enough just how much you want to have your eye on this one.

It is quite hard to talk about this one in a spoiler free way, so I’ll forgive you if you choose to skip the rest of this review and go in blind. But to give you a very quick plot rundown: the story opens with an exile (this will, of course, come back to haunt us). We then cut to years later, when it’s time for the emperor to step down. Seven factions put forth a candidate to take the throne and these candidates must go up against each other in duels, and challenges. Our main character, Neema, is not originally one of those candidates but, the day before the contest is meant to start, the Raven candidate is murdered, leaving her no choice but to take on the role herself. Oh, and investigate the murder.

This is a 650+ page book and not for one moment did it feel too long. In fact, if anything, it felt way too short. I wanted it to go on forever and I cannot fathom how I’m going to survive until the sequel is released. I couldn’t put this one down (not even at work, but don’t tell my boss). There are many reasons for it, but I think it’s mostly about how compelling the narrative was. The balancing act of murder investigation and contest to win the throne was perfectly done, and the truths as they were revealed drip-fed you right up to the end (I’m still not convinced a certain character is dead, though). And, oh my god, the ending. This is a book which felt like multiple books in a series in one.

And then we have to talk about the character who haunts the narrative. This character is barely in the book, all things considering, but so much of what happens later comes back to them. So much of what’s yet to happen also comes back to them. They are unavoidably, inextricably entwined with the narrative. Even when you might not immediately see the significance of elements, it all comes back to them. Maybe once this book is out I can speak in less vague terms but, oh, oh, it’s so good. So, so, good.

I don’t know how much more I can say about this one. The summary might sound a bit generic, but the book is anything but. This is a book that puts you in a chokehold and just does not let up. I was hooked from the first chapter, but definitively from the end of the first part. I defy you not to see the same happen to you.

If, then, there is any 2025 fantasy release you put on your radar, it should be this one. It’s one of the freshest, most compelling reads of the year, and one not to be missed.

Antonia Hodgson’s The Raven Scholar is an intricately plotted historical mystery steeped in gothic charm and intellectual intrigue. Set in 18th-century England, the novel follows an unlikely scholar-turned-detective as they unravel a series of cryptic murders tied to ancient texts and secret societies.

Hodgson’s attention to historical detail is impeccable, and her sharp, evocative prose brings both the gritty streets of London and the shadowy halls of academia vividly to life. The protagonist’s wit and intellect are matched by a gripping, twist-filled plot that keeps readers guessing until the very end.

Fans of historical mysteries with a literary edge will find The Raven Scholar an utterly captivating read, full of suspense, dark secrets, and richly drawn characters.

Wow. Talk about hooked. Talk about being completely immersed and absorbed into the story that 600 odd pages felt like 50! I’d give this book 10 stars if it would allow.

Sometimes new fantasy worlds like these (especially those on the chonkier side) can take a while to get to grips with and I normally start to enjoy about 100 pages in - but not with this one, it was immediate page one hook! It was instant complete immersion.

I loved the whole premise of the plot and the world it was set in. Stellar world building, great characters and easy investment into the characters and the story. Couldn’t have asked for more. The writing, the twists and turns were absolutely astounding and found myself eager to see what would happen next.

I can’t remember the last time I was so wholly consumed by a book. This is one of the first books I’ve read this year and I’m already thinking that I honestly don’t think anything else I read this year can top this. The wait for book two will be a killer!

This is an excellent fantasy novel. It begins with a prologue about Yana, a young girl exiled by her brother and the emperor. This event is pivotal to the rest of the book although you do not know why or how for some time. Moving forwards in time, it is 24 years since the current Emperor took the throne and it is time for him to step down, 8 contenders, representing the 8 ‘guardians’ will compete for the throne, Amongst this, Neema, the High Scholar and a lonely girl, must make her way. Things start to go wrong when one of the contenders is found dead with a legendary knife in her back.

The story is full of twists and revelations which are clever and unexpected. There is strong character development, magical interventions and a low key romance. The book feels complete but is set up ready for the second of three instalments which I can’t wait to read (although I must). This is the best fantasy novel I’ve read in a while and I highly recommend it. Thanks to Netgalley for an ARC.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Truly magnificent read!

The story follows an intelligent young woman, Neema. A commoner who was best in class, and fought hard for her position in court. Faithless, among the faithful, Neema finds herself caught up in a murder, in a competition to be a ruler, in a fight against her own perception. Neema could rule, Neema could doom the people of world, but I won’t spoil - you simply must read it. A woman who never fits in, a woman without friends, a woman who just wants to be accepted.. Such a marvellous journey through a beautiful world!

Strong female character ✅
Politics ✅
Fantasy ✅
Plot twists ✅
Amazing characters ✅
Laugh out loud moments ✅
Tears ✅

I have a feeling I will still be thinking about this book next year. Truly wonderful read.

