Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was completely enthralling! I am slightly sad that I did not realize that this was the fourth book in the series (though I already have the first book ready to read right away after this!) but it did not detract from the immediate hooking of my attention in The Countdown Killer! I must say, Cara and Griffin and the rest of the officers are amazing with working together to find this latest serial killer, who has worked under their noses for years and may be connected to other killers. The action goes quick, and even as more bodies show up, they still keep working to unravel all the twists this case takes. And it does get really dark what with the films that have very graphic deaths, though there is justice in that (at least according to the killer). This was very hard to put down and I did really enjoy all the twists that I did not see coming. I am looking very much forward to reading the rest of the series now and I do not mind already knowing bits mentioned in this book (I am sure it will still be a wild ride!) I also can't wait to see what is next for Cara and Griffin, though I think they deserve some rest and relaxation after all that happens in the hunt for this long time serial killer!

Was this review helpful?

This is the 4th in the Major Crimes series, and I can not rate this highly enough. I am shocked at what I read and how incredible it was. To fully appreciate the series, you must read them in order.

After a mysterious package is dropped off at the main desk, the team are drawn into finding who they believe is a hired killer. As the case goes on, Cara wonders if this case is somehow linked to The Echo Man.

After the cliffhanger at the end of book 3, I couldn't wait to read this book. At book 4, I am now fully invested in these characters, which are so excellently written. I personally think this is the best book in the series, and I literally could not put it down. I was up in the early hours finishing it, I was absolutely gripped.

I have read hundreds of crime thrillers books, and this book and series are definitely one of the best I have ever read.

Was this review helpful?

This is the forth book in the major crime series following DCI Cara Elliott and her team, it’s actually the first one I’ve read and I’m now desperate to go back and read the first three.

It was a well written thriller, pacy with a lot of tension and Sam Holland doesn’t shy away from graphic scenes.

Cara is a strong lead character and I would love to see her development from the previous books and see it in the next one.

Although it was the fourth in the series and there are a lot of references to previous events, there was enough information mentioned so I didn’t feel lost and not too much to spoil the books before.

A disturbing recording is dropped off at the police station which leads to the teams next murder case. A killer has been active for years leaving multiple victims and without raising suspicion. Whilst investigating Cara finds a link to one of her previous cases and her actions put a member of her team at risk.

I loved this book for the plot, writing as well as the characters.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been waiting with anticipation for the next instalment from Sam Holland & featuring DCI Cara Elliott especially since the cliff hanger ending from book 3 the puppet master, & Sam Holland has done it again and created a novel I truly could not stop reading, it’s not for the faint hearted and is truly grizzly in places but what I like most about this series is all the characters are flawed they are all dealing with their own demons but they still manage to work together to bring the bad guys to justice and this story definitely keeps you guessing right to the end. I’m not sure if there will be anymore of this series but I hope there will be.

Was this review helpful?

A man has been murdered and it was filmed live on camera and delivered on DVD to the police station. DCI Cara Elliot and is determined to get to the bottom of the Murders. When a police officer is taken the countdown is on to find him before the time runs out and he becomes another victim.

This book was brilliant and the best one in the series so far 😍 (they're all brilliant) A flew through this and just couldn't stop reading it was fast paced with so many twists and turns. I had no idea what to expect. I would highly recommend this series 🤩 (read them in order starting with The Echo Man)

Thank you to Netgalley, Harper Collins UK and Sam Holland for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

5 of 5 stars
https://lynns-books.com/2025/06/05/review-the-countdown-killer-major-crimes-4-by-sam-holland/
My Five Work TL:DR Review: Seriously, My Favourite of Series

I’ve been thoroughly enjoying this series by Sam Holland. No.3, The Puppet Master was so good but The Countdown Killer takes the biscuit. I could not put this down. It’s so good. It’s fast paced, brutal, dark, the characters are developing so well and it’s just compelling. I will say, at this stage in the series I think if you’re wanting to read this author I’d start at the beginning of the series. The books simply go from strength to strength, the character growth is excellent and frankly, though you could probably read all of these as standalones I think you would miss the depth that starting at the beginning really delivers.

Once again we have the winning combination of Cara and Griffin. As the story begins I think the whole Major Crimes unit are looking forward to something of a break, they’re all a little worn thin to be sure, but with the delivery of a CD to the station, their hopes are about to be dashed. The CD is apparently a snuff film but although it at first appears to be an easy one off case to solve that is far from the truth.

So, i’m not going to expand on the plot because this is an absolute corker and has to be discovered in the moment, no clues from me, no sirree.

Why this is so good.

Well, firstly, this is book four and so not only am I totally immersed in the characters and their jobs but It also feels very much like the author is in full swing. Like she has a purpose and knows wheres she’s taking us readers and her cast.

The tension is really ratcheted up for this one. The crimes are quite brutal so I’m just going to warn you about that. This is one dark and twisted story. And, of course, by book 4, I’m totally invested in the characters so for a large part of this story my heart was in my throat. Not even kidding.

The pacing is fast. Again, I think this author is a tricksy so and so, she throws everything at you and gives you little time to consider what’s going on or who the culprit might be.

