Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Mysterious Case of the Missing Crime Writer is an Icelandic mystery into the sudden disappearance of bestselling Icelandic crime author, Elín S. Jónsdóttir.

Given her status and the fact that nobody has heard from her in a few days, Helgi Reykdal is called in to figure out what happened to her.

While attempting to piece together her last few days, which is trickier than expected given that she was a bit of a loner with no partner or children, there are few people who know anything about her movements.

At the same time we are treated to three other timelines – one from the 1960s, one ten years later in the 70s, and one from 2005 when Elin gave a very in depth interview to a journalist.

For the reader this is crucial as it allows us to piece together a much bigger puzzle than just Elin’s disappearance.

At just 320 pages, the book is relatively short for a modern crime novel, but Jónasson makes every page count.

The pacing is solid, with enough twists and revelations to keep things moving, but there are moments when the darkness threatens to overwhelm the narrative.

Now, let’s talk about the one big caveat: this book is deeply entwined with Jónasson’s previous works and it doesn’t offer much in the way of recap or context, which means that first-time readers may feel a bit confused.

If you haven't read The Darkness (2013), you could easily find yourself frustrated by unresolved subplots, especially about Hulda.

That aside, the book’s structure, with its shifting timelines and layered secrets, makes for a reading experience that’s both challenging and rewarding, it just makes more sense if you've read The Darkness first.

Was this review helpful?

Yet again Ragnar Jonasson delivers another thriller in his latest book The Mysterious Case of the Missing Crime Writer. The pun if one can call it that is not lost on me. Elín S. Jónsdóttir is an extraordinarily successful crime writer who has suddenly gone missing. Or has she? Helgi has been tasked with solving this mystery and he has to accomplish this quickly. Despite her fame and fortune she led a very down-to-earth lifestyle. At least that is how it appears on the surface. In his attempt to locate her he must delve deep into her life. An in-depth scrutiny of her life, however, reveals a very different picture.

This is another episode of the popular DI Helgi Reykdal series. Strewn in the plotline are other characters from previous series and at least one subplot. Having read Jonasson’s books, I have always admired his plot building skills and the build up to a climax. Here again is his signature style that both thrills and rivets the reader keeping one glued to the novel until the last page. I not only learned a lot more of Helgi’s character but also that of the other characters who are part of this series. I loved how he subtly explores various issues like abuse, social norms of the past and present and their effect on people, their actions and behaviour. Some are still prevalent to this day. This was skilfully woven into the tapestry of the mystery, yet it was there for all to read without sounding preachy. I love this role that Jonasson adopts of a loving parent correcting society through his writing. The main protagonist Helgi is analytical yet sensitive with his own inadequacies. There is a certain quiet strength in the man. This has always endeared me to him. It seemed more realistic rather than the usual spiel of tough detective. Jonasson travels back and forth in time providing the reader with small insights into the mystery that add up to a big thrill. As with all his books there is a twist in this tale.

Despite being a series, the DI H Reykdal mysteries can be read on their own. In each book of the series the mystery is completely solved. That’s true of this thriller too. Unfortunately, this book ends. on a cliff hanger. There is a persistent sub plot or two that do not finish with this book. I’m guessing they get solved in the sequel which I also hope will be out soon or Jonasson is going to get stalker e mails from me. Lol

Nevertheless, an exciting thriller particularly for fans of the Golden Age Mysteries. Kudos Jonasson for your latest thriller and awaiting the sequel with anticipation.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Michael Joseph for an arc in exchange for an honest review.

What does a bank robbery in the 1970s, an interview in 2005, and a criminal investigation in 2012 have in common? This book!

An aging crime writer disappears without a trace. A police officer who loves reading crime novels starts investigating her disappearance - and what unfolds is a slowly developing mystery told through interweaving timelines that gradually blur the line between past and present.

The first half is gripping. The Icelandic setting is cold, quiet, and adds a sense of unease to the mystery. The alternating timelines add intrigue, peeling back secrets layer by layer as the past and the present converge at the book's end. I really liked the story's clever reference to Agatha Christie's brief disappearance in the 1960s.

By the end of the book I found myself wishing for some more depth, both in the characters and in the final reveal. The character's back stories, emotions, and motivations could have been fleshed out a bit more. Some threads in the book felt like they simply fizzled out instead of typing up neatly at the end. The protagonist police officer was struggling to come to terms with emotional trauma but this wasn't fully explored in the book either. For a brief moment I thought that my book was missing a few pages or chapters because the ending felt a bit abrupt. It does make me curious though if another one may pick up where we left this one.

Still, I quite liked the hook of a crime writer becoming the mystery herself! This book is quite a readable page-turner, especially if you are into literary mysteries with a Nordic vibe. Go in expecting a slow unravel rather than a fast-paced thriller!

Was this review helpful?

For me, there’s nothing better than reading a crime novel which has an element of crime fiction or crime writing in the storyline. It’s like taking something you love and multiplying it by ten. I was such a huge fan of The Sanatorium, where we met Helgi for the first time. His love of detective fiction was a real highlight and I even made a note of the books he was reading or had in his library to read myself later on. With this book, Ragnar Jonasson has taken things a step further and made the entire premise of the book about a crime writer, rather than it being an addition to the main storyline. I couldn’t ask for more as a fan of this authors work or as a fan of the genre.

