I ended up not finishing this book. It was an interesting premise and plot, but the writing was so simplistic and uninteresting that I just couldn't drag myself through it. Think this may be a translation issue, rather than a book issue.

City of Fiction is an engrossing saga following Lin Xiangfu through his emotionally tumultuous relationship with Xiaomei and his quest to find her after she abandons him and their infant daughter. The novel is sprawling and encompasses the lives of a myriad of exciting and likeable characters. At times violent and tragic, this is a powerful and moving tale and the conclusion is truly poignant, it truly left me reeling. I couldn't put this down and only wish I had picked it up sooner!

An epic tale set in early 20th-century China at a time of momentous change, Yu Hua’s City of Fiction, translated into English by Todd Foley (thank you @europaeditionsuk via @netgalley for a review copy), is almost a novel and novella in one. Telling the story of Lin Xiangfu, a talented and wealthy carpenter from the north of China whose parents both pass away when he is young, City of Fiction follows his journey to find the woman who gave birth to his daughter and abandoned them. Arriving on his doorstep under the pretence of travelling to Beijing with a man who claims to be her brother, Xiaomei captures Lin Xiangfu’s interest. When her brother leaves to continue their journey, she stays behind. Lin Xiangfu and Xiaomei settle into a routine and, disregarding the customs of the time, get married and have a child. Shortly after, Xiaomei leaves without a word. Devastated, Lin Xiangfu is committed to journeying south to Xiaomei’s hometown only to discover that the city she claimed to be from doesn’t exist. Settling instead in a city where the accent reminds him of Xiaomei, he makes a new life and home for himself and his daughter. Due to the societal and cultural upheavals of the time, life is difficult and full of danger. Whether it was Yu Hua’s stylistic choice or the way his writing has been translated, the story felt devoid of emotion. Truly harrowing experiences, such as the numerous forms of torture that exist/ed and are enacted on the characters, are told in a detached manner which equally frustrated and horrified me. I also felt at a remove from Lin Xiangfu and the emotional journey he must have gone through. The story felt more like a list of everything that happened and we never really get underneath this to find out the characters’ thoughts and feelings. Even when the story switches to Xiaomei’s point of view about 70% into the novel (what I called earlier the ‘novella’), I didn’t feel like it added very much because I could already guess what Xiaomei’s life was like and the reasons behind her actions. I know Yu Hua is a celebrated author and I would very much like to give another of his books a go, I just don’t think City of Fiction was for me.

Unexpectedly epic yet also personal, this book combined historical fiction, adventure story, family and a slightly dystopian element really well.
A story that started off as quite a personal family story, then switched to rather gruesome descriptions of kidnappings, torture, banditry and fighting, and then ended once again as the story of a young girl with a sad fate, offering an explanation for all that happens in the first part of the book.

A haunting literary experience, following the lives of a group of people brought together by random events in early 20th century China. At one level, the story follows a young man who meets a young woman, has a baby daughter with her only to see the woman disappear. The story then follows this young man's travels to try and find and her, before settling in a remote town (which he believes is where the woman is from). On this level, this is a slice-of-life bitter-sweet love story, which allows the novel to talk about family values, life in rural China, the beauty and horror of tradition, etc. On another level, the story of our protagonists also shows the brutality of life in China in those years, against the background of the social and political upheavals that ravaged the countryside, and caused innumerable deaths and suffering.

I really liked the book, and I especially appreciated the style. I'm not totally sure whether it was the translator or the original text, but it left an impression. The style itself is rather dry and somewhat telegraphic - there isn't much description or flowery prose. This style, however, contributes directly to the experience - the haunting nature of the text is amplified due to the dry delivery, which leaves the richness (and horror) of some events to itself, not requiring a lot of narration. It activates the imagination and creates an immersive experience that really affected me.

I also learned a lot from the book - being angry at times, frustrated at others, and moved at yet others. The author seems to want to convey what lives of simple people felt like in those years, without defaulting to tropes that other authors often employ to over-dramatise the situation.

I think I also need some more time to digest the feelings that echo in me as a result of this book. This, in itself, is a sign of its greatness.

My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an early copy of this book in return for an honest review.

I loved the beginning of this book, and I loved the ending. The writing in both of these parts pulled me in and made me think this could be a five star read.
The only problem for me was the middle section. The whole book was slow paced, which I don't have an issue with, but I found myself getting lost in the middle of this.

Overall though, the writing was beautiful, the setting compelling and I enjoyed the begging and end so much that it was well worth the read.

Yu Hua's "Cuty of Fiction" takes place in early twentieth century China, and it's a novel about reinvention in a new century. A new China and a new way of creating yourself in this new China. We have two competing stories in this narrative. Lin Xiangfu seeks to find his wife who has disappeared. He meets Xiaomei and the other part of the novel follows Xiaomei's story.

