Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley and Kodansha for the e-arc!

I really like Historical Fiction and manga. So i'm glad i pick this one.

I thought it will be two volume, turns out for this ARC, there's only one volume, which is fine by me.

I like the historical setup, and the story is pretty make sense they travel from Japan to Spain. And they mention Batavia as well.

The main chara is a bit too good at his job(at least that's what i read from this first volume) but the villain is good too..

And i also like the art. No complain so far from first volume.

Was this review helpful?

Phenomenal storyline and artwork, this is a historical action manga that I absolutely lost myself in.
Only issue was that, while it is called the "Omnibus" version, this only contains Vol. 1 (which in and of itself was fantastic)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Kodansha for the e-arc!

I do have to note that this was not the full omnibus but rather just volume one which is fine as I had read the first two chapters previously through KManga. Now that I finished the volume, I would say that this was good set up. I am a sucker for historical fiction and this did not disappoint with the story and atmosphere. I do think character work could have been better but this could improve as the story goes on. I will be reading volume two soon to determine if I will keep reading. I recommend checking this out if you like dynamic stories of revenge set in a historical backdrop.

Was this review helpful?

is a manga with a historical theme that engages with its visual aspect, but catches you by the revealing it is. Undoubtedly, an interesting work in more than one sense.
Thanks to NetGalley and publisher for this advanced reader's copy.

Was this review helpful?

I received a partial e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Firstly, I'd like to explain the "partial" part of this. The listing of the e-ARC I received says "Issak Omnibus 1 (Vol. 1-2)," which is what I thought I would be receiving. I even had the Goodreads entry for the Omnibus pulled up and ready to add to my "Currently Reading." However, I quickly noticed the page count and read some of the first pages, which has an explanation stating that the e-ARC only had the first volume, not the second. That being said, it's a little misleading and I want to urge people to check the reviews of both the Omnibus and Volume 1 individually because I don't think some people realized the e-ARC was only half and their reviews may not be truly indicative of the Omnibus. I will be posting my review on Volume 1 and not the Omnibus because I do not want to lead people astray in that regard.

All that being said, I did enjoy this first volume. I can see where a lot of people are coming from, however, on not really connecting with Issak in the first volume. I think some flashbacks, even minimal, would've been helpful to the audience to connect with him on an emotional level. He is very stoic so I think a lot of people may have trouble understanding where his motives are coming from. I think leaving the first volume off at the end of Chapter 2 and adding in flashbacks of what happened before (even just visual panels showing some of Issak's emotions) would've been a better idea.

I really do like the art style. It feels both modern and traditional, which I enjoy. Some panels feel very cinematic. It's also reminiscent of an older art style (think late 90s to early 00s) without the awkwardness of it. The story flows quite well. I was disappointed that I didn't get volume 2 because I felt I didn't get a proper grasp on Issak within volume 1 alone.

I would give Volume 1 a 3.75/5. I think the art style and plot made up for the lacking in character relationship and I'm interested enough to pick up the next volume. With my tastes, I really do think my rating would go up if I'd had volume 2 since I'd have a bit more time with Issak so I will go ahead and round my rating up to 4/5.

CW/TW: SA within the first few pages, but it does not get far once Issak steps in.

Was this review helpful?

Okie... this was really educational! Considering I handled these topics literally this year at history, I could still recall some things I knew. I really liked this concept, I researched some about Japanese people in the Netherlands in the 17th Century and read some posts on Reddit talking about things that were correctly depicted but also some things that were placed in the wrong time period (some guy was really yapping about their armour being from the 16th Century and I was here for it lol).

I definitely want to research more about this topic. I didn't even know that the West had Japanese slaves and I want to learn more about the power struggles in Japan during that time.

Overall really enjoyed it, I think I'm also sensing a little romance...Which I will never complain about! I think I'll give this a 3.75 stars, I like history, I liked the concept, I liked the battle scenes (and badass scenes). I want to jump into the next Volumes because that cliffhanger is not okay!