This story sees Helgi investigating the disappearance of successful Icelandic crime author, Elín S. Jónsdóttir. Her books are loved by crime fans all over the world but Elín is notoriously secretive about her personal life. This makes things slightly trickier for Helgi as he has to persuade her close circle of friends to reveal any information which might help to find her.

I just loved the format of this book. The majority of the story follows Helgi and his investigation, but, the author's story told through a transcript of an interview she previously invited a journalist to record but not publish. As a clever crime writer, there are obviously clues and reasons for her behaviour but it all has to be painstakingly pieced together - with events from Elín's past also linking with the present investigation.

I thought it was brilliant that Ragnar Jonasson did an 'Alfred Hitchcock' and put himself in the book - "as well as some modern translations and a recent crime novel that Helgi had heard of, by the translator of some of the Christies." As a huge Christie fan, I also loved the parallels to Agatha Christie's own mysterious disappearance for 11 days back in 1926. These little references to crime fiction really make this series stand out as the perfect crime stories for crime fiction fans!

I loved everything about The Mysterious Case of the Missing Crime Writer and am very much hoping for a third book in the series!

Was this review helpful?

I have read a couple of books by Ragnar Jonasson and I struggle to see how he can be described as “one of the greatest crime writers out there” as some reviews claim. His books are not bad but they seem to lack the depth of other authors in this genre so to describe him as one of the greatest is a stretch. But once you temper your expectations his books are good and very readable page-turners but more nordic-noir-lite This one features a very puzzling mystery indeed which draws parallels with another mysterious disappearance that is a big subplot in the book that is left completely unresolved, This may be addressed in another book in the series if this is a series. The ending however is so abrupt I was left wondering if a final chapter was missing.. It’s not even a cliff-hanger, it just stops and parts of the story are left unresolved so it was a very frustrating ending considering the time invested in reading and investing in the story, I’ll be keeping an eye out when this is released to see if there is a final chapter and the ARC was incomplete.

Was this review helpful?

Welcome back to the young detective Helgi, introduced in the author's last wonderful book. He has to solve the mystery of a missing author and the book features an intoxicating combination of sleuthing, Helgi's own life issuers and previous mysteries laid out by the author.

As always the writing is excellent as is the plotting and it was an engrossing read.

Was this review helpful?

Another great read from a new author to me. As with the last book in this series there are lots of twists and turns. My emotions were up and down and my heart in my mouth on the last page...where the reader is left wondering if a bad deed has definitely taken place.
I really enjoyed this book and know that anyone who likes a murder mystery should put this book on their list to read - they will not be disappointed.
I am looking forward to read the next book in this series.

Was this review helpful?

"It was his belief that all books provided an insight into their author's psyche. After all, it stood to reason that authors must reveal something of themselves in their pages, either deliberately or unconsciously, though no doubt you often had to read between the lines to discover it."

Ragnar Jonasson's novel is about bestselling crime author, Elín S. Jónsdóttir, one night she goes missing. There are no clues as to her disappearance and it is up to young detective, Helgi, to crack the case before it's leaked to the press.
As he interviews those closest to her he soon begins to realise her life wasn't quite as it seemed. If anything, her past is even stranger than her stories.

I devoured this book in one go. It was just too good to put down. I knew I was going to like this one as I have enjoyed previous series written by this author.

As soon as this story begins there is no room to pause or speculate the truth behind this crime writer's disappearance. Page after page there are clues that connect to stories of the past and present. I had my theories and although one of them came true there were many more I had not seen coming.

Much as the previous book "Death at the Sanatorium" this novel keeps you hooked right through till the end. I am hoping there is more to come from this story.

Was this review helpful?

Helgi, a young police officer, is tasked with the case of missing crime writer, Elin.
As he interviews Elin's small circle of close friends, her secrets are gradually revealed.
This book is quite slow paced and there's plenty of time to work out the mystery before the actual reveal. Then it skids abruptly to an end leaving one aspect unresolved. At first I thought I was missing some pages!
Not your typical dark book from this genre, a much easier read.

Was this review helpful?

I was looking forward to this book with it being from an Icelandic author, as I was expecting a different sense of humour, or difference in the way things are described, but sadly I just didn’t find this book could hold my interest. There was nothing against it really, but it was just a bit beige. Also when I got to the ending I wondered if some pages had accidental been missed off, as it ends abruptly and without warning; I can’t even call it a cliff hanger as it feels like it ends mid sentence, not with a tbc ending. There is lots of back and forth with timings and characters so it can be hard to keep track of things if you’re not used to that, especially with the names not being ones we’re used to hearing. Overall it’s not a bad book, it’s an ok read, it’s just one I’d struggle to recommend

Was this review helpful?

