Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I'd already decided I wasn't going to read any more WWII books, it's all be done, all been said but this one was a little different in that you don't see that many books that relate the story of Japan's part in the war. As I'd read other books by this author I thought I'd give it a go. It's interesting in the story it tells of what it was like for the nurses working in such difficult circumstances and later the harsh treatment both nurses and patients suffered at the hands of the Japanese with little food and no medical supplies to treat the patients.

However for some reason, that I still can't put a finger on, but it must be down to the writing in some way, it failed to bring about much emotion in me. I kind of felt like I was reading a history book and didn't feel completely invested in the characters. I was the same when I read Sisters of The Sky, enjoyed learning about the women fighter pilots but I didn't find it emotive. Perhaps a little slow, maybe could have been shortened a bit and there were a lot of amazing coincidences too in relation to a couple of characters who seemed to pop up out of nowhere at a convenient moment. Perhaps not my favourite of this author's books. The Countess of the Revolution was the best for me, I loved that book.

Was this review helpful?

Set in the Philippines in 1941 this is a moving story about a group of nurses. Rose is on her first assignment with the US Army, she is looking forward to having an adventure. War which was a distant possibility comes to soon and Rose faces daily threats against her life and that of her comrades. Will she survive the turmoil of war?

Was this review helpful?

Another outstanding book from Lana Kortchik. This is the second book I have read recently about nurses in the Philippines and the hardship that both the Islanders and forces suffered under the Japanese. It is horrific to read about the way that human beings were treated and anyone who survived must have been both physically and mentally strong. The horrors must have lived with them for the rest of their lives.

The book is well written with characters that are easy to relate to. The storyline remains strong throughout the book and keeps the reader wanting to know more (several nights I read later than I normally would as I was engrossed). I did feel it was rather rushed at the end and would have liked to have had more about how everyone managed when they got back to the US and how their families reacted.

Highly recommended to anyone with an interest in historical fiction.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publishers and of course Lana for another fantastic read.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this one. I was immediately hooked and loved the characters,
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for this arc

Was this review helpful?

When Rose Williams joins nurses Kate, Anne, Tess & Ida in Manila their idea of paradise is soon shattered when the bombing starts. Soon the nurses are tramping through the jungle to find safety from the Japanese soldiers.
Rose is liked by patients and staff for her caring nature, often putting others before herself (especially in matters of safety) .

I enjoyed the attention to detail, learning more about this particular war.
My favourite character was Rose for her kindness, followed by Hiroshi who proved not all were bad. I had mixed feelings about Anne

Was this review helpful?

This was an excellent read even though the degree of hardship described tore at the heartstrings, making it difficult to read at times. The book tells the story of nurses in the American forces stationed in the Philippines during WW2. Of course, nursing 8n wartime was always going to test your resources to the limit, but then the country was taken over by the imperial Japanese army. The nurses find themselves in a PoW camp and many starve to death. While there are some harrowing moments, the story is lifted by extraordinary acts of kindness and self sacrifice that lead to the survival of the lead characters. For them it is a happy ending, although as rightly pointed out, for many this was not the case. A powerful, dramatic read..

Was this review helpful?

My thanks to Net Galley, HQ Digital, and the personal invitation I received to review this arc.

What an excellent read!!! I loved reading about Rose s maturity growth as an excited young new nurse going to the Phillipines to facing love, death, and the horrors of war. I also found it interesting learning about the aspects of war in Manilla. Highly recommend!!

Was this review helpful?

3,5* rounded up to 4*. I found the historical background set in the Philippines during the Second World War really interesting and gripping as I don't know much about it. The medical team did an incredible work everyone should be aware about. However, there were quite a few coincidences around the romantic part that rendered the storyline rather unrealistic. The romance fell flat to me, plain and utterly predictable. I wanted to read till though because I absolutely wanted to know what would happen to the nurses and doctors. Maybe not the best novel by the author, but still well worth reading!
I received a digital copy of this novel from HarperCollins through NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A heart filled story of an American Nurse in the Pacific during WWII. I’m glad there was a happy ending!

Was this review helpful?

this was a new take for me on that time in war. ive not read it from this location or view point. and i applaud Lana for ripping my heart in two! no no i mean that lol. because wow what a book. it was just so powerful and emotive and it felt like at times i was crying for them, amongst them and about them. i wasnt but it still hit hard. you know that funny feeling you get in your tummy when things really hit. good books manage that. really good books like this one.
it felt real and by that i mean well researched. and it led me to look further too. i went on to do my own finding out about that time and location and just what the nurses were up against. the bravery and courage of those fighting and those at home is something ill never stop being in awe of. and i dont think i shall be allowed by my own brain to forget this story in a very long time.
im so glad people still write these stories. we need to never stop reading and never forget them.

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic read, loved every minute. Fabulously researched and had you hanging on. Emotional, realistic you felt like you were in the camps, heartwarming and challenging. Makes you think how people survived. Not to be missed.

Was this review helpful?