Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this story. I love romance and when it is so well done I cannot recommend it enough. This will definitely be one of those times. The plot was well written and the characters felt so real!

Was this review helpful?

I love the concept behind these books. Four new friends are out to get revenge against the ex-boyfriends in their lives. The ex-boyfriend that Astrid meets is Aiden, but it's his twin brother Blake who she can't seem to get enough of.
I loved this romance as Astrid did her best to not get tangled up with Blake, who seems to be every bit her usual type (bad boy and heart breaker) but she soon begins to see that there's much more to him than first thought. It doesn't help that his twin Aiden also doesn't seem to be quite the heart breaker he first appeared to be.
I thought that Blake and Astrid made a great couple and worked so well together. Seeing Astrid trying to resist him, while still convincing him that he was just as much of a good guy as his twin brother was great.
I've already got the next book in this series lined up and ready to go. I'm just a bit sad I haven't read the first two yet, but I plan to change that soon.
I received a complimentary copy of this book through NetGalley. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own and given voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

My first book by Rachael Stewart and now I want to go back and read the previous from the series! The premise is so good and different. When you read as much as I do you love for something new to come along.

🏒 Revenge Pact
🏒Hockey Romance
🏒Forbidden Romance
🏒Workplace Romance
🏒 John Tucker Must Die meets The Hating Game


Astrid is a journalist who has been scorned by a man. While snowed in at the airport she meets 3 other women who turn into her ride-or-dies as they bond over the men that hurt them. It’s during this drunken experience that they make a pact to hurt the exes of one another. Astrid gets pro hockey player Aiden Carter. Aiden broke Astrid’s new bestie when he left her behind and now he must be punished. Astrid’s way in? Aiden’s twin brother Blake. The problem? Blake might be just what she needs. Can she accomplish her mission without breaking her own heart?

The immediate mention of PMDD made me know I’d love this because YES PMDD IS REAL.

Thank you to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This Karma Club installment had a lot of serious topics as well as lots of yearning between the two main characters. One golden boy twin along with his bad boy brother and fellow hockey teammate are the subjects of Astrid’s next journalism story. She is using her time interviewing them as her means to getting revenge for the way Sienna was treated 10 years ago. It has realistic portrayal of alcoholism, domestic violence, as well as PMDD.

This series keeps weaving an intricate web and I am here for it. The timelines overlap in each and are best read in order. Only one more story until we see karmic fall out in its entirety for this group of women.

Thank you Boldwood Books for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to boldwood books and NetGalley for this arc.

Hockey romances are my fave, and this is no exception. I love Astrid and Blake together! This book is spicy and funny! I love the revenge pact but I love Blake and Astrid together more.

Was this review helpful?

You know that magical feeling — curling up in a cozy bed, rain tapping on the window, book in hand, and the world just starts to melt away? That’s exactly what "The Puck Stops Here" felt like. Warm, funny, swoony perfection.

The romance? Heart-fluttering and knee-wobbling. The spice? Just the right amount to make you blush. The POV shifts were seamless, and every character — even the coach — felt real and lovable.

But the humor. Oh my goodness . I expected a few giggles, maybe a snort or two. What I got? Full-on cackling, until I was gasping for air. Rachael Stewart is a comic genius — she seriously needs to consider stand-up on the side.

From the outrageous revenge mission to the fierce, ride-or-die friendships and the banter that made my heart ache in the best way — I was obsessed. And Blake and Astrid? Their chemistry crackled off the page from the first moment. I couldn’t get enough.

I’ve read a lot of hockey romances, but this one? It makes me want to bundle up, grab some cocoa, and sit rink-side with the fictional Titans — because this team? Adorable, chaotic, and completely irresistible.

10/10. Unputdownable. Unforgettable.

I received a free Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for sending me an ARC of this book! While this could read as a standalone, this is the third book in a series focusing on one of the main characters. Because all of the characters/storylines are interconnected, it's a more satisfying read if you read the entire series. And what I will say is clever about this series: each FMC's story is written by a different author. As such, each book/FMC has a unique voice even though the books themselves tend to follow a storyline formula.

This book followed Astrid's story, which you get glimpses of in the other books, but really delve into here. I thought this book read the clunkiest of the three so far. While the main character is British, the story and other characters are all set in NY. Knowing that, I was constantly thrown while reading because all the characters spoke as if they were from the UK. The NY characters were using phrases and words that New Yorkers would never use and it made for awkward reading. This book also used multiple POVs, which I don't mind, but they would switch mid chapter and sometimes I found myself having to go back and reread to understand whose POV I was reading. Overall it was a sweet, predictable, feel good read, and as the other books do, it set up the final book #4 very well.

Was this review helpful?

