Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I’m a big fan of Michael Connelly’s books and have read many over the years so it was exciting to be introduced to a new detective and new setting. I enjoyed the different and more laid back pace of this book with its base on the island of Catalina. Stilwell, the new detective, is likeable but obviously needs more time and development to become as engaging as Harry Bosch. Overall an enjoyable and easy read which leaves you wanting more.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to review and to the author for another good book.

Was this review helpful?

The first in a new series Detective Stilwell. Sergeant Stilwell has been transferred to Catalino Island off Long Beach having previously worked Homicide with LAPD. Not the most ideal of positions but he finds himself enjoying the quieter and easier life in comparison with life on the mainland. As soon as the introduction of these new characters and situation are done the pace moves up a notch and I was compelled to read it in one sitting!

Briefly, the laidback lifestyle Stillwell has been enjoying comes to an end when, first a headless bear is found and then a woman’s body is discovered in the harbour anchored to the bottom. There is also a reported theft of a statue from the boat club. Are they connected? Stilwell has a local girlfriend Tash who finds herself caught up in the criminal activity on the island. Stilwell of course does not endear himself to his bosses in the manner in which he sorts that out!

I liked Stillwell, I can’t help but think Bosch, in that Stillwell is an abrasive character who makes enemies easily and it always dedicated to solving the case regardless of his superiors orders and his own safety. This similarity is definitely not a bad thing. I love Bosch. A great plot and twists aplenty this is classic Connelly territory and makes for a most enjoyable read. I can’t wait for book 2.

Was this review helpful?

A new character for Michael Connelly, but still the excellent, all-engaging writing, and another brilliant character in Los Angeles County Sheriff's Detective Stilwell and the new beautiful (yes, I was googling the location) of Catalina Island.
This is a multilayered read: a fabulous main plot, a nice subplot with lots more to offer and a great backstory of how Stilwell is exiled to this ‘backwater’. All human emotions are here and skillfully interwoven into the narrative.
There are no surprise cameos from our beloved Bosch, Ballard, or Mickey Haller, but there is a nice nod to something that happens in a previous novel that did make me smile.
Another outstanding read from this master storyteller. No one could ever replace my affection for Harry Bosch but I was delighted to hear Michael say we will be hearing more from Stilwell and I’m already looking forward to it.

Was this review helpful?

A law enforcement officer is in overall charge of Catalina Island as a punishment by his superiors for what they consider a breach of judgment based on evidence from a lazy unprofessional colleague. Holding a grudge but committed to policing the island with integrity, he comes totally involved in solving a murder case of a young woman despite warnings from his commanding officer to leave the investigation to mainland officers. Wrong footed from the onset of finding the body, he travels the tenuous and lonely journey of interviewing potential witnesses determined to find the killer. The investigation uncovers numerous characters and potential witnesses many who appear superfluous to the crime. Michel Connelly is the expert and weaving a tangled and convoluted plot line giving his stories the inescapable magic of totally confusing the reader as to whether something is relevant or a character planted as a red herring. A slow methodical exposure of information gathers momentum towards a fast paced conclusion that delivers another five star read from an author who never fails to deliver. Many thanks to author, publisher and Netgalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

As a reader who is currently working his way through the Bosch Universe of books I was intrigued to see Michael Connelly had a new,series starting and couldn't wait to jump in.

From the outset its all very Michael Connelly and you instantly get that irresistible writing style that has drawn so many millions of readers to keep coming back.

The slow laid story of a murder on an island for the rich plays out very much as expected but the style in which it is executed is second to none. There isn't a better crime writer out there today and Connelly deserves to be thought of as one of the very best.

Was this review helpful?

Nightshade is a stand-alone novel by Michael Connelly but definitely has the potential to make an exciting new series. Detective Stilwell has been posted to Catalina Island, where boat owners are king. It's a far cry from the LA Homicide division and Stilwell finds it hard to let go of his old habits. Soon he has a murder to investigate when the body of a young woman is found. Who is she and how did she die?

Along with the action happening in the police sub-station, Stilwell has his hands full and things don't always go to plan.

Nightshade is a thoroughly enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Not the usual fast paced, intriguing novel from Michael Connelly. A slow burner that never really gets going, in my opinion. Trundles along, has an attempt at excitement and ends. A pleasant way to spend some time but for me forgettable.
Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The author is one of my favourites and I always enjoy his books. I loved the Catalina Island setting of this one but I failed to connect with the characters, Stillwell, the main character, is a bit of a loner and I just failed to empathise with him. The pacing was a bit on the slow side and the dialogue was stilted. Perhaps the follow up will be more interesting, although he plotting had promise it just failed to deliver. Thanks to Net Galley for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a huge fan of Michael Connelly so new books from him are always a treat and this is no exception, even though it’s the start of a whole new series and we don’t meet the familiar faces.

