Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was a fun spring time read. Magic and romance, quirky, friendships and book clubs. At its heart it looked at all different kinds of love and I enjoyed each characters story.

Was this review helpful?

Within Cambridge there's a group meeting regularly to talk about books. It just happens they are also witches. At the moment there's a lot happening in the small corner of the world where they reside, and it relates a lot of magic. This isn't a book about a single person but a collection of people, with magic being a connecting part of their lives, whether they have it or not. The story is told from the perspective of multiple characters, so that we are privy to a more complete picture of what's happening. There's a fair bit of drama in all their lives and magic can be helpful and not so helpful for all of them. Some of what they thought was good might not be totally good. And some of the magic that was problematic may be less so than thought. I think what it comes down to is that the magic is part of them for good and not so good. How they accept it or not can make a difference in their lives.

I really enjoyed this book, especially after the story sets itself up. There are mysteries to solve and deal with and there are risks and fortunes (so to speak) to be found in their lives. We get to know these people, for good and bad, in happiness and in some desperation. We discover there's dark magic about and we learn about how we can cooperate to work things out at times. Overall, I give this 3.5 stars and would like to thank Netgalley and Allison and Busby for giving me a free advanced reader copy. My feedback is totally voluntary.

Was this review helpful?

"The Witches of Cambridge" is a novel in true magic realism style. It is recommended for readers of Alice Hoffman and Sarah Addison Allen, and I understand why. Both the writing style and content can easily be compared to these authors, in the best possible way. I really enjoyed this book! The characters all have a touch of magic in them, and I loved how they connected with each other and could give and take from each other's subtle magic to help and guide their lives. Some also wish to exploit magic, which added an interesting aspect to the book.

There are multiple points of view, so the novel tackles several topics: heartbreak, infidelity, new love, and life in general. There are many references to art in this book, both paintings and literature. And since several of the characters speak French, there are many French sentences throughout. Even though I don't speak French myself, it didn't matter. I felt it added a nice atmosphere to the book, and I don't think I missed anything by not understanding it.

Reading this book was a mix of emotions, including sadness, anger, but also joy. It was lovely to see the camaraderie between the characters and how they found each other. I absolutely recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

would like to thank netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this book

a group of witches that meet at monthly to discuss books ... what else do you need to know

they each bring to the group their own powers unique to them which is about to test them all...

not a bad read though its a slow burner....

Was this review helpful?

I did get a little confused at first with the narrative changing perspectives however, once I found my groove I really enjoyed this book! I loved picturing the book club above Magdalen Tower and really just the love for books throughout the story as well! The relationships were crafted so beautifully and so full of romance and magic. I enjoyed the variety of relationships too: mother and daughter, sisters, unrequited love. Each so beautifully written and developed! I really enoyed!

Was this review helpful?

I have read this book on its first release and enjoyed it. The magical component is secondary to the bonds shared between the members of the coven, although it proves very useful at times. Great characters and wonderfully written I recommend this as an easy and enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Not quite what I was expecting but an ok read nonetheless. Magic takes a back seat to the relationship dynamics, which is fine but just not what I anticipated reading about.

Was this review helpful?

I actually read and reviewed this in 2016. Here's the review I wrote then: A pleasant light read! Try this one if you enjoy stories told by several women and which have a healthy dose of whimsy. Yes the idea of witches is a little out there and yes the characters could be more fleshed out but you'll still find this a worthy read. It's refreshing. I had not read van Praag before so thanks to NETGALLEY for the ARC which introduced us. Thumbs up for this one!

Was this review helpful?

** spoiler alert ** This was a fast read, some good thoughts and character development arcs, females being there for each other, and sprinkles of art references.
However, while magic was central to one of the storylines and mentioned quite a bit, it still felt like a separate element. And the setting didn't feel like being in Cambridge either.
While the storylines were fun to read, and the revelations and reactions, they were too many and too fast, making it a good book to speed through, but not memorable. I wish I had more time with the characters to empathise with them. I reeeally wanted to love this book.
Also, everyone just having found the love of their life in an instant? And the witch knowing when one person did magic on them but not when the other one did? Some things just felt like they didn't make sense. And ethically wrong but no consequences. And the casual acceptance of them being witches? It is convenient but not what I expected.
The witches supporting each other and having a book club were perhaps the highlights for me. So... would I recommend it? Yes, for a fun read.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of, The Witches of Cambridge, by Menna van Praag, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Amadine Bissett is an empath, though she mainly keeps that to herself. There is a lot of drama in this book. Im not really into witches so I found this book, to be an ok read.

Was this review helpful?

A charming witchy read, this novel explores the lives of a coven living in Cambridge. There are many characters with many stories going on. However I enjoyed the setting, and the ultimate outcomes for all the characters was satisfying.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this book as I love Menna van Praag's writing and was a couple of chapters in before realising that I'd read it before, in 2018! This must be a reprint/reissue. Anyway, I was delighted to read it again and enjoyed it just as much as I did the first time. The characters are great, the magic is fun and the recipes sound absolutely delicious. The use of various herbs, flowers and spices for different spells was intriguing and it's left me with a longing for a pistachio cream croissant.

