Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy of this book.

This is an unusual book and quite hard to classify. It is not what I would call sci fi and it is not what I expected from the blurb.

When I started it I really was not sure what was going on but I was drawn in and the more I read, the more I enjoyed it. Adina is an interesting character and her observations are usually very funny but also can also give a person pause for thought. I am still not entirely sure what was going on, is Adina an actual space alien? It didnt matter to me though because I just enjoyed reading about her life and the choices she made. The book actually reminded me a bit of books like "Hello God, It's Me , Margaret" but, as I say, perhaps I am missing something deep.

The advance copy I had gave the replies to the faxes as simply ".", a full stop. I don't know if that was deliberate or if some words were missing. There were also some letters missing which occasionally stopped my reading flow, In Adina's flat, for example I spent some time wondering what the replace was, it is of course fireplace.

i would recommend this book as a story about a woman throughout her life, with the alien side just a hook to hang the story on.

Was this review helpful?

Delightful. A story filled with charm and mystery. Is Adina truly human? Perhaps not. She believes she’s come from a faraway planet to study Earth and so, sends reports back to the ‘Shining Ones’ via a fax machine rescued from a bin.
She graces her environment like an ethereal being and makes this story enchanting.
It’s a truly different kind of ‘sci fi’ tale and I loved it.
I believe this book will be read far and wide and will appeal to all ages.

Was this review helpful?

This book. Ugh I’m so frustrated by it! Adina believes herself to be from another planet. She sends faxes to her higher ups & attends ‘night school’ with them. All the while she’s just trying to be a normal girl.

Okay, the bad. I found the first half of this book monotonous & repetitive. Whack a solid 50 pages outta there. She’s an alien! On and on. It’s been 84 years etc etc

However!!! The second half I thought was excellent. Extremely moving & tender. A really beautiful portrait of loneliness and belonging.

So that’s why I’m frustrated. A true tale of two halves. At least the good half was at the end and that’s the memory I’m left with.

Was this review helpful?

Beautyland
By Marie-Helene Bertino

This is one of those books that I put off reviewing because of anxiety over not being able to do it justice. I almost let it pass me by until a friend, who knows me better than most people do, demanded that I read it because it has my name written all over it. From the first page I recognised Adina. I know her and I understand her because she is me. Yes, I am also an alien from another planet, trying to make contact with my people.

Anyone who grew up feeling out of place and operating on a different system to everyone else will surely resonate with this. The narrative voice that Bertino has given Adina contains many clues to who she is, and why she thinks the way she does. She speaks of her life in parables, in abstraction, almost in listicles, you can almost imagine the bullet points. Her frank and dispassionate pronouncements on human behaviour are astute, considered and funny, sometimes painfully so.

This book touched my heart in so many ways. My usual stoic reading face broke so many times, in surprise, in empathy, in sympathy and in close to home humour. If there is a word or phrase to describe the feeling you get in your sternum when an orchestra arrives at the zenith of its piece, that's how the last few chapters made me feel.

I love Adina, I love cookie mother and I love the way her life trajectory lines up with Voyager 1's journey from Earth, through our solar system and beyond. A fabulous read, especially for those of us who don't quite feel of this world.

Publication Date: 27th March 2025

Thanks to #Vintage for gifting me an ARC

Was this review helpful?

Beautyland by M.H. Bertino is a coming-of-age story wrapped in an otherworldly premise—Adina is an alien (or so she believes), sent to Earth to determine if it's worth saving. But instead of first contact and cosmic revelations, she gets something far more terrifying: growing up.

Adina drifts through her childhood and adolescence like she's watching from the outside—always on the verge of something, always holding herself back. She’s relatable in the way loneliness is, in the way wanting but not quite accepting feels. Her story unfolds in tender, offbeat snapshots, full of humor and longing, a balance Bertino wields masterfully.

This book reads like a quiet ache, the kind you don’t notice until it lingers. It’s about belonging (or not), understanding (or pretending to), and the strangeness of simply existing. And isn’t that, in some way, the most alien feeling of all?

Was this review helpful?

Some books linger long after you finish them, and I think "Beautyland" is one of them for me. It’s quiet, introspective, and deeply observant - the kind of novel that slowly seeps into you rather than demanding your attention. It took me a little while to settle into its rhythm, but by the second half, I was completely taken in.

