Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Modern take on Greek mythology but I found it quite a boring read - it's set up didn't lend great to an ebook either, the family trees didn't work

Was this review helpful?

So I adored Herc and told basically everyone I knew to read it. So when I saw Aphrodite was available by Rogers on, there was no doubt I was going to read it.

It's a fantastic deep look into the stories of Aphrodite, told from her very beginning to...well I won't spoil the ending for you.
It takes aspects of her tales, where she seems to have 2 origin stories and makes that make sense. It gives her a personality that is deep and ambiguous, well beyond just the incredibly beautiful goddess of Love.

I would say I prefer Herc, but I think that's because I enjoyed some of the more comedic aspects of that book, whereas this, although it had the odd amusing moment, had a lot less of it.

But overall this was a fantastic book. Highly recommended for all lovers of mythology. You won't be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Aphrodite is written in the same brilliant style as Herc, with stand-out voices and fantastic characterisation. My favourite POV character was Ares - which isn't something I think I've ever said about Greek myth before!

Was this review helpful?

I am in love with this refreshing take on Aphrodite. And this is from someone who had to DNF the author's debut book Herc.

Phoenicia's writing style has definitely matured for this book and while the whole vibe is still more light-hearted than your usual retelling it flows a lot better. There are still a few overly silly chapters thrown in here and there but they are few and far between, and honestly you need them as a break to the absolute DRAMA of Aphrodite's life.

I am in awe with how the author has so beautiful woven multiple versions of the myths together seamlessly. And we even have some lesser known aspects of Aphrodite's past thrown in too which was really interesting to see. For once we have a book that doesn't just focus on Aphrodite as a beautiful but jealous person. Instead we get to see the woman who sparked the Trojan War, complete with all her scheming. And I ate that up.

The only flaw I could find with the book was that the timeline gets a little messed up. Which I'm sure is intentional from the author but there were a couple of scenes that confused me since events were happening but then the key factors for those were introduced later in the book. (I swear Eris is mentioned way before she's born?)

But no matter, I still had a brilliant time reading it and I was genuinely sad when it finished because I just wanted more.

Big thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the chance to review the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Where to even start with this?? It’s a Greek mythology retelling but not as you know it.
Though if you’ve read Herc and enjoyed it, you’ll have some idea what to expect from Aphrodite.

I’m fully riding on the Greek mythology retelling bandwagon, but this is my first that features Aphrodite front and centre. I loved the rise and fall of Olympus from her POV (and the other characters along the way) and her take on all the main players in the Trojan war.

The interweaving of fate was a new angle for me, which made this fresh and original. The dialogue and narration is not going to be for everyone but give it a chance and you’ll absolutely never look at the Gods the same way again!

Was this review helpful?

Compared to other retellings of Greek mythology that I have read this very much feels as though written to appeal to younger readers in its style. Nothing wrong with that, at all, especially if it stirs an interest in learning more about ancient civilisations! Each chapter is written as a POV of different characters, Aphrodite’s footnotes are particularly hilarious, and there is much humour throughout. Some liberties are taken with source material (acknowledged by the author) to make this a light, enjoyable take on the stories of the goddess of love. Thank you to the publisher for the opportunity to read a pre-publication for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know what it is about this one I cannot get into. Aphrodite seems interesting enough as a character and I like seeing all these other gods from her perspective but I found it hard to be invested in Aphrodite/the book as a whole.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely amazing read this was an Aphrodite retelling that’s full of love, betrayal and more! The footnotes are written in Aphrodite’s POV which was totally sassy and was one of many things I adored.

Was this review helpful?

Firstly, thank you to Netgalley and HQ Stories for the opportunity to read and review this ARC!

As someone who is obsessed with greek mythology and its retellings, I was really excited for this one. however, for me, this fell flat.

Something I really don’t like in retellings is the use of modern slang, personal preference but i want to feel like the setting is ancient Greece, not the modern day world where Aphrodite probably has a TikTok account. for me the constant use of ‘humour’ and slang became very old, very quickly

As I was reading I felt like the flips between pov’s didn’t really work and made for a confusing read, due to all of the characters having the same tone of voice. it feels like the author was trying to cram in as many stories about aphrodite as possible, but it ended up being a very choppy read

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely amazing read this was an Aphrodite retelling that’s full of love, betrayal and more! The footnotes are written in Aphrodite’s POV which was totally sassy and was one of many things I adored.