The story is totally gripping. If you start this one I actually defy you to put it down. Negative. Not possible. I needed to stay up and keep reading.

And the writing is great. Everything flows well, I literally didn’t have a single little niggle.

In conclusion, I can’t recommend this series enough and I can’t wait to see what comes next.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.

Was this review helpful?

The Countdown Killer by Sam Holland is a chilling, fast-paced thriller that hooked me from page one. With sharp twists, a compelling main character and an atmosphere filled with tension, it’s everything a great crime novel should be. Smart, suspenseful, and deeply unsettling — a must-read for fans of this series and psychological thrillers in general (although I do recommend reading the others first, particularly The Echo Man).

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been a massive fan of Sam Holland and the Major Crimes series ever since I picked up The Twenty.

The Countdown Killer only emphasizes what a brilliant author Sam Holland is. As this book is electrifying, gruesome, and truly unputdownable.

It follows the Major Crimes team as they search for a serial killer after a DVD is handed in, showing a man being murdered in the most brutal way possible. And that is just the tip of the iceberg.

As the team led by DCI Cara Elliott tries to find a killer seemingly paid to exact justice on those who have gotten away with heinous crimes.

But a startling discovery sends Cara down a dark path, bringing her face to face with the Echo Man.

However, it soon becomes clear that he is the least of their worries. When a team member is abducted by the killer they are desperately hunting. And they are now in a race against time to save them.

And with shocking moments, twists, and turns, this is a story you need to read. Which is why I would happily recommend it to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

Wow.

Didn't realise this was part of a series of books.

I went to read the whole set but this is certainly best of the lot. Major twist and very highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Wowza what a brilliant and captivating read! This book is dark, gritty, and shocking, in the best possible way.

I have been a great admirer of Sam Holland since The Echo Man, which remains one of my favourite books, so I was thrilled to hear this was a continuation of that case. And this book certainly delivered! While I found Echo Man to be twisty and shocking, this one surpasses it. If you enjoy a well-crafted serial killer story with surprising twists, this is a must-read!

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins UK for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion

Was this review helpful?

WOW what a dark and grisly thriller surrounding the issue of snuff videos,one is delivered to the main character and how farsome evil people will go for their kicks
Fast paced,intense and got to say scary,a book you cant/ wont forget

Was this review helpful?

This is book 4 of the Major Crimes series and, as per usual, to get the best from it, you do need to start from the beginning and read in order. If you haven't already done this, as certain things in this book carry on from shenanigans in the first book - The Echo Man - and its aftermath, I really do recommend you at least read that one first.
In this book we follow DCI Cara Elliott and her team as they investigate another really nasty case. An old lady handed in a DVD that she found in her late husband's effects that they really need to see. What they then witness on film is shocking to say the very least. It appears that someone has been abducted, tortured, and then, after verbal confirmation, executed in an extremely brutal way. Start to finish 2 days.
Further investigation brings more of the same and then a live target. The clock is started, the police have 48 hours to save one of their own...
Quite how the Echo Man is involved in this book I will leave you to discover for yourself. Suffice to say that this case brings up a lot of bad memories for Cara, Nate and the rest of the team and there's quite a few secrets divulged which splits the pack so to speak. It delivers double the book I was expecting as you have the nasty torture snuff film case intermingled with connections back to the Echo Man. Tension really ramps up as we race to a rather shocking, but wholly satisfying, conclusion which left me reeling.
It's fast paced and doesn't really leave much respite for the reader, just enough to keep things from getting too over the top dark, but it is pretty brutal all the way through. The author definitely knows how to ramp up the tension and intrigue and compel the reader to carry on.
All in all, a cracking read and a great example of the genre. If you do go on to read these books, and enjoy them, I would also recommend you check out the author's other books, writing as Louisa Scarr. Not as brutal, but just as good.
My thanks go to the Publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

My thanks to HarperCollins UK, HarperFiction and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read ‘The Countdown Killer’ written by Sam Holland in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.

An elderly lady drops off a DVD at Southampton Police Station’s Major Crimes Unit and as DCI Cara Elliott and her team watch it they realise it shows a particularly gruesome snuff film that viewers are paying to view. Cara doesn’t know the identity of the killer but realises that time is limited before the next victim is chosen, but what she doesn’t know is that the killer is watching her.

‘The Countdown Killer’ is the truly gripping story of a killer who enjoys subjecting their victims to the most horrific and violent of deaths and with little evidence to work with DI Cara Elliott knows she’s not going to be able to stop the killing unless Noah Deakin, jailed for being the Echo Man, gives her information. I can’t understand how this is the first book I’ve read by this author as it’s exactly the type of thriller I enjoy, although the blood and gore had me cringing at times, and the suspense and tension built up so perfectly it was impossible to stop reading. I agree with Sam that the Noisy Lobster is a great restaurant with an amazing view of Avon Beach, and I liked reading of the enjoyable evening Griffin and Brody had there. It’s an incredibly well-written thriller with multiple twists and turns that had me sitting on the edge of my seat unable to let go of my Kindle. But then I reached the final chapters and the explosive ending that had me in tears! Now that I’ve finally discovered DCI Cara Elliott I’m hoping she’ll be in another book in the not too distant future.