Yu Hua's writing is gorgeous and evocative, and it underscores the fragmentation that these characters face in this new China. Yu Hua still highlights the humanity. It's a beautiful and devastating novel. Highly recommend,

Set against the turbulent backdrop of societal upheaval in the early 20th-century China, City of Fiction (forthcoming Apr 2025) by Yu Hua and artfully translated by Todd Foley, intertwines themes of love, loss, transformation, and the clash between the traditional and modern worlds. It’s a translation of Wencheng, Yu’s 2021 novel.

The story follows Lin Xiangfu, a quiet man from the north who sets out on an arduous journey southward. With his newborn, he sets out in search of Xiaomei, his wife and the child's mother, who has inexplicably disappeared. The novel is divided into distinct parts, with one part focusing on Lin and his early encounter with Xiaomei, followed by the story of his journey and the other part following Xiaomei’s story. Some events occur concurrently. It started out slow, but got emotional and even brutal.

Despite a rather complex narrative, the novel remains deeply human; a mesmerising, thought-provoking read that reveals character misery and challenges the boundaries between fiction and reality. What does the titular city refer to? It’s a mysterious city, maybe even fictitious. The story of Lin and Xiaomei comes together (or falls apart?) eventually.

Yu’s prose is both poetic and evocative, painting a world that is at once familiar and foreign. The descriptions of the dying crafts and vanishing customs in a rapidly modernising China serve as a powerful metaphor for the characters’ own transformations.

This is a heartbreaking, extraordinary novel that is gripping despite its slow pace. I love the relationships between the characters, who are so in depth and evoke strong emotions from you. Parts of this book were very difficult to read but I enjoyed the journey. I will be recommending this book to others.

City of fiction is less fictional than one might think. Yu Hua takes us one a journey between traditions and the new world. Change that can happen gradually, but for some it feels like the world they know crumbles before them at an excruciating fast pace. This story is gripping and gives so much to think about, the characters are well written and the story is easy to follow.
I hope to read more from this author in the future.

Yu Hua’s *City of Fiction* is a mesmerizing novel that showcases his signature blend of vivid storytelling and deep philosophical insight. Through rich prose and a dynamic narrative, the book explores themes of fate, identity, and the power of storytelling itself. Set against a backdrop of societal change, Yu Hua crafts an immersive world filled with intriguing characters and unexpected turns. With its thought-provoking structure and lyrical style, *City of Fiction* is a captivating read that challenges perceptions and lingers in the mind long after the final page.

In general, it is an interesting book, with the story of Lin Xiangfu, who started as a woodworker but went south looking for the mother of his child; he ended up in Xizhen, a city that then becomes the center of the fiction.
The novel shifts into horror mode at times, and is hilarious at others; romantic scenes follow epic pursuits, and the main characters fight nature, bandits, and sometimes their own weaknesses.
It is divided in two parts that occur more or less simultaneously; the first part focuses on Lin, the second on Xiaomei, the mother of his “little one”.
However, I am not totally sure that putting that second part after the first really works. When you arrive at the end of the first part, Xiaomei is mostly forgotten, and discovering what happens to her does not really pay off. Also, there is a bit of first-person action by Lin in this second part. While this would feel right at home, yin-and-yang style if they were interspersed, it looks like a bit or retcon here.
The convergence of the two threads in the final pages does not work that well either. While it Is well within the general theme of the book, persons and lives bumping into each other as snowflakes in a storm, it feels anticlimactic when you get there.
There are also a few typos. Anyway, I liked it and would recommend it heartily.

Set against the dramatic backdrop of early 20th-century China, City of Fiction by Yu Hua is a sprawling narrative that explores themes of loss, transformation, and the clash between tradition and modernity. With the old empire crumbling and the winds of change sweeping across the nation, the story follows a quiet man from the North who embarks on a journey south through a relentless snowstorm, carrying with him a newborn child and searching for a woman— the child's mother— who has mysteriously vanished.

What unfolds is a story that is part historical journey, part exploration of personal redemption. The man’s quest leads him to a city that doesn’t exist in the way he expects it to, a place caught between memories and reality. As the narrative weaves between the man’s quest and the story of the woman he searches for, the reader is drawn into a world where the boundaries between the personal and the collective history blur. Yu Hua masterfully juxtaposes the profound inner journeys of these two characters against the sweeping changes taking place in the country at large.

The novel is not merely about the individuals within it, but also about the world they inhabit—a world where ancient crafts are dying out, where old customs are vanishing, and where storytelling itself is evolving. It’s a tale about how people adapt to the winds of change, how they cling to the past even as they are swept along by the present. Through vivid, complex characters and rich, evocative prose, Hua takes readers on a journey through a world of violence, love, friendship, and above all, the inexorable march of time.

City of Fiction is an epic exploration of the tension between nostalgia for what is lost and the relentless pull of the future. With its intricate plot, surprising twists, and a profound meditation on the act of storytelling itself, this novel is a haunting and unforgettable read that examines the human condition within the broader context of historical upheaval.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.