There were POV changes from the other Gods. which I would have found jarring but they were all so differently written and hilarious which made me love it! I also felt like there was almost a reality TV vibe to it with the povs feeling like confessionals, which is totally valid for all the chaos that would happen on Olympus.

Overall an absolutely brilliant read and I will be snagging a copy on release day!

Was this review helpful?

Omg! Where do I begin? I absolutely loved this book! There was so much I didn’t know about Aphrodite. This story is full of love and betrayal, how she fights for everything she wants. Expect multiple POV, humour (obviously), war, strong female energy. Phoenicia has made another Greek myth comeback to life! If I could I would give it more than 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

I love a book about the Greek gods and goddesses, and this was up there with the best I've read. Mixing traditional legends and myths, Aphrodite is given a chance to tell her story about the most dysfunctional immortal family that ever existed! In doing so, she rattles through all the well-loved myths and legends with a wry and insightful commentary into the chaotic world to which she has made herself belong through sheer force of will. Her story is funny, sad, tragic, hopeful and above all interesting, and makes the readers look at the gods and goddesses of legend in a whole new light.
As Aphrodite is the goddess of love , she has done her job well selling her family to the reader. They're angry, vengeful, sulky, lusting, vulgar and badly behaved, but you can't help loving them all. I admit to a particularly soft spot for Prometheus now - what a legend he is!
This is a definite five-star read - in telling Aphrodite's story, Phoenicia Rogerson has aimed for the sky and caught the sun, moon and stars of the ancient Greek world.
Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

4.75 stars

I loved this retelling! While it appeared at first that I was in for another standard “feminist” myth retelling, this book ends up going in a completely different direction with Aphrodite taking matters into her own hands (sometimes literally) and asking: how does one take down the seemingly omnipotent king of the gods?

Phoenicia Rogerson maintains the humour and sarcasm that I loved in Herc, as well as the different narration styles for each POV, so that every major character has a distinct narrative voice. I loved how she writes the dynamics between the gods - they bicker like the messed-up family they are, it’s almost like watching reality TV. She strikes the perfect balance between laugh-out-loud funny and heartbreakingly introspective, and I absolutely loved the character arc Aphrodite has throughout the book. Bonus points for including both Diomedes (my underrated fav) and references to the Aeneid, aka my favourite epic poem.

The book remains relatively canon compliant, yes there are a few creative liberties taken with the timeline - which is usually a bit wibbly-wobbly in Greek myth anyway - and inserting Aphrodite into a few stories she doesn’t originally appear in, but these creative liberties I can forgive. (What I can’t forgive is the fact that The Song of Achilles was clearly used as a reference for both Achilles and Patroclus. Madeline Miller you will answer for your crimes of character assassination.) I do also wish that the other female characters were a little less one-dimensional and annoying, for example Hestia who is pretty much reduced to a clingy people-pleaser. They massacred my girl :(

The book is relatively accessible, with family trees and footnotes explaining the many, many characters mentioned (the footnotes are written from Aphrodite’s POV and as such are characteristically sassy), but because the book covers so much content I wouldn’t recommend it to complete newbies to the genre. That said, if you have a little knowledge of Greek mythology and you want a fun and unique retelling, definitely give this a read!

Was this review helpful?

I found Aphrodite a fun easy lighthearted read, but with a YA vibe. The pacing, formatting (some conversations read like text messages), and language used seemed to me to be written to appeal to a younger audience. I definitely had a fun time reading this book, but I wouldnt describe it as a serious retelling - more a quirky, lighthearted approach to Greek Myth. I think if you are a fan of Herc (same author) or perhpaps Bea Fitzgeralds YA myths this might be your sort of story.
Sprinkled with humour but some of the language and especially the nicknames made me cringe (though I was glad to see atleast one other character criticised one of Aphrodite's nicknames). I still found it engaging and read it in 3 days, but not something I would rush to read again. The Trojan war featured a lot more heavily than I expected and although it was fun to get different perspectives on Aphrodite's relationships with those around her (particularly Prometheus, Ares and Hephaestus) there were a lot more POVs other than Aphrodite than I was expecting.

