Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Ginny, recently widowed and having moved to a small town, takes a job at the library. On her second day of work, the unlikable head librarian is found dead. The unofficial widows' club, a group of other women who also happened to be widows and enjoy other's company (as well as sticking their noses in everywhere) adopt Ginny to help them solve the murder and clear the name of one of their daughters, who is a suspect. This was about what I expected for another of the "old folks solving murders" books that are popular at the moment. 3.5 stars rounded to 3.

Was this review helpful?

The Widows' Guide to Murder is the first book in Amanda Ashby's Widows' Detective Club Mystery series. It features Ginny Cole, an amateur sleuth in her sixties who’s just lost her husband. Instead of wallowing in grief, she decides to stick to their retirement plan and moves from Bristol to the quaint little village of Little Shaw.

Things take a wild turn when Ginny stumbles upon a body in the local library. She picks up on some suspicious clues and, with the help of three other widows from the village, dives into solving the mystery.

This cozy mystery is a total delight! The writing is charming, the characters are fantastic, and there are moments that will make you laugh and cry. Ginny is super relatable, and her three widowed friends add a lot of heart and humor to the mix. Plus, she adopts a clever stray cat named Edgar, who brings some hilarious moments to the story.

The plot is well put together and pretty suspenseful, with a nice ending that wraps everything up well.

Honestly, this book is one of my top picks for 2025 so far! I can’t wait to see where the series goes next.

If you’re into Agatha Raisin, The Thursday Murder Club, or The Marlow Murder Club, you’ll definitely want to check out the Widows' Detective Club Mystery series.

Was this review helpful?

If Ginny Cole didn’t have bad luck, she wouldn’t have any luck at all. Or so it seems when she finds the body of the local library manager, who was not beloved by the town folk. If finding them body weren’t bad enough, her friend’s daughter is accused of murder and now she joins several other widows to help clear the young woman’s name. Can Ginny turn her luck around, or is this the end of the road for her?

I saw the start to a new British cozy series. I absolutely loved it and can’t wait to see what the future has in store for Ginny and the other ladies.

Was this review helpful?

Short and fun mystery read. Anyone who likes older detective shows will find a lot to love here. Fun supporting cast and a wonderful and easy to like lead

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the first book in this new cozy mystery series by Amanda Ashby. Set in small town England it follows Ginny Cole as she tries to move forward in a new town after her husband's passing. Her plans for retirement in Little Shaw aren't going to be exactly how she planned now that she's a widower. She needs to get a job to help with her finances and she needs to adjust without her constant companion of decades.
She finds a job at the local library, finds a sweet cat and she meets a group of fellow widowers who welcome her into their "club" of sorts.
She needs their support when she finds a dead body on only her second day of work and when one of the widower's daughters is suspect number one in the death the group works together to uncover the truth.
There's lots of adventures that ensue and what comes to light will leave you guessing and surprised. I really enjoyed the twists and turns and was not expecting where the story ended up. I can't wait to read the second and get back to Ginny, her cat edgar and her friends. I also am looking forward to where things go with her detective neighbour and her mentoring relationships at the library.
Well crafted. I highly recommend this series!

Was this review helpful?

I always look dorward to this author book's. They have good flowing plots and good characters. They catch me from the frist pages as they build to the end. I received arc copy from Net Galley and Storm Publisher.

Was this review helpful?

Je ne connaissais pas l'autrice, donc je me suis dit pourquoi pas.

Et puis c'est un cosy murder. Donc moi qui suis fan des cosy je me suis lancée.

C'est le premier livre de la série The Widows' Detective Club, et c'est toujours bien de se lancer dans le premier d'une série.

Ginny a déménagé dans une nouvelle ville après la mort de son mari et pour démarrer sa nouvelle vie, elle travaille dans une bibliothèque, mais voilà que son patron a été retrouvé mort à la bibliothèque peu de temps.

En principe on laisse la police faire son travail mais comme dans tous cosy murder, les amateurs vont se retrouver mêler à l'enquête et Ginny va y participer activement, avec trois autres veuves , avec lesquelles elle va se lier d'amitié

.Tout est réuni pour passer un bon moment réunissant tous les ingrédients d'un bon cosy.

Was this review helpful?