County Sheriff Detective Stilwell (‘Stil’) has been sent to a new posting on Catalina Island off the coast of California following problems on the mainland. His initial apprehension about the location has changed to a love of the island and a blossoming relationship, both disturbed by the discovery of the body of a young woman weighted down in the harbour. His investigations force him to work with those on the mainland with whom he has had problems and begin to uncover a dark side of the island.

As always with Connelly, it’s a great read. It does take a little time to get going and is slowed slightly purely because there is so much to set up for the new series, but the story is as interesting and gripping as ever. Stil is a very good character, independent in his outlook and dedicated to uncovering the truth no matter the damage to him personally, and it’s interesting to see that side of him coming out for the first time in his new home and impacting those around him too.

As with the city in his other books, the location is key to this one and almost becomes a character in itself. There are also nice little mentions of events from Connelly’s other books which set it in the same time period and allows the chance for there to be more future crossovers. Connelly is an absolute master at this kind of thriller and it’s great to have a new character to add to the list of unmissable reads from him.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge Michael Connelly fan, so I was excited to be approved for his latest book. Los Angeles County Sheriff's Detective Stilwell (nickname Stil) is sent to the Avalon Substation on Catalina Island following an incident on the mainland. I loved learning about him, his small team on the island and the team back on the mainland where is tension between him and the others. The location setting is a backdrop to the plot, especially when a body is found in the marina attached to an anchor. Stil investigates a mystery of what happened to a buffalo, which then leads him to more than he is expecting. It was taut, tense and a rollercoaster of a book! The highlight for me - is how they get around on golf buggies, lol!! I look forward to book 2.

Was this review helpful?

What a treat! A new first in series from one of my favourite authors.

County Sheriff Detective Stillwell is moved from a homicide team in LA to the quieter location of Catalina Island. He is very quickly embroiled in more than one case and the reader is gradually introduced to some of the residents on Catalina, his work team on the island and the wider team back on the mainland. There are some similarities to Michael Connelly's Bosch novels, for example the complexities of dealing with more than one case at a time. But I really enjoyed reading a new set of characters in a new location. Some of the relationships in the wider team are a bit broken and this really adds to the tension throughout the novel.

Some reviewers have said the book was a bit slow to start. I agree, but I think this is purely due to it being the first in a new series. In this book, all the introductions need to be made, whereas in book two some of the names will already be familiar.

A great read. Looking forward to book two (and the next Bosch/Ballard and the next Lincoln Lawyer!).

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

New character and series from Michael Connelly set on Catalina island.

Starts slowly, however, the reader is soon hooked like any good Connelly novel. Detective Stilwell is a flawed but likeable character and he certainly earns his keep in this storyline with murder, kidnapping and corruption. Better still, the police navigate the island on golf buggies!

Strong start to a new series from one of today's finest crime authors.

Was this review helpful?

‘Nightshade’, by Michael Connelly,is the first book in the new Detective Stilwell series.
As a returning reader used to catching many of his captivating novels featuring Harry Bosch, Renee Ballard,or Mickey Haller it initially feels slightly off kilter to be introduced to new characters where there isn’t immediate sense of empathy for them or some knowledge of their backstory.It takes a little while to settle into the fresh surroundings and pace of Stilwell’s professional exile to Catalina island.
The story gradually picks up momentum and increases interest as the investigations into a gory buffalo mutilation and an unknown woman found dead at the bottom of a harbour progress.
Overall this feels like solid investigative cases where the writing is entertaining through Michael Connelly's style but there were for me too few real surprises or twists in the unfolding storyline.An enjoyable enough routine tale but a bit more predictable than I expected from this rightly celebrated writer.
It will be interesting to see how the series progresses and characters are developed.

Thank you to NetGalley and Orion Publishing Group,for an Advance Readers Copy.

Was this review helpful?

Lovely book, sooo easy to read, flowed fluently and a different type of police procedure crimes. The character of the police sergeant could be made into a TV series or a new series of books. Love the sound of the island culture, who doesn't want to live there.

Was this review helpful?

I am a great admirer of Michael Connelly. Partly as a result of the tightness of his plots and the way he fleshes out his characters. If you have read most of an author's output it means you have very high expectations of them!

