This was a fun, super spicy why-choose romance with some sweet moments mixed in. Vivian is a thirty-something librarian who ends up in a complicated (but hot) situation with three hockey players after a wild birthday night. Things take a turn when she finds out she’s pregnant, and the rest of the book follows her and the guys as they figure out what this unexpected future looks like.

I really liked the dynamic between the four of them—it felt supportive and surprisingly wholesome at times. They actually talk about their feelings, which I appreciated. It was cute watching them try to figure it out together, even if some parts felt a little rushed.If you’re into steamy group dynamics this is for you!

I quite enjoyed this story. I really liked the character development throughout the book, it never felt too rushed or too slow. Also the amount of spice scenes, not too many, not too few and spread out thought out the book.

My one qualm is how quickly the relationship came about. I get why cos other stuff had to happen but it felt a little rushed to me.

Apart from that, I give it 4 stars. Nice quick read.

Thanks to NetGalley for this arc (i have added this review to my story graph linked on my account but I don’t know how to add it to here)

I had a great time reading this; it was exactly what it promised: a fun sweet spicy little romance with multiple partners!
Vivian is a university librarian, single and in her 30’s.
She finds herself in a situation ship with three hot hockey players and ends up being pregnant later on. The baby daddies are supportive and there for her, making sure she is not alone having her baby.
I loved the relationship between all four adults, they work through their feelings together when they’re anxious about the future involving a baby that was not planned. This was super cute and I would love to read more about these four.

2.5⭐️ rounding up to 3.

Thank you to NetGalley and Katie Ashley for the chance to read this arc.

If you’re looking for a smutty reverse harem hockey romance then you’ve found it. I was expecting a fun time and that’s what I got (most of the time).
What really put me off was how the male characters in this book spoke to the fmc. Looking back it was only a couple lines but it just felt that majority of the time one specific mmc was always talking down to her. Not really taking what she says as the truth or gaslighting her into thinking that something she feels strongly about is actually not that big of a deal.

This wasn’t my favorite and I would say the language used in the book was a pretty big turn off for me.

Omg this was so much fun. Hockey and accidental pregnancy are my favourite things and this did them so well. All the boys are so precious.

As Vivian's thirtieth birthday arrives, Vivian decides it's time to be a little adventurous. So, when Grayson, a student and hockey player asks her out on a date, she says yes. What Vivian thought was an innocent date, turns into a birthday foursome. Vivian swears to herself that their night was a one-time thing but when she finds she is pregnant, she must tell each of the potential baby daddies. As they await paternity testing, Grayson, Bennett, and Theo all fight for a place in Vivian's heart and bed.

I loved everything about this book, especially the polyamorous relationship between Vivian and her three hockey players. This is the ultimate why choose romance. I enjoyed how they supported Vivian in their way throughout her pregnancy and worked together as they navigated the ups and downs of their relationship. There is the right balance between romance and spicy scenes, and I loved every part of it. If you want a non-traditional romance with a lot of spicy scenes, I will recommend this book.

Three Pucks and a Baby is out now!

Thank you to NetGalley and Katie Ashley for the opportunity to review Three Pucks and a Baby. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

this was such a super read. it was fun, entertaining and just what i wanted going in. i didnt expect to be dawn in to it with so much heartfelt love for each of the plot points and characters. we got to know them, we got to feel them and i love how different they all were but somehow still slotted together. and i felt really warmed by how much they all cared for our main female character Vivian. their protectiveness was such a charming addition. because what a sticky situation they found themselves. a foursome. a baby. and although each of them reacted rather different to the news i loved seeing how it went on to be handled. it felt real. but still we saw such tender moments.
i wont tell you who my secret soft spots were for. and i admit they might have changed a little here and there in the book as some characters came to the forefront with their ability to grow. but i still felt a little eekish at one point worrying if any were going to make Vivian a safe home and baby daddy. would this be the right one? the right dad? the right one for her...okay or the right one for me as a reader. or what if, what if none of them was the right one? you see where im going. how much trickier it becomes when you give us one stellar lady and four men?
ive read a few surprise pregnancy books recently and ive been really enjoying how the authors have handled them. this one will definitely be added to the list of goodens.