This book had me hooked from the start! The pace of the book is a bit slower than I personally like but I think that’s due to the volume of YA I have read of late. The depth of the plot, the twists, the world building - more than compensated for this which is why I read this in two sittings.

The religious system reminded me of the Chinese zodiac in a way though it’s not necessarily what you are born under that defines you. I absolutely adored how this was done but don’t want to write too much here for fear of spoiling. I will say, I want my own solitary raven as a companion - there would never be a dull moment!

The characters were superbly written. I could resonate with elements of them all and there’s a couple that simply stole my heart: Cain, Sha, Tala, Fenn, Benna. Even those you weren’t meant to love had elements of endearment to them with their growth (Ruko especially quickly).

The world building was beautiful, I could easily paint the scenes in my mind. The plot itself was brilliantly done and I cannot wait for the second book.

Finally - Bran - I wish to know more in the acknowledgements of book 2 or your socials :)

When I started to read this book it seemed like a hunger games copy. After a few chapters when the scene was set it took off. Neema against the world and would Cain be her sole mate once again or a disappointment. Fast paced after the beginning though the ending has left it open for a sequel…..

The Raven Scholar is a strong build with its lore and mood.
If you enjoy longer books where spend enough time to grasp the world, this one is perfect for you.
It was almost a 5 star read in my experience, and I can see why it is so widely-acclaimed and liked. It deserves the hype.
As for the story, which I should have first mentioned, we have a Raven Scholar called Neema in the fictional Orrun (perhaps this is why I haven’t started with the story - I appreciated a fresh fictional world, and its being novel can be exciting for the next reader). Something happens. and Neem has to take the matters to her own hand, while fighting inner and external demons. Most of the characters are flawed (+), moreover, the diverse representation won my heart. Not all characters were likeable or made full sense. As for the prose, it was 4.5 stars, mostly a hit, and the plot, sometimes a little slow, but with mostly interesting and well done twists, was 4 stars.
Overall, an engaging read.

Quite a challenging read, but engrossing and entertaining, we have part magic realism, part romance, part mystery and a whole lot of suspense. This is a terrific fantasy power struggle with shape shifting and animal magic. We follow the raven scholar, who is caught up in the struggle against her wishes, as she is more dedicated to books and calligraphy than a taste for competition. She has had a romance go wrong, and has had to do things she would not wish to. There is a large cast of characters and this can be very confusing, but despite this there is a lot of humour and humanity. I really enjoyed reading this, although it’s quite long, but kept me gripped.

4.5 ✨️

A huge thank you to the publisher for access to this ARC.

I really enjoyed this. There were so many layers to the plot - I found I never knew which direction it was going to go in and some of the scenes were nothing short of brutal!

Sol was a fantastic character. When they were first introduced, I wasn't sure at all. But, who knew you could laugh so much at the dialogue from a Raven fragment? Such a unique concept.

The ending is perfectly set up for another book so roll on book 2!

I couldn't bring myself to read all of this book. How Yana was treated was too cruel and the family betrayal? Not for me.

Yes it's well written and others with more appetite for an emotionally challenging fantasy read with twists may love it. I didn't. Sorry.

How many ways can I say how much I loved this book? The story grips you right from the start and doesn't let go until the very end. It has a real flavour of a Game of Thrones but with an other-wordly fantasy element to it. There is a sense of danger right from the start when the young twins Yanara and Ruko come before the emperor who years ago defeated their father in a rebellion. Their fates are determined at the foot of the throne with a shocking betrayal from Ruko who condemns his sister to death to secure his place as heir. Yanara, though, holds sway over the story and continues to influence the characters even though she is dead. We skip forward in time another 8 years to meet Neema and Cain, and to see what has become of Ruko who all enter a series of trials to determine who will be the next Emperor. Each one is allied to one of the 8 mythic animal guardians - Neema to the Raven, Cain to the Fox and Ruko to the Tiger. What lifts this story up the most is the quality of the characterisations - you care about each and every one of them and each one has hidden depths that you uncover. You want them all to succeed and for Ruko to redeem himself. Unfortunately you have to wait impatiently for part 2 to be written to find out what happens next! This was an excellent start to a really original and exciting series and I cannot wait to read the next installment!

Let me start bt saying this book is fantastic. It is a long book but the story really immersed me in the world. The world building is great, the characters are varied, the story has lots of twists and turns. I really loved this book.

It has been a while since I read a high fantasy book/series that is focused on political intrigue, treason, murder, trials for succession to the throne and drama. There is a slight element of romance but it fits in well without being the main of the book. I found that really refreshing.

