DNF'ing at page 75 (33%) due to the overuse of 'adjectives/adverbs/chunky af writing'

I didn't read book 1 or 2 from this series. I wasn't aware it was book 3 when I requested it on NetGalley, and one of my libraries have copies of the previous books. I could only find them on Kindle Unlimited and Audible, neither of which I have due to lack of funds. I wish I had access to them to see if the writing is different, maybe the editor pushed for this in later books or something.

Here are some examples of what I feel are way too chunky writing;

"At the mention of Annabel's name Cynthia's face completely closed, her haughty expression slipping smoothly back on"

"Tuppence bobbed her head, her gray curls spiralling (spelled wrong in the book) out around her"

"the fourth woman shot back" "Cynthia flushed and bowed her head" "Tuppence interjected" "Tuppence ploughed on" "Cynthia choked and turned away" "Tuppence explained in a sunny voice" "the second woman grimaced" "the third one coughed (but not in a sick sense)" "Ginny blinked" "the third woman chimed in" "Ginny tentatively asked" "Ginny sighed" "Cynthia's frosty expression melted slightly" "woman two let out a distressed wail, her eyes going wide"

All of those appear in just a span of barely 10 pages!

It's like the author just used a thesaurus on every single word, and made sure every single line got a quirky adjective/adverb/action added.

J'avais lu le 1er tome mais je n'avais pas été emballée, et je n'avais donc pas demandé le tome 2. Pourtant me voilà avec vous après avoir lu le 3.

Assister à un mariage, découvrir un crane humain, je pense que ça peut etre classé dans les pires mariages. C'est étrange non? surtout que nous sommes face à des querelles familiales, un village au bord de la crise de la nerf, et puis nous avons le club des détectives, oui ces amateurs qui aimeraient découvrir d'où vient ce crane.

MAis voilà Ginny et ses amies ne s'attendaient pas à de tels rebondissements. Oui pendant les mariages il peut avoir des surprises, et surtout des révélations. Donc qui est vraiment le coupable et pourquoi? Et ça comment peut on gacher un mariage?

C'est cosy, c'est mignon, drôle, et puis si vous aimez les cosy murders avec des veuves, alors laissez vous emporter. Ce n'est pas prise de tête, on passe un bon moment, et c'est le but de tout cosy.

A skull discovered at a wedding prompts a group of widows to investigate a decades-old plot involving family feuds and village rivalries, leading them into a dangerous game of cat and mouse before another murder occurs.

I wish this had had less gossip and more murder. The plot is slow-paced, and I couldn’t keep up with all the characters.

Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC I received. This is my honest and voluntary review.

It was lovely to be back in Little Shaw with Ginny, JM, Tuppence and Hen. Ginny is invited to a wedding where a skull ruins the wedding day of her friends! There was a touch of the Capulets and the Montagues between the two families - The Faulkners and The Wests.!!! Ginny decides that her and the other 3 friends will investigate the circumstances behind the skull and why the police won't follow up on the skull's origins. It was hilarious in places, full of twist and turns with a few red herrings. However, in the background, Ginny and friends have help in the investigation! All the sub plots came together to a surprising conclusion.

Not having read any of the other books in this series didn’t matter at all, it is a perfect standalone. Grace and Theo are about to be marries at St Luke’s church when they are interrupted by Colin, the mother of the groom’s dog depositing a skull at Grace’s feet. The police are called and the wedding is called off. The rivalry between the two villages and the alleged curse are seen to be the blame, it when the skull proves to belong to the body of a woman murdered twenty years previously the police are happy to close the case.
Grace’s grandmother is not so happy though and asks Ginny and her friends to try and find out how the skull got there. Their investigations uncover murky deeds and Ginny wonders if they are ever going to get the bottom of things.
A really good story that I enjoyed immensely, especially as it was full of twists and unexpected outcomes.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc.

Another feel-good edition to this cosy crime trilogy. Yes, we’re back with Ginny, the librarian turned amateur sleuth, in this third novel. (I previously reviewed the first book in the series, and you can read that here.) I feel like Ginny is really getting into her stride now – as you’ll know if you’ve read the previous books, she’s a really warm-hearted character and in this book, getting on, happier and more settled in Little Shaw. I love the quirky personalities of all of her friends and of Edgar, Ginny’s adorable black cat, too.

The setting evoked Miss Marple type villages, complete with cottages. It’s always lovely to lose yourself in a setting like this. The theme of this book was a cold case murder. I do love a cold case cosy crime, and the novel managed to weave the history of the local area successfully.