Was this review helpful?

Issak is a historical action manga focusing on a Japanese mercenary in 1600s Europe looking for vengeance. The premise is quite unique and makes it stand out from the usual historical battle action series. This is a good fit for people who like Vinland Saga and Vagabond.

Was this review helpful?

3.5⭐️

first just a quick thing, I thought we were going to get vol 1 and 2, but I think we only got vol1 of the omnibus (and I can't find anywhere so I can confirm this)

about what I read, I got really interested in continue this one! I don't think this is something i gravitate to normally, but I do like war in my mangas😅😅

i'm really interested in seeing him getting his revenge and the journey to that!! and is that girl going with him??👀👀👀

Was this review helpful?

Issak Omnibus 1 is a visually stunning historical manga set during the Thirty Years’ War. The story follows Issak, a mysterious Japanese marksman on a revenge mission in war-torn Europe. The premise holds a lot of promise, and the artwork is undeniably beautiful—detailed, atmospheric, and clearly crafted with care.

However, I found the story difficult to connect with emotionally. The volume is packed with action—primarily battle scenes—which left little room for character development. We’re told Issak is driven by vengeance, but beyond that, we learn very little about who he is or what makes him tick. The supporting cast is similarly underdeveloped, making it hard to feel invested in the stakes.

One element that particularly soured the reading experience for me was the introduction of the character Zetta. Mild content warning (skip this paragraph if you’re avoiding spoilers): Zetta is first introduced during an attempted assault, a scene that felt unnecessary and exploitative rather than narratively meaningful. While I understand the intent may have been to reflect the brutality of wartime, the scene didn’t add anything to her character or the plot.

Zetta herself remains frustratingly one-dimensional throughout—constantly frightened yet perpetually close to battle, with little explanation or evolution. As the only notable female character in the volume, this portrayal felt like a missed opportunity.

While fans of war stories and historical settings may find more to enjoy here, I personally prefer more character-driven narratives. Future volumes could flesh out the cast and deepen the emotional stakes, but as a first volume, this omnibus didn’t quite hook me.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the DARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Issak is a historical seinen series with beautiful art style somewhat reminiscent of Tite Kubo’s. The start of the series is promising, with an interesting setting and detailed panels, I think there’s a lot of potential to be had. However, this omnibus used probably 60% of its page count on battle panels instead of world building or introducing the characters properly. While it was an absolute eye candy to look at, it failed to showcase what it has to offer outside of it — after 3 chapters, we barely even know anything about our main character; only where he is from, what is his goal and how cool his gun is. I’ll check out future volumes but so far the title leaves a lot to be desired.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge history nerd so this manga was right up my alley. It's fast-paced, brutal and somethimes touching. I instantly fell for Issak's character (he's such a broody figure) and can't wait to see where his story of revenge goes.

Was this review helpful?

Issak has made his way to Germany from Japan for revenge on the man who killed his master. Now he is wandering Germany in the midst of the Thirty Years War hunting for him while acting as a mercenary. Such a task has brought him to Fuchsburg where he has joined the defenders holding off the Spanish armies. Lucky for them, Issak is a superb marksman! But will his talent be enough. It will be interesting to see what happens in the next omnibus volume!

Thanks Netgalley and Kodansha Comics for the chance to read this title!

Was this review helpful?

I was interested by this book because I like manga's that are set in a different era and this one is pretty good so far. The main character we follow is named Issak as the manga goes on we learn why he decided to leave Japan and what self mission he is on. He is seeking revenge for his master and in turn brings him to Europe. I did enjoy manga for the action and how good the art style is. The art style has some intricate details with the weapons as well as the characters. Most of the characters have depth but not as much as how I expected them to be. Issak did not have the most depth to him as a character above the seeking for revenge but he does seem to have a good heart for others. If you are like me and enjoy historical/era setting with action, I believe this manga series could be for you.

Was this review helpful?