I'm so in love with this book, and I'm excited that it will be a series! It's cozy and sweet and thoughtful. Like Agatha Christie but with three dimensional women. Even though I am half her age, I really connected with Ginny. I am definitely going to be recommending this one to people! This book is DEEPLY cute and I enjoyed it immensely! Highly recommend. Read it. Especially when you need something light and lovely!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book and would classify it as a cozy mystery. Ginny is fun female lead. There were funny parts, but mostly just cozy with a library theme (and a cat!!). The book held my interest and was a quick read. I look forward to book 2.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the advance ARC and giving me the opportunity to review this book!

Was this review helpful?

I feel this book set the tone just right through Ginny’s character in the way that she dealt with grief and having to start a new life.

The friends she made were quirky with the typical warmth you hope to find in a small town cosy crime novel.

Now, moving on to the murder plot – so many moments when I thought I didn’t see that coming! The developments in the plot kept me turning the pages. There was something happening all of the time.

I like a good cosy crime mystery with an ameteur sleuth as a library assistant or librarian. There’s a cat too and a very clever one, Edgar was purrfect. What more could you want?

This book gave me what I was looking for with plenty of key moments revolving around the library.

It also steered away from the use of clichés with good development of the relationship between Ginny and the local detective rather than the local force being portrayed as bumbling characters. There were no retired spy characters or MI5, which I was pleased about.

In some aspects, with Ginny needing to get a job after her husband’s death and the lives of some of the other characters, more realism was brought in and we were presented with less of a middle class slice of life. I found that to be a breath of fresh air.

Ginny was very down to earth in the way she thought and went about solving crimes – she had Miss Marple’s humbleness and gentle yet strong personality.

I felt like the other characters played their parts well overall, if sometimes the baddies were a tad soap operaesque. However, it was a very engrossing storyline, and Ginny’s development made for an enjoyable read.

I’m very keen to find out what is next for Ginny and I want to know more about her past life too.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for the ebook ARC.

I don’t often gravitate towards contemporary cozy-ish mysteries but I think I will read more after this.
By the 4% mark I knew that I would love this book. Ginny is a charming character. I enjoyed watching her slowly healing in her new situation as a widow who starts off demure and lonely and slowly evolves into an amateur sleuth with a decent circle of friends and accomplices. The writing is delightful and smooth and the mystery plot was engaging and well constructed. The Filofax references were everything!!!

Will I read more of this series? Absolutely! I can’t wait to start book 2. I will also look into Amanda Ashby’s backlog.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book from Amanda Ashby that I have read, I will need to rectify that and soon, I loved this one from start to finish getting to know Ginny Cole and the widows she has met when she moves to the village of Little Shaw, come a long and meet the Ladies you are sure to be kept thinking.

When Ginny loses her dear husband, Eric she follows the plan they had for retirement and moves to middle cottage in Little Shaw here she decides that getting a job will be needed and before she knows it she is hired as library assistant at the local parish library where her boss Louisa is not a very nice person, her second day on the job she discovers Louisa’s body and here starts her sleuthing never realising that it was something that she would get into making friends with three other widows, Hen, Tuppence and JD together they make a formidable team and Ginny is soon doing things she never thought she would and what’s more getting on the wrong side of the law and pushing the Detectives buttons along the way.

It takes a bit, but Ginny is soon settling in to her new life in Little Shaw and loving her new friends and the cat Edgar who has adopted and her job at the library, as well as uncovering murderers, this is such a well written cosy mystery that had me thinking all the way through I was cheering Ginny and the widows on as they uncovered secrets and did their best to save lives.

This is the start of a new series and it is one that I would highly recommend, I loved it and book two is realeasing very soon, can’t wait to read it.

My thanks to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for my digital copy to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

I was in a weird book slump, and I couldn’t get into several books that I had been excited about. I randomly decided to pick this one up, and it stuck! I think I needed something easy but that kept my attention. And this one did that! I wasn’t a huge fun of any of the widows. I think if I had loved their characters, I would have loved this book more. But the mystery itself was not one I could easily solve, and so I’m definitely rounding up because of that.

If you’re looking for an easy, cozy mystery novel, this one’s got your name on it!

3.5/5 rounded up

Was this review helpful?