The investigation started off well with some suspects unfolding. However, at times, the plot line started to get a bit samey with Ginny and friends constantly interviewing suspects.

I couldn’t find many potential big plot clues or twists either to hook me into the storyline. Ginny had a very good rapport with some of the local force, and this could have been explored more. Things did pick up the pace towards the end of the novel when a rather dramatic showdown occurred with a great twist.

Ginny is such a great character, and there are other themes in the book, such as how older women are viewed in society. I hope in the next book, we get to hear more of Ginny’s inner thoughts. 3.5 stars.

"The Widows’ Guide to Skulldaggery" by Amanda Ashby is the third installment in the Widows Detective Club Series. Things become quite interesting when the local librarian, Ginny, attends a wedding that takes an unexpected turn due to an uninvited guest. This cozy mystery is filled with chaos, mayhem, and Ginny’s quirky sidekicks. I really enjoyed reading this book. Thank you to NetGalley, Amanda Ashby, and Storm Publishing for providing me with this advanced ARC copy for my honest review. for this advanced ARC copy for my honest review.

After signing up for a guide to skulduggery, I received a mystery filed with humour, love for one’s community and the twists and turns of a Dan Brown thriller.

Whilst at a wedding appropriate for the Montague’s and Capulets, a dog unearths a human skull, and evidence in a decades old murder mystery, causing the wedding to be cancelled.

We then join Ginny, and her friends Tuppence, JM and Hen who are helped by an eclectic cast of supporting characters to try get the wedding back on, and find out the true facts behind the cause of the surprise skull intrusion.

Remarkably well written, you can feel the warmth and camaraderie the main cast feel for each other.

This book has me on the edge of my seat at times, and caused a wide eyed, slow jaw opening moment once or twice (but I implore you to read it yourself, to find out why!)


For fans of: Agatha Christie, Janice Hallett, Dan Brown

I didn't realize this was book 3 until I had already started. This series is amazing and twisty on every page! I need more!

I have to be honest, I totally picked this book just because of the title. Skulduggery is a great word, and it fit this book perfectly, in a couple ways. I really enjoyed the four widows, each with their own strengths. They referred often to DI Wallace who lives next door to our main widow, Ginny, but he was absent for most of this book. This was a fun, surprising cozy, that kept me guessing. I will definitely be going back to start at the beginning of this series. 4 ⭐️

The Widows' Guide to Skulduggery is the third book in The Widows' Detective Club series, a delightful cozy mystery that delivers charm, intrigue, and engaging twists. The story follows Ginny Cole and her crime-solving group of widows, an endearing cast whose interactions and investigations are a joy to read.

The novel kicks off with the discovery of a skull at a friend's wedding, abruptly halting the celebration and setting the stage for the mystery. Since this isn’t an official police case, Ginny and her fellow widows take it upon themselves to dig into the truth. Their investigation leads them through a tangled web of family feuds and rivalries, revealing secrets that keep the tension high and the pages turning.

Ginny Cole, a librarian, brings a calm and rule-following demeanor to the group, making her an enjoyable protagonist to follow. Her sweet nature contrasts beautifully with the complexities of the mystery, adding to the book’s cozy appeal. The plot is fast-paced, layered, and filled with entertaining surprises, making this a fantastic addition to the series. The Widows' Guide to Skulduggery offers all the fun of a great cozy mystery, and I can’t wait to see what’s next for Ginny and her detective club.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

Goodness, I loved this book! The 'retirees/widows/widowers solve crime' genre has somewhat been done to death but I'm all for repetition if it's been done well. And this has been done well indeed! Not having read the first two books, I crash landed onto the third without any frame of reference for the characters or running themes/plots but that wasn't a deterrent as the previous two were hardly mentioned in this.

I love the ladies in Little Shaw, a fictional Lancashire village who go around sleuthing and get involved in another mystery when a skull shows up to disrupt the wedding of son of one of the noble families of Walton-on-Marsh to the daughter of one of the working class families of Little Shaw. A fabled curse that supposedly strikes everytime a Little Shaw resident decides to marry a Walton-on-Marsh resident is said to be the cause, but of course, our ladies have to prove the curse is very much a fiction.......

This book starts off strong and involves a cold case that very much melds together with the present to bring out the history of the two feuding villages with a startling twist at the end that neatly ties it all together. The book is well written and well paced. I understand that DI Wallace was an important character in the first two books and in this instalment, is on an overseas holiday so his absence is felt. Nonetheless, the ladies do well in their investigation and the book is an entertaining cozy mystery which I thoroughly enjoyed reading.