This is the start of a new sereis and I accept it takes time to establish a character. Stilwell - our hero may become more interesting. Currently he is two dimensional rather than three dimensional. A little too good to be true.

There ae also a great number of bit characters which means you keep having to remind yourself who is who. I found the girlfriend deeply uninteresting and a bore. In fact the women in the novel were not at all interesting. The most interesting was the murder victim.

It is an interesting plot line, animal abuse/murder, human murder, sex, corruption and police office politics. In terms of how we move through the novel it is best described as a police procedura. This would mean my partner will adore it it. For me there were times the writing was somewhat formulaic.. It felt as if the novel had been gridded out and the writer became a little bored in reaching the high points.

It is still a good read and even - just not as tightly and tautly written as some of his other novels. I am very glad to have read it and will definitely recommend it to those who love police procedurals.

Was this review helpful?

I've been known to take a while to warm to new Connelly characters, but not this this time.
This time I liked our new guy straight from the off.
He seems pretty decent, and wants to get to the truth of things. He has questions, lots of them.
It was slower paced I felt than a lot of the authors work, but it works well.
Some nice surprises along the way.
I'm already looking forward to book 2, may this series run for some years.

Was this review helpful?

Detective Stilwell is sent to run the police department on the island of Catalina off Los Angles. What unfolds in this new novel is edge of the seat stuff with twists and turns. A wonderful read.

Was this review helpful?

Nightshade by Michael Connelly is book 1 in a Detective Stilwell series and I confess the first book from the author that I have read.
Set on the island of Catalina of the coast of Southern California L.A Sheriff Silwell has been transferred to the island after and incident on the mainland where he was booted of a case. Catalina is where members of the Police force have done wrong but not so much to be booted off the force. But although Stilwell has been sent there. He Likes the different way of life on the island and its different pace.
But when Stilwell gets a call that a female body has been found with a purple streak in her hair and the signs that she has been murdered. Stilwell old instincts kick in at full force to find the find the killer. But his colleagues on the mainland are not too happy about it and thinks Stilwell should stand down and they deal with it. But he knows if he does that. They will do anything they can to close the case down quickly and discover what really happed to the body in the water.
This is my first outing of Micheal Connelly’ s work and you can tell by the quality of his writing how well established he is. I really enjoyed this, with this great well-paced storyline, with its multiple avenues but come together in the end. Stilwell is such a likable character as you keep reading you want to route for. And with a bit of romance thrown in it was such a delightful story. I can’t wait for more of this series and will no doubt go back and read previous novels from ths author. 5 stars from me.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a longtime fan of Michael Connelly and have read all his books, so was very excited to start this book specially because there was a new character being introduced. I thought the book had a confusing start with a lot of boating terms and a new setting, but picked up pretty soon. The story was interesting and there were enough twists to keep me gripped till the end. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this and definitely recommend it. It will be interesting to see how the character develops, so definitely waiting for the second book.
Thank you to the publishers Orion Publishing Group for an advanced copy of this ebook and giving me a chance to review this book!

Was this review helpful?

Michael Connelly's books never fail to suck the reader into a world of characters and settings he has created from the very first page and then keeps you there through until the end. Nightshade is no exception and in it he introduces a new main character, Detective Stillwell, who's fallen out of favour in LAPD resulting in his being "banished" to a remote outpost on Catalina Island. This small island, about 25 miles offshore from Long Beach, is a big tourist spot and popular destination for wealthy yacht owners. There is little crime there but then a body is found and Stillwell's arch nemesis is assigned to investigate.
For Connelly's devoted readers (I include myself in this category) the set up is very similar to the lengthy Harry Bosch series where a talented detective, constantly at odds with his bosses, sets off on a crusade to solve a crime ignoring personal career risks or political fall out to his department chiefs. He does it because he is the best person to solve the crime and because it's the right thing to do. It's what all good heroes have in common so I have no problem with the similarities. As with Bosch, I found myself just as intrigued with the Stillwell character and just as curious to see how he handles complexities of crime solving, relationship handling and personal animosities. Connelly is a wonderful story teller, his characters are quite compelling and the police procedural framework results in a very enjoyable read. I recommend Nightshade to fans of Harry Bosch or those who have not read a Michael Connelly book but love murder mysteries. He is an outstanding author in this field. I also hope that this is the start of another lengthy series!

Many thanks to Net Galley and Orion Publishing for providing access to this book.

Was this review helpful?