Was this review helpful?

As soon as I saw the cover of this book, I knew I would like it. Like is an understatement!! This is a fast-paced, full of action, get-ready-to-roll kind of book that keeps you on the edge of your seat and awake late at night for just some more pages!!! What I really loved the most is that I wasn't aware this is a sequel to another book, and you can absolutely read this one alone. The book poses some quite important moral questions like, if we could freely get retribution against bad persons who did horrific things to us, would we cross that line? I really loved the fact that all these notions and feelings were explored in the book, it's not your regular thriller, I thought it was much more deep with regards to the underlying message. Loved it and thank you so much NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book, now I'll go read the first book in this series!!

Was this review helpful?

“Hell is empty. And all the devils are here.”

The Countdown Killer follows DCI Cara Elliott’s latest case when a DVD is delivered to the station, containing a horrifying showreel of violence… This is death, on demand - and viewers are paying for the killings. The pattern: twisted specifications and a forty-eight-hour pattern. But when the killer finds out they’re being investigated, they reveal their next target: a police officer. The hunters have become the hunted, and the clock is ticking…

The Countdown Killer is told over three parts, and is the 4th book in the major crimes series. It's hard to fully express just how much I adore this series and its characters. I enjoyed being reunited with Cara and her team (well, some of them - iykyk), but this comfort was soon overpowered by a mix of horror and admiration as I was drawn into yet another masterfully crafted, suspense filled narrative.

Sam Holland has one of the most brilliant and darkly fascinating minds, and it is this that sets her apart as an author and makes this whole series 5 stars for me. This book was graphic, intense and so gripping it genuinely gave me palpitations. Each chapter was packed full of action and ingenious writing, often ending on a cliffhanger or a case-breaking that made it impossible to stop reading. The twists had my head spinning, and the ending was beautifully constructed and flawlessly executed.

I don’t want to say too much more that could spoil anything for those eagerly awaiting this book, but trust me - you won’t be disappointed. And if you haven’t started this series yet, do yourself a favor and grab every book now!

Thank you so much to Sam Holland and HarperCollins/Hemlock Press for this advanced copy of The Countdown Killer to read and review. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Omg this book was a wild ride and one of my faves this year.

I loved the fast pace and tense atmosphere created by Holland’s fantastic descriptive writing. I was sucked in from the first page and I didn’t (couldn’t) ease up, not even at the end, when I was left with so many playbacks of scenes.

This book shook me and it’s not often that I am affected by these types of books but there was one scene in particular that challenged me. This book made me cry and o my Holland, you may have ruined me a bit and written one of the most memorable scenes that will live with me for a long time.
I loved the developing relationships and we finally had some closure in Noah and how his childhood journey led him to his current predicament.

Overall a phenomenal book. If you loved The Echo Man you are absolutely going to LOVE this one!

Thank you to Netgalley and Harper Collins UK for the chance to read this amazing book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

DCI Cara Elliot receives a dvd delivered to the police station on it is a snuff film. As Cara and her team investigates, the killer targets people she loves. A thriller that stands with the best. Fast paced with wonderful characters. Edge of you seat plotting. Sam Holland is now one of my go to authors. Thanks to Harpercollins UK and Netgalley for this review ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a brilliant crime thriller that ties up some elements of previous books, so I’d recommend reading those first.
Cara can’t believe her eyes when she watches a DVD that has been delivered to the station, as it contains a snuff film.
Cara and the team are sickened by what they’ve seen and know they need to catch this killer quickly.
They have a few leads and soon realise this killer has struck many times in the past.
Things soon turn personal for Cara when people she knows and cares about are targeted, and even though she’s taken off the case, it doesn’t stop her following more leads.
This is a fast paced crime thriller with a few gruesome descriptions that add to story.
Thanks to Harper Collins UK for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is the fourth book in the Major Crimes series, and it relates back to The Echo Man, so I’d definitely recommend reading that (and the other two excellent books in the series) first.

The familiar faces and personalities from the series are back, and although things seem to have quieted down for the team, a new case is about to throw everything back into turmoil.

In this book we have the dubious pleasure of meeting the insufferable, ambitious DCI Ryder from the Basingstoke Major Crimes team. I liked the glimpse we had of her character, but less was definitely more with everything else going on…

I did feel the book started slowly, which is by no means a bad thing because it helps to be invested in the characters and their lives. From about halfway the stakes were raised and became almost unbearably tense.

With 25% to go, no way I was going to sleep without finishing this book. I’m here for the thrills, even if some elements are far-fetched, and The Countdown Killer delivered. A twisty plot, plenty of nasty murders, and a pulse-raising race to find the killer. Sam Holland has become one of my favourite crime/thriller authors, and although this book hasn’t hit the shelves yet (it’s out 5th June), I can’t wait to see what her next will be!

My thanks to the author, publisher and to NetGalley for the advance review copy.

Was this review helpful?

A very intense and dark read as we see the depravity of people willing to pay for death on camera. Very gripping and twisted read overall.

Was this review helpful?