I absolutely love this book! It's so funny, and the plot and storyline really keep you engaged. I would highly recommend it.

Thank you to Christy McKellen and NetGalley for sending me an ARC. I will definitely be checking out more of your books in the future!

Twin swapping lives is what roped me in, because it seemed like a fun read.
It just fell flat for me. The writing seemed all over the place and i couldn’t grasp onto to anything.
Jonah and Bea just don’t seem like they are a couple who will make it forever. They just seem like happily ever after for now….
While I didn’t care too much for the story, I will say it’s a quick read and it’s fun so if you’re looking for fun, quick and insta lust then I would definitely recommend

This very short and sweet. The two of them just connected on everything in a way that they haven't before. It was nice to see them have someone supportive.

I received an arc through netgalley.

Cute story. Unfortunately, I found myself skipping through certain passages to get the story moving along. The climax seemed to be rushed, as was the actual moment of "I love you"s... didn't have much depth to the relationship. I was very interested in continuing to know more about the characters and how they would work through the situation they found themselves in. However, I felt like the jump to love didn't leave any build-up for that strong foundation of the relationship. Otherwise, a cute read if you're just looking for a palate cleanser between denser books.

Too much telling, not enough showing. The first chapter is nothing but an exposition info-dump while the heroine works on her PC. It’s a masterclass on how NOT to open a novel. Maybe that works okay for a British audience, but not for an American one. DNF.

Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC I received. This is my honest and voluntary review.

Get ready for a whirlwind romance packed with heart, heat, and a touch of humor in Best Mistake Ever! With its irresistible combination of grumpy-sunshine, workplace drama, and hidden identities, this book delivers all the tropes romance readers adore. The added twists of a sister swap and celebrity romance keep the stakes high and the tension sizzling.

Beatrice Donovan’s attempt to save her twin sister’s career by pretending to be her lands her in the middle of a high-pressure hotel management job—and under the scrutiny of Jonah, her grumpy and impossibly handsome ex-rockstar boss. The manor house boutique hotel setting, complete with wood-fired hot tubs and secret spaces, adds charm and intimacy to the story, while Jonah’s unexpected talents and hidden depths create an emotional pull that’s hard to resist. And the spice? It’s there in droves, delivering all the swoon-worthy moments you could hope for. 🌶️🌶️🌶️

Best Mistake Ever is a steamy, feel-good romance that balances humor, tension, and heartfelt connections. If you love strong heroines, brooding heroes, and an unforgettable journey of love and self-discovery, this one is a must-read!

This book was very cute but a little too slow for me. The story was well written but was slow and then the "plot twist' give away kind of came our of nowhere. I know this author has other books so I would love to give them a try but this one is just not it for me!

From the start, I kept thinking to myself how strongly obvious the development would have to be, with a plot that could go in only one direction, when one of the love interest deceives the other. This said, you do not go into romance for the big surprises most of the time, and all in all, Christy McKellen delivered on the tropes announced.

I was not so convinced by any of the characters, as they lacked a bit too much of substance for my taste. The book is fairly short, which does not provide much room to develop them in details. I found Dee especially annoying and childish <spoiler>and felt like the epilogue was a clear introduction to another novel going over a romance between her and her sister's friend.</spoiler> In the same spirit, I found it sad not to go deeper into the reasons why Jonah was not drinking anymore, instead of brushing it off.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an early copy in exchange for my honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley & Boldwood books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

My first read from Kristy McKellen, and I found her writing quite difficult to get into, the beginning felt rushed and by the second page we had been introduced to about 7 characters.

A nice, quick read if you're looking for a palette cleanser.

Tropes:

⭐️ grumpy x sunshine
⭐️ forced proximity
⭐️multiple POVS

If you're looking for a quick, straight-forward romance read then this is for you! 3.5 stars (rounded up)

The concept of twins switching places intrigued me, and I was excited when I got the approval from NetGalley.

The dual POV was nice - i always love seeing perspectives from both the FMC and MMC. To be honest, I could have done without Dee's POV - it didn't give much (imo) that Bea or Jonah couldn't have provided.

I enjoyed the intensity between Jonah and Beatrice, and the tension of "will they, won't they" throughout. It was a quick, to-the-point story line with a nice plot.