The novel follows Adina Giorno, a girl born at the exact moment Voyager 1 is launched into space. From the start, she senses she is different - she possesses knowledge of a distant planet and, with the arrival of a fax machine, begins sending transmissions to her extraterrestrial relatives. As she moves through life, navigating love, loneliness, and the contradictions of human existence, she continues reporting back, searching for connection and understanding.

I loved Adina. She feels so fully realised, so singular yet familiar, that I know I’ll be thinking about her for a long time. I went into this expecting more sci-fi elements, but I wouldn’t necessarily categorise it that way. I think it’s best to approach the book without any fixed ideas of what it’s going to be - it unfolds in its own way, at its own pace, and you'd probably have a better reading experience.

It is incredibly slow, and I think if you don’t enjoy introspective narratives, it might not be for you. But if you do, it’s the kind of book that invites rereading, which is why I’ve already bought a copy of the new paperback.

4.25/5 ⭐

Thank you to NetGalley for an eARC in exchange of my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Adina sees the world in a different way, hearing and reacting to noises that nobody else notices. At night she finds herself in a virtual classroom while sleeping where she is versed in the knowledge of her people and planet who want to know about humankind. She communicates her observations though an old fax machine. We follow her living through the space race from the 60s onwards. I found this story to be strange but compelling.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful, heart-wrenching book. This genuinely made my heart hurt with yearning for the past and how simultaneously beautiful and painful the human experience can be.

Beautyland by Marie-Helene Bertino is definitely a literary fiction novel with sci-fi elements; if you’re going into this expecting it to be a full-blown sci-fi, you’re going to be disappointed. We follow Adina, who believes herself to be an alien sent to earth to observe humans and report on their behaviour via a fax machine back to her people. At its heart, though, this novel is about being and feeling different, and as a neurodivergent person that hit REALLY hard. Adina’s experiences are so relatable and multifaceted, and she’s such an interesting character to follow and root for. I’ll definitely be revisiting this one in the future and am really looking forward to getting myself a physical copy to highlight the hell out of.

Overall, I would highly, highly recommend Beautyland to fans of literary fiction who want an introspective, character-driven story with light speculative elements. This is definitely going to end up being of my favourite books of the year.

Was this review helpful?

Within a few pages, this became a DNF for me. The writing style is choppy and very detached - I felt nothing but was just told stuff. It's written as scenes rather than chapters but what does "Adina: noble Giorno: day" as a scene even mean? I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure exactly what I was expecting from this book - but it was very different to what I had imagined. The blurb intrigued me, but I am not sure the execution of the idea lived up to what the blurb promised.
This was very slow paced and while charming, funny and sweet at times, it was also quite plodding in mundane in other places. Therefore the pacing was a little off. And there were lots of things that didn't really make much sense? Not sure if that was because the premise was a little over my head or I just wasn't understanding what the author was trying to portray. To me, it lacked any real purpose or direction.
The ending was simultaneously dragged out, and yet far too abrupt! I can't really explain that any more without giving spoilers.
Overall, a very strange book.

Was this review helpful?

oh this book was too much for my heart. its was too much for what i was expecting going in! its wasnt sci fi for me, which is what i thought it might be when i chose to read it. and boy am i so overjoyed its not. and more glad that i took a punt and read it(because sci fi isnt my thing but i wanted to try something different because the blurb sounded so good) its so beautiful. its so heartfelt and heartbreaking. there is too much to put into one review. and i dont want to ruin the moment of pure beauty you come across from reading it by giving away those moments in the book
but everyone should read this. especially those who feel or have ever felt a little further away from the group. or not quite sure. or not quite part of it.

Adina is the lovely soul we follow. and her voice story felt like it just wafted over and through you. it flowed off the pages. and a fair few times i just wanted to hug the book, or was it hug Adina. she believes herself to be an alien. and contacts those back home of the goings on in her life and other via a fax machine. we follow her from her first moments all the way up through adulthood. it includes all the important bits and the bits in between that are actually sometimes more important. its not all bad. but its certainly and definitely not all good.
its not a light read. buts its worth it. especially for those who find comfort in books. this one will comfort you.