While it took me a little while to warm to Neema because she was almost arrogant at first, but she really developed and as I learned more about her I really like her character arc. In fact, all the character arcs were well written with depth, flaws and relatability.

The twists in the story were excellent. Some of them I guessed but others really had me at the reveals! I will be thinking about this book for a long time.

I loved the writing style, it was easy to read and the perfect balance of action, mystery and humour.

There is so much more I want to say but don't want to give spoilers!

Overall a 5 star read with a lot of potential to be a fantastic high fantasy series. I highly recommend this book!

This has all the makings of a great new fantasy world, but there are some kink- there were a lot of words, the plot chaotic and the pacing was off in places. I didn’t feel drawn to any of the characters. Nevertheless, there are many quality elements and I’m interested to see how the story continues. Many thanks to NetGalley for an arc of this book.

Wow what a book! It's complicated but worth sticking with. The world-building is sophisticated and sometimes a little confusing. But the characters are great - funny and interesting. Will DEFINTELY be buying the sequel.

A huge thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and Antonia Hodgson for providing me with an ARC of The Raven Scholar in exchange for my honest review.

The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson is a magnificent epic fantasy brimming with political intrigue, battles, magic, friendship, and love. It is truly one of the best epic fantasy books I’ve read in a long time, with writing that is nothing short of exquisite.

While the story predominantly follows the perspective of High Scholar Neema Kraa, the inclusion of multiple other points of view enriches the narrative and adds depth to the world. Hodgson’s characters are so well-crafted that calling them “side characters” feels reductive; every individual has a clear purpose in the grand scheme of the story. For example, Cain, the Fox Contender, is a standout—a hilarious, charming, and lovable rogue who brings levity and charisma to the tale.

This book is a hefty tome, but there is remarkably little filler. Each chapter serves a purpose, propelling the narrative toward its gripping conclusion. It’s rare to find a book with so many twists and turns that genuinely surprise me, but this story delivered them in abundance. I found myself constantly guessing and being delighted by the unexpected.

In short, The Raven Scholar is a masterclass in epic fantasy storytelling, and I am eagerly anticipating the sequel!

I loved this book once I got into it, but did find it hard going at the start to become immersed in the fantasy world Antionia Hodgson has created. I'mlooking forward ot the next two books in the series.

For a 700 page book, I wish this had went on longer - it was such an enjoyable read, every moment of it.

There's so many little twists and turns, and the main plot from the synopsis doesn't even start until a quarter in and there was so much to get there, the less I say, the better. But I will say:
If you like political twists!
If you like ridiculously good, complex characters!
If you like great, nuanced writing, with some well-placed touches of humour!
If you like incredible worldbuilding, especially for mythology!
If you like talking kind-of-animals!
Did I mention the characters?
And if you like having your heart torn out nearly immediately!

Then this book is for you.

Thank you to the publisher, Hodderscape, and to NetGalley for the ARC.

The Raven Scholar is an intensely gripping fantasy full of twists, political intrigue and a murder mystery. The world building is incredible and the writing style was distinct, drawing me in from the first page.

At first I was put off by the length of the book - far too often recently I've found stories that are painfully long with lots of unnecessary and boring content. However, that wasn't the case here - every word was important and actually when I was done, I wished it were longer.

Everything about this book is exceptional, and I intend to persuade everybody around me to pick it up!

I received a copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review

"The Raven Scholar" is a masterclass in epic fantasy, weaving a gripping tale of political intrigue, cutthroat competition, and imperial deceit. Set in the sweltering summer heat of Orrun, the story pits eight exceptional contenders—each representing a sacred animal—in a deadly trial to claim the emperor’s throne. But when one contender is murdered, the competition spirals into chaos, and the brilliant yet eccentric Neema Kraa is thrust into a high-stakes investigation that could determine the fate of the empire.

Hodgson’s storytelling is as sharp as the trials the characters endure. The lush worldbuilding breathes life into the empire of Orrun, from its rival monasteries to the complex hierarchy of power. The contenders are richly drawn, with their skills, personalities, and rivalries making for a cast as dynamic as they are dangerous. Neema Kraa is a standout protagonist—quick-witted, flawed, and utterly compelling as she navigates a maze of secrets, betrayal, and ambition.

What makes "The Raven Scholar" truly refreshing is its unflinching focus on the political and philosophical stakes, eschewing romantic subplots for a narrative bursting with tension, humor, and heartbreak. The twists are unpredictable, the stakes immense, and the story’s emotional core—centered on ambition, loyalty, and the price of power—resonates deeply.

At 700 pages, this sweeping epic flies by, each chapter leaving readers hungry for more. For fans of intricate worldbuilding, razor-sharp intrigue, and brutal competition, "The Raven Scholar" is an absolute triumph that redefines the adult fantasy genre.