Was this review helpful?

The premise itself holds promise: a group of witches living in a university town, each possessing their own unique magical abilities. However, much of the story feels like it revolves around human drama rather than the exploration of witchcraft as a central, untamable force. Magic in this book often comes across as a tool for navigating personal struggles rather than as a profound, transformative aspect of the characters’ lives.

The narrative spends much of its energy on interpersonal relationships, exploring family dynamics, love, and personal growth. While this approach may work for some readers, I found it distracting from the essence of witchcraft itself. The witches' powers are often treated as secondary to their emotional journeys, which ultimately weakens the sense of magic as something greater than mere personal development. The magic is occasionally intriguing, such as when it's used to reveal secrets or navigate difficult situations, but it never feels like a driving force of the plot—it’s more of a background element, rarely at the forefront.

What disappointed me most was the missed opportunity to dive deep into the craft itself. Magic, when it does appear, feels almost like an accessory—something to help resolve a problem or advance the plot, rather than something that shapes the characters' lives and decisions. There’s little exploration of the history, rituals, or the true weight of magic, leaving it feeling more like a supernatural gimmick than an authentic part of the witches’ identities.

Another frustration lies in the way the supernatural elements are incorporated into what could easily have been a conventional story. The witches’ powers sometimes feel like an afterthought, added into an otherwise human-centric narrative. The magic is there, but it doesn’t hold the gravitas or mystery that one might expect in a tale centered on witchcraft. Instead, it often becomes secondary to human conflict and emotional resolutions.

In conclusion, The Witches of Cambridge is a novel with charm, but it doesn’t fully capture the essence of witchcraft in the way I had hoped. For those of us who crave a deeper, more authentic exploration of magic and its complexities, this book may leave something to be desired. The witches here feel too human, too caught up in their personal stories, and not nearly connected enough to the ancient, unyielding force that witchcraft should represent.

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Cambridge is a journey through grief, love and friendship as a Coven of Witches within the rarified confines of Cambridge, find themselves confronted with their own emotional struggles, and need to rely on their friendship to survive.
It took me a little while to settle into the storyline as there are several different characters, each with their own set of emotional complications to meet in the first chapters:
- Amandine, is fearful that her husband is having an affair but does not dare confront him for fear of the consequences
- Noa, is a student with an unusual and potentially dangerous power where she can see secrets but is completely to tell the truth
- Kat, Cosmia & George are entangled in a messy family situation
- Héloïse is dealing with heartbreaking grief
- and Santiago, well he could cause trouble for everyone.
I enjoyed the character connections and how our protoganists come together in the story. I particularly found Héloïse's story to be touching.
A slow-burning and gentle tale, with both humorous and tragic moments - reflective of life.

Was this review helpful?

✨3 stars✨

I found this to be an okay witchy read. I definitely think the first few chapters were the most engaging.

However, I think my main issues with this book is that the author tried to juggle too many characters and their respective storylines which resulted in them all feeling quite flat and underdeveloped. There just wasn’t enough time spent exploring them especially as this book just wasn’t long enough to do so effectively in my opinion.

If you’re in the mood for a witchy read, or if you have enjoyed this author’s other books then you should give this a try. However, it just wasn’t for me sadly.

I received an ARC from the publishers via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

the Cambridge witches meet every month on one of the college rooftops to discuss books and other things. good story.

Was this review helpful?

This was a weird one cos it had all the cosy witchy vibes I love, but it was kinda disjointed and felt like multiple stories squished together into one. The pacing was all over the place, and I just didn't connect with any characters enough to be invested. Would reccomend, but don't think about the story too much.

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Cambridge by Menna Van Praag is such a cool book. I love this theme so much! It's totally my vibe. I totally recommend everyone to read this book as fast as they can because it's really good and the characters are fantastic.

Was this review helpful?

Book review for.
The witches of Cambridge by Menna van Praag.
This was a good read. I did like the cover and blurb of this book. I did find it to be a slow read. I read in a few days. I did like Amandine. I liked the writing style. I did like George and Noa. I really didn't like Santiago. I liked the ending.


Blurb.
The Cambridge University witches meet every month on the roof of one of the city's many colleges to discuss books among other things, but lately the ties that bind them have begun to unravel.



Amandine, professor of art history and empath, has the power to feel the emotions of those around her. Lately though, she might have wished for her student Noa's ability to hear others' innermost thoughts and secrets, to understand what is amiss in the group and in her marriage. Mathematics professor and master spellcaster Kat struggles with unrequited love, but refuses to use magic to win anyone's heart. Her sister, Cosima, is not above using such powers, sprinkling pastries in her bakery with sugar and enchantment. But when Cosima sets her sights on the love of Kat's life, she sets off a chain of events that turns each of the witches' worlds upside down . . .

#thewitchesofcambridge
@MennavanPraag
@Allison&Busby
#MagicRomance
#WomensFantasyFiction
#MagicRomanceeBooks
#netgalley

Was this review helpful?