Skip to main content

Member Reviews

unfortunately i can't really read this as the format doesn't want to work on my kindle and it's just too difficult💔but i will look for a copy when it is officially released! thanks to netgalley and the publisher for a copy of this arc

Was this review helpful?

This is a brilliant, electric and powerful read. I never knew what was going to happen next and I love that. Gala and Lane are such different people, but they are bonded not only through a complicated, fraught friendship, but also through their own personal experiences of love and loss. I liked the change in perspectives, time changes and the exploration of Gala’s relationship with Gabriel and Lane’s own with Scotty Lane’s struggle with motherhood was delicately written and poignant.

Five stars. Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the backdrop of this book set in the LA party scene during the 60s and 70s. The authors descriptions were so atmospheric and the book very character driven. I found both female characters, Lane and Gala, to be strong and free characters of their time. I however found it very difficult to connect with them as I did not find them very likeable and perhaps that is part of the charm. This book explores female relationships that maybe aren’t truly friendships in an engaging and emotive way. It covers topics such as friendship, motherhood and addiction with very complex relationships throughout. I think it’s a book that you definitely reflect upon once you’ve finished reading.

3.5⭐️

Was this review helpful?

This book had so much potential but I struggled with the characters. I hardly liked any of them, to be honest. It took me some chapters to really get into the story. I had to get used to the author's writing style.

Yet, it was very interesting to learn more about women's life at this time.

Was this review helpful?

This turbulent story takes place between ‘then 1965/66’ and ‘now 1975/76’ in sunny Los Angeles. We meet two ambitious women - Lane Warren, reserved and resilient who feels undeserving of love, and Gala Margolis, a true free spirit with a magnetic personalty.

Although it took until around the thirty-percent mark to truly captivate me, the story gradually deepened, becoming more atmospheric and emotionally resonant as it developed stronger connections with its characters.

Set amidst the shimmering facade and gritty underbelly of Hollywood, we explore how their fragile lives intertwine and how as two female journalists and writers, are pitted against one another. When suddenly Gala goes missing, Lane becomes consumed, emotionally unraveling more and more as time goes on without her. Difficult themes such as abortion, homophobia, and drug addiction are woven into the story with sensitivity, adding real weight and nuance to the narrative. (I also truly despised all of the men in this story)!

I really loved how the story ended, and how their characters weren’t compromised to conform to traditional relationships. Personally, I really enjoyed reading a story where women aren’t made to feel like their only role is to be a mother.

L.A. Women is a perfect testament of the risks and rewards of chasing success on one’s own terms - where free-spitted ambition collides with shifting expectations of womanhood, and where triumph is often shadowed by jealousy and sacrifice.

Was this review helpful?

LA Women is set in LA with two different timelines – the 1960s and 70s.

Lane and Gala are two very different women caught up in the LA Party scene. Gala loves a good party and always seems to be in the thick of it whereas Lane is a writer and possibly considers herself above the party scene.

When Gala suddenly absents herself from the party scene Lane starts to reflect on her friendship and where her friend may have gone.
The plot is hard going and the characters go from dislikable to extremely dislikable. Lane is intelligent but emotionally unavailable; especially to her two children. Gala just likes to party and seems to only care about herself.

The conclusion as to why Gala went, I didn’t see coming and was left with some questions that were What? Why did you do that?

Not the best LA party scene novel around but this is a decent read all the same.

Was this review helpful?

I originally requested this on NetGalley because I loved Before We Were Innocent.

I was in a bit of a slump when I went on holiday so started this and it was the perfect book to keep me interested.

The book focuses on 2 main characters Lane and Gala navigating womanhood in 60s/70s Los Angeles.
I looove all the glamour and the drama and the sex, drugs and rock and roll and the fact that it still felt raw and real.
I’ll tell you one thing Ella Berman is the best at is making an equally loveable yet insufferable character. Even the supporting characters are endearingly flawed.

I won’t say tooo much to avoid spoilers but I will say one thing that did disappoint me slightly is the ending but maybe it’s exactly how it’s meant to be…..

Was this review helpful?

Although a bit bit of slow burner, it is well worth sticking with this book. Beautifully written and truly a masterpiece.

Was this review helpful?

I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me early access to this one. All opinions are my own.

LA Women, by Ella Berman, caught my attention for the description and for the fact that I had already read and loved another book by the author. However, this one was not my cup of tea and I ended up reading only 66% of it, although I feel I already know everything there is to know.

The book devolves around two female writers who are friends and rivals at the same time, making me feel like I was reading Yellowface once again (another book I didn’t love). The plot felt too superficial and I couldn’t feel their friendship, everything felt too swallow, which I know is a way to look at the Hollywood environment but prevented me to connect with the characters and their stories. I really didn’t care bout either one of them.

I felt like there was potential, with difficult topics being brought to the spotlight, such as abortion and homophobia, but their appearance in the book, once again, felt too superficial. The whole book felt like a mix of Yellowface with Less than Zero, not being particularly innovative or interesting. The story drags on the same situations for pages on end, I skipped more than ten pages at a time and continue reading about the same issue before skipping.

Was this review helpful?

This gripping book explores the turbulent friendship between two ambitious writers in 1960s Los Angeles, a story marked by envy, betrayal, and the high stakes of artistic ambition. Lane Warren, once a fading literary star, is staging a comeback with a new book based on the life of her elusive former friend and muse, Gala Margolis, who has mysteriously disappeared.