I had such a great time reading this book. It was a mix of some serious topics but also a really fun time. The relationships in this book were written so well. I love Astrid's relationship with her karma club girls, even though their friendship started as revenge against their exes it blossoms into something more and deeper. Blake and Aiden have such a great sibling relationship. I also enjoyed Blake and Aiden's relationship with their mom as well as Astrid's relationship with her mom. Astrid's relationship with Aiden started off as one thing but evolved when he saw the good she could do for his brother and that was really sweet. I really loved Blake in this book, he is not a perfect character and really had growth throughout the book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for providing this book, with my honest review below:
After reading an extremely complicated historical (war based) fiction book, I desperately needed an easy to digest and fun read. The Puck Stops Here fit that bill in spades. I never can resist a hockey romance book - and Astrid and Blake's story did not disappoint. The plot was easy enough to follow - love scorned women looking to dish back a little karma to the men that did them wrong...but will the plan succeed or backfire in the most delicious way imaginable? Delicious in the sense that I devoured the entire book in less than 24 hours - and as a sleep deprived mom of 5, staying up till all hours of the night to keep reading 'just one more chapter' is saying something. It had just the right amount of spice and slow burn to keep pulling me along to see how the story would unfold, The author does a great job developing characters that are relatable, flaws and all, that make you want to root for everyone to have a good ending. I love a book that makes me feel lighter and not like I had to really focus in order to understand and the Puck Stops Here was just that. My few minor complaints were the following: The story follows characters born and raised in the United States, but the words they use are frequently not how, at least in my experience, Americans speak. A few examples are referring to boarding an airplane as 'the coach this morn', or sleeping in as 'lie-in', or to walk up to something is to 'rock up', or going to someone's home as 'calling' on them, or a French press is called a 'cafetiere', saying 'aye' for yes, calling a young boy a 'lad' etc... While none of these things kept me from enjoying the book, it did distract me a bit and made the story feel a little less authentic due to the fact it was happening during the times Americans were supposed to be speaking or at least from their point of view. Also, much of the writing is put together in a way that I had to reread sentences here and there to see if there might have been a typo or if it was simply said in a way that is more palatable for the British and not as understood by an American. "Blake looked back to the exit. To where she'd been stood...feeling her presence even though she was gone" To where she'd been stood made me pause to realize this wasn't a typo, it just simply meant 'to where she had last been standing.' Also, many colloquialisms I was not aware of that had me stopping to google- journalists are referred to as journos, foo foo was slang for vagina, calling air-condiditoning 'aircon'. There were many times throughout the book that I was just slightly distracted by these little things. In the overall scheme of things, very unimportant, but for some reason it stuck out for me. Just the same, I very much enjoyed this easy and fun read, and am intrigued by the dangling carrot the author leaves at the end.

Was this review helpful?

This book was really sweet.

Gruff hockey player Blake meets his match with journalist Astrid.

Astrid and her friends make a pact to get revenge on their ex’s for making their lives miserable. Astrid ends up agreeing to fool Sienna’s ex Aiden and making a mockery of him to the world.

Things don’t quite go to plan when Astrid falls for Aiden’s twin brother Blake.
Astrid goes behind the scenes to write an article about the brothers and how they became such superstars in the NHL.
She gets very close to the brothers but there is a big spark with twin number 2.

It then gets complicated when feelings change and Astrid struggles with her deceit.

Third act breakup but doesn’t last long and we get the HEA we all love and need!

Great story by this author and will definitely read more.

Was this review helpful?

5 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I was approved for this book on NetGalley while in the middle of reading something else but decided to read the first couple of chapters to see what it was like… 4 hours later I’d read the whole thing, this book was so addictive.

The story line is a throw back to 2000s rom- com hits like John Tucker Must die and How to lose a guy in ten days. With a really likeable cast of characters and a really cute central couple, this was an incredibly fun nostalgic read.

There are some really funny moments too, I laughed out loud when Astrid learned the hard way not to use a hand dryer to deal with wet jeans and when Blake comes up with an inventive use for an oversized Christmas jumper 😂

This is a book to cancel plans for!

Thank you to Boldwood books for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, this book was a bit tough to get into at first, but I ate it up once the dynamic was dynamic-ing. My only complaint, which is generally common for me with less than 400-page contemporary romance, is that the MMCs feel a little Insta love. And unfortunately, this book had a lot of that.

I realized later that this is part of an interconnected series, and I probably will read the other books. Overall, no major complaints with this book, just not revolutionary. I thought the steaks were just high enough to be fun and enticing, but at the end of the day, this is very similar to other books I've read.

📖 / 3⭐️

Thank you to Boldwood Books via NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for my honest opinions! #ThePuckStopsHere #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

The puck stops here is an adrenaline rush of a tale with swoony, seductive and sage moments interwoven in a tale of devastating attraction and the chords of self realization and adoration of the soulmate who truly sees you for who you are...

The tale sees Astrid Sinclair play the investigative journalist whose aim is to rain sexy retribution on Aiden Carter for abandoning his childhood sweetheart, if she can tune her focus away from his broody twin Blake...

Rachael Stewart weaves a stunner of a tale for spicy, sporty romcom lovers, with oodles of texting, flirtation and hot heavy moments. The meshing of childhood traumas and how they influence our perception of events and color our personalities is explored in a nuanced way.. I breezes through the tale in a couple of hours and am bathing in the afterglow!