Issak omnibus contains the volumes 1 and 2. It's a historical seinen series set in 1620. I do enjoy historical series and this takes place in Europe. Thirty Years War is on its way and Issak is fighting alongside Europeans (or some of them of course) to take a revenge on the guy who killed his master. Issak is a gun man, or more like a sharp shooter, with a matchlock gun that looks like a riffle of sorts. The setting is interesting and I liked that Makari explains stuff at the back of the book. But, the problem is that the manga is mostly fighting so it's hard to care for the characters when we don't even get to know them enough. Basically the depiction of time and place is nowhere to be seen and the characters are paper thin too. This is omnibus so in two books there's...nothing.

The art looks good and works well with the story. Men look like men and fighting looks good too. The authentic feeling suits this well. I wish we'd get to see flashbacks and whatnot. Also, basically anything else aside fighting would be great. This is still good though and the rhythm works and all, but it's just hard to care. I would like an explanation how Issak can shoot long distance with that gun of his too. Yeah.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Kodansha for the e-arc of this manga omnibus! This is such a compelling historical manga. Set in Holy Roman Empire Europe, it follows a Japanese mercenary seeking revenge for the death of his master. A man of honor and fidelity, Issak is a strong main character and noble in his cause. The art style was immaculate, with such detail in every panel. The story is epic and only just beginning. I would recommend this to anyone wanting to start a new historical saga that doesn’t shy away from violence, war, and loyalty. The drawings are graphic and the content is mature, so please check trigger warnings. 4.75 🌟

Was this review helpful?

The headline says this is an omnibus and contains 2 volumes but the download is only the 1st volume. With that being said I loved this story. The art was beautiful and story kept me so engaged I was kinda sad when it was over. I will 100% be continuing this series

Was this review helpful?

An interesting story with beautiful art and solid, well rounded characters. The plot was intriguing enough and kept me reading and the characters were reletable and real.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars!

the illustrations?? AMAZING!
the plot?? I LOVEEEEE!

this is a manga that i will genuinely be continuing to read. i could not get enough of this.

10/10 recommend! read it!

Was this review helpful?

When I picked up Issak I was drawn in by the fact that it was presented as a character-driven historical fiction story. While this first volume delivers on the historical fiction aspect, I found it hard to really care about the characters. Let me start by saying the art of Issak is impressively beautiful and extraordinarily detailed. Especially the double spreads featuring battlefields and nature are stunning. You can see DOUBLE-S has put a lot of time and effort in portraying even the smallest details.

The action scenes are also incredibly well done. They are easy to follow and impactful. The harsh black lines illustrate the brutality of war. The first volume features little dialogue and seems more focused on environmental storytelling along with a string of action scenes. We do get some exposition, mostly regarding our main character, but I would have liked for this to feel a bit more natural. I adored the historical details and the extra pages at the end explaining which events this manga is aiming to follow and which figures did and didn't exist in that time period. I loved hearing how Makari got inspired to write this story.

Overall Issak was not for me personally, because I prefer character-driven stories over plot-driven ones. However there is space for the story to develop in that direction. The art is stunning and the action scenes are a highlight. If you enjoy action-focused manga exploring historical settings be sure to give Issak a try.

Was this review helpful?

Goodreads
11 May 2025
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7560637670

Artwork is stunning - on par with Black Clover. Funnily enough, the artist includes a note in the manga saying this was his first history drama manga. It looks amazing for someone who’s never done this style. Main character looks the part, cut throat and fierce. The plot is so good! Main character is a Japanese man named Issak on a revenge mission in Europe. There is war between Protestants and Catholics. He is a remarkable marksman. At first I was surprised since Japanese at that time would’ve been samurai (swordsman), but the author included a note at the end saying that they is a lot of evidence that during this time period, Japanese traveled to Europe and were marksman due to a war in Osaka forcing them into artillery warfare. I really appreciated the historical notes they included at the end so I didn’t have to go research everything. This manga is top tier and can’t wait for the next volume. 10/10 recommend

Was this review helpful?