All in all: Enjoyable entertaining read

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this book wasn’t for me. I hate to give bad reviews but I didn’t enjoy the way this was written.

Was this review helpful?

Well that was brilliant fun!

Aphrodite is maybe one of the most known / popular Greek goddesses and I loved this retelling of her life from her birth to her days at Mount Olympus. I can't emphasise enough how much I adored this version of Aphrodite - wickedly funny, caustic, fierce, playful and cheeky yet with a soft centre.

It's totally unique and very different from any Greek Mythology retelling I've ever read and I appreciated the research whilst loving the spin and interpretation.

The characterisation is simply brilliant and the God's and Godesses leap from the pages and it's really engaging. Each has their own distinct personality. Told in first person it's like being a fly on the wall in the Palace of Olympus. I enjoyed the dialogue and interaction between the characters and the way it felt like watching a reality TV show.

The writing is really vibrant, wry and witty. It's very contemporary which I think adds a whole other dimension to a market which some say has become over saturated. An absolute breath of fresh air which shows history is anything but stuffy and boring.

Throughout there are Aphrodites footnotes - I absolutely loved them and they really made me laugh. They are a delightul addition and help the story flow. I'd happily read a full book of these observations!

This is a book not to be missed. I don't think you have to be an expert on the Greek Myths to enjoy this. Phoenicia explains what's happening but it doesn't feel like a lesson at all. I highly recommend and give it all the 5 stars it deserves!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and HQ for the advanced digital copy.

“Aphrodite” the novel was at times gossipy and young. That is not a criticism, being gossipy and young can be very enjoyable!

At the beginning, I kept comparing it to the strength of voice and retelling of Aphrodite’s perspective in Claire North’s “House of Odysseus”, but the characterisation was more like Bea Fitzgerald’s YA “Girl, Goddess, Queen”.

It’s a fine retelling, in that it successfully attempts to weave in a great many myths and still keep a fresh, adolescent style.

I didn’t always love the fourth wall breaks in the footnotes, but I did like the family trees throughout.

As an intro to Greek myth retellings, this novel is a good jumping off point. The characters are recognisable and react to their world in a Kardashian/soap opera way.

I would recommend this to a younger audience, 17-21 for example. And certainly, if Aphrodite is one of your favourites in the Greek pantheon, this is not one to miss.

Was this review helpful?

A retelling of the Greek goddess Aphrodite from the award-winning author of Herc. A fun, pacy novel backed by a lot of research. However it's considerably less about Aphrodite than the title suggests, with the entire pantheon of Greek gods and Titans weighing in on their story. It's hard to differentiate their voices and really connect with any of the characters. An interesting read but not a standout in the genre.

Was this review helpful?

3⭐️

This book is pretty much just a bunch of Greek myths shoved into a book and made to link to Aphrodite and not doing very well at any of them


I wasn’t a big fan of the way this was written, this was suppose to be set at the beginning of time so why was it written with a lot of modern slang/sayings it felt very out of place

Some of the dialogue was very cringe aswell and took away from the plot of the book

I feel like this book portrayed the gods in too human of a way they are gods they would not think or behave in ways that human’s would be expected to and I don’t think this book explored that enough it felt like it was written to much from the human experience

A lot less serious than a lot of Greek mythology books it also doesn’t really follow Greek mythology too closely which did annoy me in parts

I didn’t like that they made Eros so childlike it was creepy

It was overall a fun book in places but nothing else it wasn’t written particularly well nor was the plot overly interesting everything about it just kind of was okay except for the ending the ending was underwhelming and overall just kind of shit

Thank you to Netgalley and HQ for the digital arc

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Phoenicia Roberson, HQ, and NetGalley for the e-arc in exchange for honest review.

Some people will love it, some people will hate it. Aphro-marmite.

I loved the comedic writing to a certain point, and then it felt overdone and cheap. The characters felt one-dimensional and the flipping between multiple POV was jarring, especially because they were all in first person.

The nicknames pushed me over the edge and telling “Prom” something is a “you problem”… sorry, it’s a dnf.

Was this review helpful?