Was this review helpful?

Ok so, first things first, I absolutely loved this book and would recommend it to anyone who has ever felt like an outsider and struggled to understand those around them. It has a really original premise, following Adina who believes herself to be an alien and contacts her superiors via a fax machine to report on human life. The book chronicles her experiences from childhood through to adulthood, coming of age, making friends, forming relationships with others and going through difficult times, with a tone of voice that makes this funny, sad and memorable.

While this has a sci-fi premise, it’s very much a literary, slice-of-life novel, taking us through the minutiae of the everyday through a series of vignettes. I loved the way misophonia was presented, with references to this across Adina’s life, showing how difficult this can be to deal with and how misunderstood it can be. There was also lots of brilliant and heartbreaking content around not being able to relate to your peers and feeling like an outsider, which I’m sure will resonate with many readers.

A truly beautiful book with a lovable main character, and one which I’m sure I’ll be recommending constantly on here.

Was this review helpful?

This book is out of this world - brilliant!!!
I really enjoyed this book, so much so that I devoured this in record time . I loved all the details and no doubt prove-able events. Adina is loveable always
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me the chance to read this delight of a novel. #Netgalley #BeautyLand

Was this review helpful?

✨ BOOK REVIEW ✨

Beautyland by Marie-Helene Bertino 🌎✨👽
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

This was a wild read! Adina, a girl who believes she’s from another planet, sends transmissions back to her extraterrestrial family while navigating the strangeness of Earth. It’s quirky, tender, and deeply original—exploring what it means to feel like an outsider, never quite at home in your own skin.

The writing is sharp and poetic, and while it took some digesting, I loved the way it made me think about belonging, identity, and the weird beauty of being human. Definitely one that lingers!

Thank you Random House UK, NetGalley, and Marie-Helene Bertino for the copy!

Was this review helpful?

Hmmm, a strange book but I think that you have to make up your own mind if Adina is an alien (or just feels alien) for yourself. It does beautifully map the human condition and the miniscule observations are a delight.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book as an ARC reader from NetGalley. The synopsis of this book is so intriguing. It had me feeling upset, happy and shocked at times. There was a way this author wrote this book that you aren’t sure whether Adina is an alien or if she just actually a women experiencing all these thoughts in regular life. It was so intriguing to see the thought process our character goes through out the story. It was beautifully written and almost felt poetic at times. I loved that even though we aren’t sure if Adina is an alien or not, that it felt relatable as a woman reading it. Overall I really really enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC!
This books follows Adina, a girl who believes she is not from this planet and is instead an alien sent to earth to report on humanity and what it means to be a human. It did take me a minute to warm up to this narrative style, with all the short paragraphs and observations thrown in. However, once I was used to it, I appreciated that it gave the reader a view into Adina’s writing without dedicating a whole chapter to it in a way that might have upset the pacing.

Overall though, what makes this book so special is how heartbreakingly human it is. The way this book followed Adina’s whole life kind of reminded me of how people will say that your mind never really feels old, you’re still generally the same person inside from when you’re 20 to when you’re 80. Obviously the things you experience will change you, but you don’t magically lose the person you were. Adina perfectly embodied this. She grew and developed as a person, but that weird little girl she was is always there. I did tear up kind of consistently from the last third onwards and I think this had a pitch perfect ending.

Was this review helpful?

I have never been an avid fan of science fiction or fantasy books so this was destined to be a poor choice for me to review. Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the chance to ARC this book. Clearly it splits other ARCs but nothing I can say positively about this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book is lovely. The first part of the book when Adina is living at home with her mum growing up has a real charm about it. Her relationships are all quite special when observed as the reader as are her observations on life. This is a really good, almost delicate read about life and living. And whether you are alien or just feel like it sometimes there will be parts of this book that you just get and will love Adina for calling out. A different and unique but worthwhile read.

Was this review helpful?

Liked this plenty.
It was unique and quirky.
Also layered and witty.
Adina is a part alien girl growing up in Philadelphia and sending her observations to her family via fax.
She grows up and keeps gifting her family and the reader with all the warm insights and introspection she has about human life and Earth.

Was this review helpful?