I would highly recommend this and look forward to reading the first two books in the series.

4 stars/5.

This is an undemanding novel which is an okay read, but it isn’t memorable. For me, much of it was unconvincing and didn’t ring true.

Ginny Cole is watching family members and guests snipe at each other as they assemble for the wedding of a young couple Ginny likes very much. However, the wedding is disrupted when a dog deposits a skull at the feet of one of the wedding party.

The police quickly dismiss it as a historical crime, but the explanation doesn’t feel right to Ginny or her fellow widows. The lack of police interest means they have almost free rein to investigate the murder, and they find themselves delving into the past, while a very present danger threatens.

This is the third novel in a series, but it stands alone effectively. There are a couple of references to previous investigations, but I didn’t feel that I was lacking any information.

It’s the behaviour of people that I found unconvincing. The emphasis on social class in a small village seemed to belong to an earlier time. Breaking up with your fiancé altogether because your wedding was disrupted by the discovery of a skull is excessively dramatic. There were numerous times when characters said or did things that just didn’t ring true.

I also found the unwinding of the crime a little unconvincing. It’s true that people do things for nutty reasons, but I just found the motivations here lacked credibility.

Characters tended to be either good or bad. There wasn’t a lot of room for shades of grey. Despite this, the characters of the widows were one of the strengths of the novel. Ashby does an excellent job of depicting the grief of losing a long term partner and the challenges of making a new kind of life for yourself.

To be frank, I was probably not quite the right audience for this novel. This is essentially a cosy mystery, and I tend to like my crime a bit darker and more modern. Readers who prefer a sense of a time gone past, minimal gore, and a gentle approach to investigation will probably enjoy this.

The third Widows guide book by Amanda Ashby I have read and enjoyed. A gentle book that grips and entertains the reader. Thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the chance to ARC this book.

After reading The Widow's Guide to Murder and when this book showed up in the ARC list, I had to pick it up and give it a quick, breezy read. Ginny Cole and her lovely group of widows do not disappoint and deliver yet another cozy murder mystery, which includes a historical animosity between two towns and a double-death that occurred decades ago, which was classified as a murder and a suicide.

When the discovery of a human skull upsets and aborts the wedding of a dear friend, Ginny is convinced the skull didn't turn up out of the blue, but was intentionally planted to sabotage the wedding. When the police show no interest in the skull when it is confirmed to be of a woman who was found dead decades earlier, Ginny and her friends take it upon themselves to solve the puzzle.

The dynamic between Ginny and her fellow widows is a highlight. Their friendship is warm, supportive, and peppered with witty banter. Ashby gives each member of the detective club a distinct personality, and their camaraderie is delightful.

This book is a comfy, come-back-home kind of feeling for returning fans of this series, but can still be a charming read for readers new to this series.

A humourous mystery solving group- some might just think them nosy old biddies with nothing better to do but they get results! Thoroughly enjoyed the wedding of rivals and the polar opposites between the 2 families. Overall a well written and entertaining read!

The Widow's Guide to Skulduggery is a fun romp through a mystery. The cozy town of Little Shaw has their own detective team (willing or not) in Ginny, TJ, Tuppence, and Hen. They are brought in when a wedding is disrupted by the appearance of a skull in the churchyard. What happens next will keep you on your toes as the group finds ways to ask questions without being too direct (they're not the police, you know!). They are witty, wily, and wise. Keep reading!

The third in the Widows Detective series starts with the discovery of a skull interrupting a wedding. Lots of twists and turns leads to a satisfying denouement. I like the characters especially Edgar the car and Brandon the labrador. A quck, humorous read.

Book 3 of the Widows Detective Club is an enjoyable read but the story started off very confusing with so many characters. It begins at a wedding where the family's are definitely not friends, then the discovering of a skull at the church delays the wedding. The club is asked to look into who put the skull at the church and why. Village rivalry, superstitions and rumors threaten to end the nuptials for good if the women can't solve the mystery and soon because a new body has just appeared.
This was a satisfying read with something for everyone, it was hard to figure who the killer was and the women are such characters you can't help cheer them on. Thanks to Storm Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC. Definitely a great read.

I really enjoyed the previous books in this series and this was no exception. A quick fun read with a bit of quirkiness thrown in. Its book 3 in the series but it can be read as a standalone although I recommend reading in order to get the back story. I can’t wait for the next book