First of all I'd like to thank Christy McKellan, Boldwood Books and NetGalley for letting me read this eARC in exchange for honest review

This book is a lighthearted, quick romance read which follows Bea as she covers for her twin, Dee, at her new job after Dee sprains her ankle.

Unfortunately this book was just not for me, I enjoyed watching Bea grow into her own person over the course of the book but couldn't get behind the writing style, the pacing and really did not like the MMC for a multitude of reasons. There were several instances where there was room to explore certain topics and flesh the characters out a little more but they were ultimately swept under the rug. I also found it a little odd that Dee and Jem just disappeared halfway through the book, I suspect the goal is to set up a second book where their storyline is explored but it was a little confusing from this perspective!

Rated 3.5 stars and rounded up to 4.

This was a delightful, quick read. The only main complaint is that this could have been longer and more detailed. It would have been fun to have more Delilah in the book (and I'm guessing her relationship with Bea's friend). I look forward to reading about Delilah in a future book and will check out McKellen's other books in the near future.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Beatrice Donovan would do anything for her identical twin sister. Including stepping into her hotel management job temporarily and pretending to be her - she’s desperate. What could go wrong? A lot apparently! Because her sister Delilah has hugely understated her role – the hotel is at risk of closure and she’s promised she can turn it around. Now Bea has to find a way to fly under the radar, get the job done before anyone notices their switch up.

Sounds easy, all Bea has to do is avoid her temporary new boss Jonah. However, that’s a lot harder than she thought. Not only does he have impossibly high standards, he’s also out of this world gorgeous, an ex-rockstar with a chip on his shoulder and he's watching her like a hawk! So Bea uses her charm to keep him focussed on the job and not her. But by trying to put up boundaries and keep things professional, Bea finds herself seeing the real man beneath the grumpy façade . Yet with so much at stake, she knows she shouldn’t fall for her sisters boss…but then again, it may just be the best unintentional mistake she’s ever made!

Best Mistake Ever lives up to its title in the end.
This is a slow-burn, feel-good romance to curl up in your blanket at night.

I don't really care about the main characters' chemistry, but I'm drawn to the sibling dynamics. I like Bea and Dee's subtle growth through the end of the book. Well, Dee's not so subtle *lol. Jonah was not likeable at the beginning.

One thing that I think will draw me 4 to 5 stars is if the supporting characters are more involved in the story.

Overall, I enjoy reading this book. I find the sibling relationship heartwarming (albeit a bit annoyed on Bea's behalf). I loveee the Festival and setting!

loved this romance and finding one's job. she switches place with her sister and does a better job, and find out what she would rather be doing then her other job. she ends up finding love too.

Delilah asks her twin sister Beatrice to take over her job as hotel manager temporarily. but has Beatrice taken on more then she can handle.?

The plot was sweet but not overly so and did not get boring. It moved along and made sense how it ended. The write did a great job describing the scenery and characters in a way that made it easy to picture.
My favorite aspect of this book was the inclusive festival. All of the events and activities seemed so wholesome and I found myself jealous of the characters that for to participate. Everyone during the events seems so happy, carefree, and just loving life. It was a wonderful addition to the story. Overall four stars.

Fun, very smooth read, adult spicy but not too much. I had expectations when I started reading this book. Spicy, romcom. That is definitely there. What I didn’t expect was such a smooth cosy feel. Totally believable? No! But that’s part of the enjoyment of this sort of book, where you lose yourself for a little while, and sort of dream for that fairytale love story experience in real life. Christy McKellen has true skill. The descriptive parts just flow, and, the conversations between the characters are just perfectly plausible. Won’t take you too long to read, but if this is a genre you like you will be satisfied. And if this isn’t your genre, or you are a guy scared to read ‘women’s fiction’ give it a go, you may be surprised how entertaining it is. Probably your best mistake ever! Thank you to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.

This was a fun read!

The premise was interesting (twins essentially life swapping) and set up a “what could go wrong?” where lots of things did in fact go wrong.

I loved how the sibling relationship developed between Bea and Dee, and I appreciated the growth of Jonah throughout the book.

I’m not sure why this book was labeled as erotica because it is VERY mild content-wise, but there is one moderately explicit scene well into the book. Beyond that, it’s lots of pining and tension (which I love).

Thank you to #netgalley + the author for my digital advance copy!

Bea pretends to be her twin sister at work, falls in love with sister's boss, forbidden love. I found the miscommunication in this book to be excruciating. Just talk to each other, people!