This is the second in the Icelandic crime series featuring young detective Helgi. He is charged with finding out what has happened to a famous author who was last heard of setting off for the hills surrounding the town where she and Helgi live. Jonasson really offers three plots in this novel: the missing author, Helgi’s private life and references to the unsolved mystery of the disappearance of his predecessor Hulda whose life and career have been addressed in three of Jonasson’s previous novels.
Helgi is in a new, happy relationship after finally breaking up with his abusive partner Bergthora but the latter has other ideas and is stalking Helgi’s new girlfriend. Jonasson switches the narrative easily between Hulda’s life many years ago and the current year of the missing author. It is good to have references to the Hulda series of novels and to be reintroduced to her character again.
There are some frightening moments in this novel and psychological tensions build. The ending is unexpected and left me eager for the third in this great series.
Highly recommended. Thank you very much to the publishers for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed Jonasson’s 2018 novel The Darkness. Unfortunately this is the 2nd book of his I’ve read since that was very disappointing.
The story jumps about suddenly adding in details from previous cases, which don’t appear to add to the plot. The domestic violence issues are introduced but not followed up – so why add it in?

Once the mystery is unravelled it only seems to take a couple of phone calls – no police processes to be followed.
The sudden ending left me wondering if I was missing a final chapter or two from my copy.

Was this review helpful?

Helgi, a Reykjavik Detective, investigates the case of missing novelist Elin, whilst also dealing with upheaval in his own romantic life.

I enjoyed the characters and the setting of this novel, but it doesn't really work as a complete work of fiction in it's own right. It is a sequel to a previous novel featuring Helgi, and also links to a previous detective series about the missing detective Hulda. If you haven't read any of these (and I haven't), then this novel is somewhat of a slight and unsatisfying read.

Was this review helpful?

The famous author, Elín Jonsdottir has gone missing, and it's down to detective Helgi, to work out what has happened. The mystery surrounding Elin's disappearance is explored alongside two other storylines in the background - one of a missing detective who had been investigating an old bank robbery, and the other being Helgi's personal life.

The ending was a surprise, and not what I was expecting. I wasn't a fan of the abrupt cliffhanger ending, but nonetheless, I enjoyed the story.

Thank you to #NetGalley and the publisher Michael Joseph, Penguin Random House for the advance copy of #TheMysteriousCaseoftheMissingCrimeWriter.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Michael Joseph and NetGalley for ARC.
Helgi Reykdal is taking some leave from the Helsinki police force to care for his mother in his home town of Akureyri, taking the opportunity to spend some time in the family bookshop and have a think about his life. When a famous and famously reclusive crime writer is reported missing, Helgi's boss recalls him as he's something of a crime fiction devotee, particularly Golden Age.
This book wears its Golden Age influences on its sleeve and is enjoyable, with the more modern fashion for a bit of reflection on the detective's home milieu blended in well so it's not merely a pastiche. Like its Golden Age predecessors character and place are subsidiary to plot but they're not ignored completely.
The abrupt and open cliff hangar ending will not be to everyone's taste, but it's a bit of a hallmark of Jonasson, who is always worth a read.

Was this review helpful?

This Scandi mystery focuses on the disappearance of Elín Jónsdóttir, an author who hasn’t been seen for several days. Detective Helgi Reykdal is assigned the case, and cuts short his leave to investigate due to his own love of books. We also see flashbacks throughout the book of Reykdal’s predecessor, who also seems to have disappeared without a trace. I love reading books that focus on books, so I really enjoyed it! I found the characters interesting to read about, and for me it was a great cosy crime read. It also left the odd thread that felt like it could be continued into a second book!

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyable read with a great mixture of intrigue and literary references. I would be interested to read more of this author. Would have rated higher if I hadn’t found the ending a little abrupt. The main character was an empathetic character with a psychotic ex-girlfriend, brilliantly portrayed. Having known people in similar relationships, that rang true.!

Was this review helpful?

The sequel to Death at the Sanatorium, Helgi is now a fully signed up member of the police and is asked to investigate the disappearance of a mystery writer. This is an intriguing crime novel and hopefully Helgi will be at work on a new case soon.

Was this review helpful?

There is nothing that Helgi, a young detective, likes better that to sit surrounded by books and reading one, possibly crime related. When Elin a crime novelist who has written ten book and now says she has retired goes missing who better than to get Helgi to investigate. His investigation is based mainly on her long standing friends from her university days and her current publisher. It soon becomes apparent that not everyone is telling the truth but in order to find the truth Helgi realizes that he is going to have to be cunning as more secrets from the past stat emerging. Set in Iceland the weather doesn't help and no wonder sitting reading is Helgi's favourite past time.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the artwork on the cover; striking and intriguing. I’m not familiar with the works of this author, but I’ve read a few crime stories set in Iceland. I like the backdrop of that country and it adds a different dimension to the storytelling. In this book, a crime writer goes missing and the investigation into her disappearance starts to uncover unexpected secrets. The investigating officer is a big Agatha Christie fan and that’s clear from the way the narrative develops and the dialogue, it’s curiously old fashioned, but also up to the minute. There’s nothing gory; cosy crime with a nod to the classic Christie crime era. I enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?