At Sixty, Ginny Cole finds herself widowed and starting over in Little Shaw Village. She has been hired as the new library assistant in the village library, which is vastly different than managing her late husband's medical practice. She soon finds her new boss dead and there seems to be no end to possible suspects as Louisa Farnsworth was not very popular. She finds herself taken under the wing of a group of eccentric widows who see themselves as sleuths finding info the police have missed. Ginny also happens to be the next-door neighbor of local policeman, grumpy DI Wallace. who also doesn't appreciate her new friends form of helping. She has also taken in a stray cat she names Edgar.


Thanks to NetGalley and Storm publishing for this ARC and the opportunity to give my review. This is such a fun book! It is funny, warm hearted, and has a pretty good mystery. I found myself drawn to all the characters and instantly liking them. I look forward to seeing them in future books. While the widows tend to get into crazy situations and a little bit of mischief, they mean well and always look out for one another. Thanks to her widow friends, Ginny is starting to feel part of the community and so maybe she has found her next chapter.

Was this review helpful?

This book offers a charming cozy mystery set in a library—complete with a cat! The story follows Ginny, a retired and widowed woman, as she steps out of her comfort zone despite her lingering grief. I enjoyed experiencing her journey through her perspective, which felt heartfelt and genuine. The mystery itself was engaging, and the unexpected plot twist kept me hooked.

However, Ginny didn’t always feel like she acted or thought her age, which made her character slightly less convincing. Additionally, the overwhelming number of side characters made the story a bit confusing at times. While the twist was satisfying, the pacing toward the end felt dragged out. Still, if you enjoy cozy mysteries with bookish settings, a touch of unpredictability, and a heartwarming protagonist, this is a great pick!

A. Setting & Atmosphere
⭐⭐⭐: A decently immersive setting, but not particularly unique.

B. Main Character & Sleuthing Skills
⭐⭐⭐⭐: Clever, resourceful, and enjoyable to follow.

C. Side Characters & Community
⭐⭐⭐: A well-rounded supporting cast with a few standouts.

D. Mystery & Clues
⭐⭐⭐⭐: Well-plotted with clever twists and satisfying deductions.

E. Pacing & Suspense
⭐⭐⭐: Steady flow, though not particularly gripping.

F. Cozy Elements & Charm
⭐⭐⭐⭐: Delightfully cozy, with drinks, crafts, pets, and small-town charm.

G. Enjoyment & Replay Value
⭐⭐: Had a few good moments but mostly forgettable.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for allowing me to read and review this book.

An enjoyable cozy mystery, which I'm guessing will be the beginning of a series.

Was this review helpful?

This is an enjoyable cosy mystery clearly been set up to be the first in series. The character of Ginny, newly widowed and new to the area, is relatively well developed.

The three other eccentric widows who feature heavily in this book have room for further development, I wonder what the later books in the series will be from their perspective.
The minor characters were all distinct and easy to differentiate from one another - not always so with other cosy mysteries.

One of the key features in this novel is female friendship after a bereavement which is well handled and nice to see in a otherwise frivolous read. I also enjoyed the focus on older women as competent and capable individuals.

Thank you Netgalley for allowing me to read in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great story about Ginny Cole, recently widowed and struggling to live an independent life. She finds herself a job as a library assistant only to discover her boss murdered shortly after starting the job. Ginny manages to be adopted into a group of widows and their search for the murderer begins, up to and including digging up a grave in the middle of the night!

This is a fun book, very well written and a really good read. I had not read her before and it turns out she is an Aussie author and she has written heaps of books. There is already a follow up to this book which I must get hold of.

Was this review helpful?

It's a bit of a slow start, and some of the characters don't quite solidify in the book. Hopefully, that will improve in the second book. I did really enjoy Ginny and her personal journey, though!

Was this review helpful?

The Widows' Guide to Murder: A completely gripping and charming cozy mystery
is book #1 in The Widows' Detective Club series by Amanda Ashby.

This is the first book in an entertaining new series. Ginny is a widow who has moved to a new village to start over. She has a job at the library with an unpleasant manager who ends up being murdered. Ginny teams up with 3 other widows to investigate. Likable characters, interesting mystery, and a cat - just what I need for a brief escape from reality. I can’t wait for the next book!

Thank you to the author, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for the Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) copy of this book and I am voluntarily leaving an honest review.

Was this review helpful?