Skip to main content

Member Reviews

An ambitious and often provocative novel exploring faith, mortality, and the human condition through a fragmented, poetic structure. The raw, experimental style is on full display, at times beautiful and haunting, but the abstract narrative and lack of cohesion may not resonate with everyone. While I appreciated the philosophical depth and bold choices, the repetition and cryptic passages made it hard to stay fully engaged. Those drawn to literary experimentation may find it compelling. Overall, Next to Heaven is a challenging yet thought-provoking read that didn’t quite land for me, though I can see its appeal to a niche audience.

Was this review helpful?

DNF - I did not care for this at all and found myself bored. Truthfully I probably could have pushed on and perhaps theree was a bias to it as I don't believe I actually requested this title in the first place as I have absolutely no interest in supporting this author.

Was this review helpful?

What on earth was this? How did I reach the end?

This book is absolutely terrible. I don’t know if it’s because it’s an ARC but the grammar is non-existent.

Was it even proofread once before sharing? The amount of repetition is CRAZY. It’s like it was written by a teenage girl (although being a girl myself I am loathe to say that). But it’s repetitive like it’s trying to be dramatic. Examples: “David watched and watched and watched and watched” and “They got a huge amount of footage, huge huge huge amount”. Who writes like that? I will never read another book by this author. Absolutely terrible.

I give this book 1 star and myself 5 stars for making it though to the other side.

Was this review helpful?

I loved a Million Little Pieces and was so keen to read this.
So disappointing. Every character is rich and beautiful but that’s it. Every now and again comes a phase or sentence that makes you think there’s a writer in there somewhere but they are merely islands in a sea of awful. If this is his life now I feel sorry for him

Was this review helpful?

Horrible people doing horrible things in the context of the world of the rich and privileged. James Frey makes this a humorous and engaging read, despite the subject matter, and I love his style of writing which captures event and emotion with such clarity, I always felt this author was hard done by, being so publicly criticised on an international scale for including fictionalised aspects in a semi-autobiographical book. This completely overshadowed his talent for writing and it is good to see he did not let this stop him.

Was this review helpful?

this book was strange and in parts not very good but honestly an interesting concept that i think could make a really good book if written better. i found the pacing of the story really strange, all the buildup to the party was extremely repetitive, hard to get into and long for the party (the main climax) to only be a few pages long. i also didn’t realise it was meant to be a murder mystery till the end because the murder doesn’t happen till like 70% in lol. the punctuation was also non existent and really needs to be checked over again before this book is published properly because it was really confusing to read in some parts due to lack of punctuation. overall, had a lot of potential but just didn’t really hit

thank you to NetGalley for the ARC of this book

Was this review helpful?

This book is one of the worst I've picked up in a long time. So much so that I gave up at about 5%. I generally don't write reviews when I've stopped reading so early, but reading around this one online I found out that the author has admitted to using AI to write the book. That in itself is enough to make me want to give the book 0 stars. The only reason I'm giving 1 star on NetGalley is because I can't give 0.

As it is, the writing is awful anyway. There's no speech marks used throughout and several other punctuation marks missing. Sentences are poorly constructed, and there was a lot of repetition even in the first few pages. Turns out AI can't write novels - Who knew?

Thanks to NetGalley and Swift Press for an arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book but at the beginning its build up and I found it hard to get into and understand the storyline it’s crime based here is the blurb

The new novel from Sunday Times-bestselling author James Frey. AVAILABLE NOW FOR PRE-ORDER.

Behind every great fortune, lies a great crime - Honoré de Balzac

New Bethlehem, Connecticut. Picture-perfect lawns, manicured hedges, multi-million dollar homes. But beneath the designer yoga gear and country club memberships lies a darker reality.

In this world of excess, Devon and Belle have it all – beauty, money, status. But they want something more. Something dangerous. Something that makes them feel alive. Their solution? A party – a meticulously curated gathering of New Bethlehem's elite, from a desperate ex-NFL quarterback to a hockey coach with a penchant for married women, and a ruthless Wall Street 'closer' who wields his wealth like a weapon.

One night. Multiple betrayals. And a murder that will shatter New Bethlehem's carefully constructed facade.

Was this review helpful?

sometimes the rich have it all. but often the rich can be just as bad as each other. so bring them all together, put all those egos and secrets and lies together and you might just have an icky situation. thats a whole lot of one up-man ship all fighting for the number one role. it might even lead to murder?
this is messy and juicy and very complicated characters indeed. the drama. the money. the snobbery. it was all just o delicious in how much it was pouring from the characters.
and when all these attend a party together...haha madness. but a fun one to read instead of envy for once.

Was this review helpful?

James Frey's inimitable shocking style of writing continues.
A group of friends have a high end adult sleepover. The ensuing story describes the outcome of the party and the entangled lives of the participants, including death and intrigue.

Was this review helpful?

This book was such fun. New Bethlehem is a wealthy suburb in Connecticut, with a cast of young gorgeous couples who are mostly cheating on each other. Devon and Belle are the queens of the trophy wives, but there is a lot going on behind the scenes and they organise a swinging party which causes fallout amongst all of them. It's a clever plot, and there are some horrible parts, but in the main, it is lighthearted and enjoyable. Great for the beach.

