Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Inspirada en mitos, leyendas, cuentos de hadas y diversas tradiciones literarias, esta antología ofrece una visión rica y variada del papel de videntes, oráculos y profetas a lo largo de culturas y épocas.

Algo que destaca especialmente es la variedad de enfoques: no se limita a lo clásico o a lo esperado. Hay textos con ambientaciones antiguas, visiones modernas e incluso toques futuristas. Esta mezcla mantiene el interés constante y muestra cuán versátil puede ser un tema cuando se trata con creatividad.

Aunque no soy muy lectora de poesía, me sorprendió lo mucho que me gustó esa parte del libro.



Gracias NetGalley por el ARC

Was this review helpful?

this was a really well done collection of stories and poems that I was looking for and enjoyed the way it was used in the genre. The authors did a strong job in writing this and am excited for more.

Was this review helpful?

Disappointing execution despite an intriguing concept.

I was initially drawn to "Seers and Sibyls" by M.J. Pankey because the theme, a collection of short stories and poems centered around those who "see," sounded right up my alley. The concept had so much potential, and having enjoyed some of Pankey's previous work, I came in with fairly high expectations.

Unfortunately, the execution left a lot to be desires, The stories felt underdeveloped, and the overall tone read more like a school project than a polished literary work. There were moments that hinted at deeper meaning or emotional resonance, but they were fleeting and often lost in uneven pacing or overly simplistic prose.

While the idea was appealing, the collection failed to hold my attention. I truly wanted to enjoy this, but in the end, it felt more like a missed opportunity, than a memorable read.

Was this review helpful?

✨ Seers and Sibyls edited by MJ Pankey is one of those anthologies that quietly sneaks up on you and then completely takes over your thoughts. This collection is all about oracles, prophets, seers, sibyls, and every other name you can give someone cursed or blessed with the ability to see what’s coming. And let me tell you… some of these stories hit hard. 👁️‍🗨️🕯️

Every piece explores a different corner of this theme, some tragic, some powerful, some straight-up eerie. I loved that it wasn’t just the typical Greek oracle vibes. You get modern takes, ancient myths, futuristic glimpses. It’s a whole spectrum of storytelling.

A few of my favorites were "Diwona" by Misty Urban, which had me deep in the Mediterranean Bronze Age drama, and “The Oracle’s Burden,” a poem that made me pause and just sit with my feelings. That one low-key gutted me.

This book really captures that bittersweet ache of knowing too much, being misunderstood, or carrying a truth no one wants to hear. It doesn’t romanticize foresight. It interrogates it, and I loved that.

If you’re into slow burning wisdom, a touch of tragedy, and lyrical writing from a whole chorus of voices, this is definitely worth your time. Perfect for fans of myth-inspired anthologies or anyone who’s ever wondered what it’d actually feel like to know the future. Spoiler alert: it’s not always sunshine and crystal balls.

4.5 stars 🌟 and a very solid yes, I will be thinking about this for a while.

Was this review helpful?

I can't think of a story I didn't like, and as mentioned in the introduction, this collection really benefitted from the inclusion of stories from all over the globe. I wasn't expecting all of the poetry (it's not a genre I typically read) and was surprised by how much I enojyed it! My favorite was probably the Cupid one. I wasn't expecting anything like it and even if it was predictable it was extremely sweet. Anyone interested in mythology would love this one.

Was this review helpful?

Seers & Sibyls is a collection of stories and poems, pulled together by the author, that focus on prophecy.This was a wonderful selection of stories influenced by folklore, myth, fairytale and literature about prophets, seers and oracles and really highlights that fascination I think we all have at least a little of with fortune-telling and seeing the future.

I really appreciated how vast the author's selection of stories were, they were able to show tales from all across the world, spanning India, Greece, North America, Nigeria, China, Egpyt and everywhere inbetween. My favourites were Blood Tears Rain, 78, Cassandra's Accounting, and The Oceanographer Waits.

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating collection of unique stories, tied together by the theme of prophecy. I particularly enjoyed 'The Oracle of Plum Harbour' as it had a vivid characterisation and gave an old theme a very modern twist.

Was this review helpful?

A collection of stories about those with the ability to 'know' things, to see into the future. Sometimes it's a curse to have 'the sight' and it comes unwillingly and without choice to the person with this gift.

An enjoyable collection of stories from numerous authors around the world dealing with themes of love, loss, fear, courage and redemption. The stories are diverse and all have their own level of appeal. My favourites from this anthology include A Tale from the World by Victoria Brun, A Tale from the Choctaw Nation by AL Munson, A Tale From Nigeria by Ekpenisi Nwajesu, A Tale from Italy by Kayla White and A Tale from China by Matthew Yap. A solid read for those who enjoy short stories featuring orales, prophets and fortunetellers.

Thank you to NetGalley and Brigid's Gate Press LLC for the opportunity to read and review this collection of stories.

Was this review helpful?

Seers and Sibyls, edited by MJ Pankey, is an intriguing collection that explores prophecy, fate, and the mysterious figures who bridge the gap between the mortal and the divine. The anthology presents a diverse range of voices and interpretations, weaving together myth, historical fiction, and fantasy to examine the power—and burden—of foresight.

The strongest stories in the collection are immersive and thought-provoking, offering fresh perspectives on well-known legends as well as original takes on the seer’s role in different cultures and settings. Some entries shine with poetic prose and deeply compelling characters, while others feel slightly underdeveloped, relying more on concept than execution. However, even the weaker stories contribute to the overarching theme, making for a cohesive and enjoyable read.

While Seers and Sibyls doesn’t always hit the highest notes in every entry, it is a well-curated anthology that will appeal to readers fascinated by mysticism, mythology, and the tantalizing question of whether the future is truly set in stone.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this wasn’t for me. I did appreciate how well researched this was. I just felt that it was disjointed and a bit of a slog to get in to.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! It was a fairly quick read, but it was so deep. I keep thinking about some of these stories, even days later. I will definitely be reading this book again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this collection of short stories and poems. I smiled, cried, and thought about these characters well after I finished reading.

Was this review helpful?

Seers and Sibyls by M.J. Pankey is that girl of a book. It was so good it was an experience reading it. I totally recommend everyone to read this book as fast as they can because it's really good and the characters are fantastic.

Was this review helpful?