Many thank yous to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for furnishing me with the ArC! And my karmic congratulations to Rachael Stewart on a spicy reckoning of a romance...

Was this review helpful?

I loved the concept and the storyline of this book. Hockey romances are one of my favorite genres! Plus add in 4 women meeting and coming up with a "strangers on a train" scenario to give their ex's some payback. Love it. I just had a hard time connecting with the main characters for some reason.

Was this review helpful?

I could not connect with the story, I found the premise juvenile and not very relatable. The characters were not easy to like. .

Was this review helpful?

The Puck Stops Here is the 3rd book in Rachael Stewart's Karma Club series. I haven't read any of the others (yet!) and had no problem following along with the story or with the characters.

Astrid is seeking revenge on behalf of a friend and the target is NHL star Aiden, and to get close to him to carry out her revenge she has to also meet his brother, Blake, also an NHL star.

Things start to go off plan when she starts finding Blake attractive and the revenge plot doesn't seem as necessary.

Ms. Steward delves into the other side of it - everything isn't as the public thinks they are and we find that Blake is so much more than a hockey star and that revenge isn't as neatly carried out as Astrid thought it would be.

Everyone grows in this book and I really enjoyed watching it play out.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I loved everything about this book! The immediate chemistry between Astrid and Blake, gah! Delicious. The characters all had well written backstories and the plot, although predictable, was still enjoyable.

Thank you Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Puck Stops Here was an enjoyable read for me. It took until about the halfway mark for the story to fully grab me, but once it did—I was locked in.

I think the author handled the complexity of the situation—Astrid’s revenge plot versus the actual truth—beautifully. I was a little worried that this angle might lead me to dislike her, but Astrid came across as both genuine and tactful. Despite her initial motivation and underlying guilt, there was surprisingly little actual deception on her part. She remained professional throughout, with just a few playful hijinks (Lion King moment, anyone?).

What really surprised me, though, was how emotional this story made me. The prevalent theme of family—both found and from—hit hard in the best way. Blake and Aiden’s relationship with each other and with their mother, in particular, added a level of tenderness and heart that I wasn’t expecting in a sports romance. It grounded the story and gave it lasting impact.

⚠️ Content warning: brief allusion to miscarriage and descriptions of physical abuse.

Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Rachael Stewart for the privilege of receiving this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Puck Stops Here is a sharp, sexy, and emotionally layered addition to The Karma Club series, proving Rachael Stewart knows exactly how to score with readers. Packed with banter, chemistry, and a perfectly chaotic revenge plan gone sideways, this book is a home run—or rather, a slapshot straight into the heart.

At the center is Astrid Sinclair, a whip-smart journalist who stumbles into sisterhood during a snowed-in layover. Along with her newfound crew of scorned women, she forms a pact to exact karma—not on their own exes, but each other’s. Her target? NHL superstar Aiden Carter, the guy who crushed her friend Sienna. Her weapon? Her charm, a press pass, and a plan to expose him in an exclusive piece.

But the mission gets messy when Astrid finds herself face to face with Aiden’s twin brother, Blake—a hockey player with a chip on his shoulder and a reputation that’s been dragged through the ice. The more she digs, the more she finds herself drawn to Blake’s gruff exterior, wounded pride, and unexpected warmth. What starts as a calculated plan for vengeance quickly turns into a game neither of them saw coming.

Where this book shines is in its emotional beats. Stewart doesn’t just stick to the spicy, enemies-to-lovers tropes (although they’re deliciously executed); she digs into grief, identity, and the public vs. private self. Blake is a standout romantic lead—moody, misunderstood, but fiercely protective. And Astrid? She’s a force. Sarcastic, principled, and emotionally complex, she adds a dose of realness to every scene she’s in.

There’s a lot to love here:
• Twin drama that actually adds depth, not just confusion
• Forced proximity that never feels forced
• Redemption arcs that hit hard
• Steamy tension that doesn’t sacrifice emotional payoff

Fans of The Hating Game, Icebreaker, or even John Tucker Must Die will eat this up. It’s fun and flirty with a pulse of something deeper—making it more than just another sports romance. And even though it’s the third in the series, it can stand on its own—though you’ll want to go back and read the others just to stay in the loop with the Karma crew.

Plus, let’s talk about that setup for the next book. If Harvey’s about to get what’s coming to him, readers better buckle up.

Final verdict: A clever, sexy, and surprisingly heartfelt romance that hits every note right. If you like your love stories with sass, sweat, and soul, The Puck Stops Here is one to add to your TBR.

Was this review helpful?

What a fun and flavoursome five-star read. This is the third instalment of the Karma club series, and I have loved getting to know all of the ladies and loved their stories, this one just had a lovely little extra to it, and I am so excited to see what this group will do next. I haven’t read this author previously, but I enjoyed this one so much I plan to check out their other work, I don’t know why but this one made me really care about Astid and it took me a while to get there with the ladies in the first two stories by the other authors. I will just say that this one I really enjoyed, and I was excited to see how Astrid went with her heart, I am sure Karma would be proud.

Was this review helpful?