Set against the glamour and grit of the L.A. party scene, the narrative delves into the complicated dynamics of rivalry and admiration. Lane’s decision to turn Gala’s life into a story forces both women onto paths that neither could have foreseen, with consequences that echo through a decade.

This book offers a powerful meditation on creativity, jealousy, and the costs of chasing success, making it a compelling read for those interested in the fragile nature of friendships entwined with art and ambition.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.

Was this review helpful?

I will convey my thoughts on this book quite shortly because while i do have a lot to think about, i also don't really have much to say. This story is about two women who are writers, one living life on the edge and one who's much more meticulate about life. Everything feels both messy and articulate, both sorrowful and aggravating. I love following both of Gala and Lane's stories, and i find that i don't really have a side because both women messed up in their own ways, and they both want something from each other that it drove them to a tentative friendship and hatred. The way the author portrayed their complicated dynamic is so interesting, although i did wish we saw a little bit more of it. I quite understand where the daisy jones and the six reference coming from, however the stark difference is the fact that i wholeheartedly despise the men in this book as opposed to the tentative understanding i have with the other book.

The thing that made the rating for this book dropped to 4 is how the storyline was sort of a mess to read and the middle was somewhat boring and a bit hard for me to get through, but other than that i highly recommend this book if anyone wants a poignant yet still unserious book about rich people drama and womenhood

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed it but at times the two timelines felt like a struggle. I couldn’t lose myself in this as much as I wanted, which is a shame because I loved The Comeback.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and highly recommend it. I am grateful to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is set in two timelines, 1965 and 1975 telling the amazing story of the lives of two women writers, Lane Warren and Gala Margolis,

I just loved this book. being of a certain age i was transported to the exciting times of when women came into their own and how they changed how women lived and were seen. Their bougee opinions and free spirits shone through. The author did a good job of bringing the story alive and I was engrossed.

Was this review helpful?

L.A. Women is a slow-burning, atmospheric novel that explores the complexities of female friendship, ambition, and identity in 1960s and 70s Los Angeles. Through the contrasting lives of Gala Margolis and Lane Warren, the story moves between decades, tracing the evolution — and unraveling — of a bond shaped by desire, rivalry, and unmet expectations.

Berman captures the cultural backdrop with care, and the writing itself is rich and considered. While the novel didn’t immediately pull me in, it gradually built depth as the characters’ histories unfolded. Some parts felt emotionally distant or difficult to connect with, and not every character resonated, but the themes — particularly around womanhood, creativity, and the cost of reinvention — were handled with insight.

It’s not a light read, but it offers plenty to reflect on. A thought-provoking portrayal of fame, friendship, and the lives women lead when no one’s watching.

Thanks to NetGalley and Aria & Aries for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Friendships can be complicated …

On the face of it, Gala Margolis and Lane Warren are two very different women. They meet in Los Angeles in the 1960s and despite their differences are drawn to each other. Gala is a free spirit, living life to the full until a romantic relationship complicates matters. Lane is a Hollywood outsider, carrying personal baggage and trying to find her place in the world as a writer.

The story shifts between the 1960s and the 1970s. In the 1970s Lane Warren’s literary star has been in steady decline. But then she secures a book deal based on the life of Gala. But Gala is missing.

I confess I did not like either of these women. Gala’s free spirit, while admirable at times, was too much for me. Lane’s insecurity, while understandable at times, was frustrating and her envy of Gala annoyed me, even before it seriously impacted on both of their lives. And yet, there was something in the complicated webs each wove around the other that captured and held my attention. In a world seemingly full of shallow people, I felt most for Lane’s friend Charlie whose need to adhere to various societal expectations blighted his life. As the story shifted between the 1960s and the 1970s, I could identify (and to some extent appreciate) some of the factors that shaped each life. I kept reading. Would Lane find the acceptance and balance she needed? And what happened to Gala?

While I did not enjoy this novel as much as ‘Before We Were Innocent’, I am still thinking about aspects of it.

Note: My thanks to NetGalley and Aria & Aries for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book for review purposes.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book about LA in the 70s and two women oscillating between friendship and rivalry. At times I thought the story was dragging a little bit though so I liked it but didn’t love it.

Was this review helpful?

I read it! It took me a long time which should probably tell you a lot. The book was fine- the story was fairly interesting and the characters were pretty thought out. But I had so much trouble getting into it… just not my thing, I suppose

Was this review helpful?

It took a little while for this book to grow on me but once the characters were established the story itself was mesmerising. you could get caught up in the rich layers of mystery of LA and the characters themselves. overall the book had a good but slightly bittersweet ending. the main characters lane and gala are direct contrasts of each other with lane being this realistic woman of the time, working but also struggling wit past issues, while gala was like this epiphany of freedom that drew everyone in. this book is filled with so much love and loss and i really think everyone should read it at least once in their lives

Was this review helpful?

Having previously found this author's work a bit of a struggle to get into, I was hoping L.A Women would be more my cup of tea. But I think that it's just not for me. I found this book to be quite flat and I struggled with the dual narrative, the writing is good don't get me wrong, I just couldn't get into the story.

Was this review helpful?