Was this review helpful?

I neither loved nor hated this book. It was recommended to me by a friend who loved it so I thought I would give it a go! It was probably too American’ for me and a lot of the frames of reference I was unfamiliar with. The concept is a good one and I really wanted to find out what happened and was pleased with the conclusion. I felt little empathy with the characters so perhaps didn’t root for them as much as I could have. It’s worth reading but not one of my favourites.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve long been a fan of James Frey’s work having read A Million Little Pieces some years ago (& recommended to many people) so I was delighted to read his latest, and it didn’t disappoint. His style can.sometimes be a little confusing (little punctuation) but I soon got in to the swing and devoured this piece. The characters were well rounded &, where meant, quite loathsome. The identity of the victim kept me guessing & I liked the twist at the end of which was hinted at but I didn’t really see coming.

Was this review helpful?

I liked the premise for this book, but for me the reality didn’t match up. There is a lot of background about ultra rich privilege and abuse, there is a lot about the aftermath of a swingers party in terms of the relationships that occur as a consequence. All of this is presented in an unusual style, and ultimately is okay. Then there is a tiny part of the book that is about the murder and who done it. I expected the reverse in terms of content. So for me not nearly as exciting or entertaining as I thought it was going to be. Thank you to Swift Press and NetGalley for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, sex-filled, scandalous, and glamorous thriller with a focus on the New Bethlehem elite. It's giving Jackie Collins but with zilch romance but ALL the scandal. I kept wanting more of this, i've never read a James Frey so had no idea what I was in for. This isn't for the faint hearted (or for prudes) but it's the perfect escapism and beach read !!!

Was this review helpful?

Next to Heaven could just as easily be titled "Rich People Behaving Badly". The writing style might not be for everyone, but I personally loved it and flew through it. There are a lot of characters introduced throughout, but their backgrounds were so detailed and varied that I didn’t have trouble keeping track of them.
The crime element is definitely secondary—it’s clear this is more of a social critique—but I do wish it had been introduced a bit earlier. The culprit was also a bit obvious, but the story was still very enjoyable.
That said, I don’t think I’ll be picking up another book about the ultra-rich anytime soon—their decadent behaviour is exhausting (and a little nauseating). 😆

Was this review helpful?

Having read A Million Little Pieces by this author and it being up there as one of the most memorable books I have ever read, I was really looking forward to this one.

It did not disappoint!

Set in a small town in Connecticut, several families and about to be tested during to the brutal murder if one of their own. Very few of the characters are likeable or even tolerable, all being spoilt, rich, egotistical, nasty and selfish humans. The first part of the book sets a great back story to each important character. The murder happens and the second half is given over to the solving of the murder and arresting the murderer. You think you have it pegged and know who the killer is but do you really …

Was this review helpful?

Was I Heaven-adjacent or just stuck in hell with this one?

Think 'The White Lotus' meets 'Clue', but all the suspects are so meh you need a colour-coded cheat sheet, and the corpse is so laissez-faire they nearly forget to RSVP to their murder. The writing style tries so hard to be clever, it talks in circles - by page 200, I felt like I was circling the drain of despair. And spoiler - there's no scratch-the-code coupon to redeem this ride at the end. I am guilty of less-than-angelic thoughts.

Forget Colonel Mustard with the candlestick... James Frey, guilty as charged.
Perhaps I'm just more of a Monopoly girl.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me the ARC in exchange for my honest thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

When I was in my last year of university in 2012, I did a module in American studies called Reading in Popular culture.
It was my favourite module of my entire degree, and there was a portion of the course on Oprah’s Book Club.
And of course, James Frey’s A Million Little Pieces.
Fact or fiction, I truly don’t care. I loved the book and think about it often.
I don’t think except My Friend Leonard (the sequel to A Million Little Pieces) I’ve read anything by James Frey since then, so I was intrigued to see his name on my Netgalley a few weeks ago.
I loved the sound of this book. A murder mystery, Stepfor-wives esque setting in a town of opulence.

I really enjoyed this book. The setting and the characters were so well-realised and I loved the Greek Chorus of gossip. The partner switching was such a good device, though I did find myself struggling to keep track of everyone.

The only thing I didn’t think this book needed was the murder plot. I was intrigued enough by all the characters and maybe because I’m not a big thriller fan I just didn’t feel it was fleshed out enough to be necessary.

A fantastic return to form for James Frey. I’m intrigued to know what he does next.

Was this review helpful?

Devon and Belle have wealth and privilege but the lives they lead give them everything with ease and now they are looking for something more. They attempt to throw the party to end all parties, full of debauchery, drugs, and it will turn out, death.

I found the writing style highly innovative but it didn't work for me personally. There were no quotations around the speech and lengthy, pages-long paragraphs were followed by line-long ones. I'm sure there are many readers who will find the literary merit here but I wasn't one of them and it only served to alienate me from the story.

The party that was mentioned in the official synopsis did not take centre stage, as I had presumed and instead much of the first half was spent lengthily introducing the couples who would attend and their various back-stories. I cared little and felt I was just waiting for the story to start. Once it did, I was hooked, but overall this just didn't work for me, unfortunately.

Was this review helpful?