Title: 3 Pucks and a Baby
Author: Katie Ashley
Rating:
⭐⭐⭐ (3 out of 5 stars)

Reviewer's Note: I received an ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Review:
3 Pucks and a Baby by Katie Ashley is a quick, fun read—perfect if you’re looking to add something lighthearted to your TBR before the end of the year. The story starts strong, with engaging characters and a sweet setup that blends romance and sports in an entertaining way.
However, about three-quarters of the way through, the plot begins to lose focus. Several promising storylines and aspects of the main characters’ development are left untouched or underexplored, leaving the ending feeling a bit rushed and unresolved.
Despite this, it’s still a solid pick for readers in the mood for a fast-paced hockey romance. If you're looking for something breezy and enjoyable to wrap up your reading year, this one fits the bill.

Would I recommend it? Yes—for readers seeking a light, quick romance read with a sporty twist.

Guys this book was a wild ride and honestly, I was here for it mostly. I have never read a reverse harem trope or romance novel about a polycule and I have to say it was both delightful and silly at parts. The spicy bits were 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ for sure and I’m not complaining about that. Some of the parts felt a little unbelievable or basic and I was shocked that jealousy between the guys never came into things. And, at the same time, I didn’t really care about any of that because it was a fun and light read for me.

This book was amazing! Can we talk about the dedication qritten at the begunnung haha that was unexpexted but funny which drew me in! The vision board was an awesome idea as it's very relatable. The spice was top tier. The story read at a natural pace, nothing dragged on or felt rushed! The ending wrapped things up nicely and answered any lingering questions I had. Bennet is my favorite! Being able to see the growth Theo had was definitely written out well.

Katie Ashley’s Three Pucks and a Baby is a very cute and fast read! I finished it in a day and really enjoyed the characters. However, the book takes place over about a year and it feels a bit like whiplash as you’re reading, especially the last 30% or so. I would’ve preferred a longer book with more details and follow up. Instead, Ashley brings things up in a chapter then moves on without details or follow up.

This book was such a fun, spicy, and surprisingly sweet ride. Katie Ashley really knows how to write chemistry, and the connection between the characters felt natural and super engaging. There’s a great balance of heat and heart, and I loved how the emotional side of things didn’t get lost in all the steam.

The writing is fast-paced (for the most part), and the banter kept me hooked. I also appreciated how the story didn’t shy away from the complicated parts of love and relationships—it was messy in the best way, and it made the emotional moments hit harder.

That said, there was a stretch near the end that dragged a bit. The story lost some of its spark during that part, and I found myself wishing it would just get back to the energy and momentum from earlier on. It didn’t ruin the book for me, but it did take me out of it a little.

I really enjoyed this one overall — it was sweet, fun, and had great found family vibes. The knitting and Tudor references sucked me in right from the beginning.

The FMC is a librarian who ends up in a threesome with college hockey players. Chaos and an accidental pregnancy ensue. This was a fast, fun read.

That said, I wasn’t totally sold on how the couple met or how quickly some issues were solved. I wanted to see more of what made the FMC so special to the three men. The age gap felt a bit glossed over too, especially with the college hockey quad setup.

Still, it was a feel-good read with a lot to like, and I’m excited to read more from this author!

3.5/5

Three Pucks and a Baby is a vibrant, unconventional hockey romance that surprised me in all the best ways. While I craved a bit more hockey action (a common wish in this genre), the off-ice drama and chemistry between the characters kept me hooked from start to finish. The story follows three inseparable teammates, known for their carefree, no-strings-attached antics, whose world shifts when one of them falls unexpectedly for a pragmatic, no-nonsense librarian—turning their easygoing dynamic upside down.

Katie Ashley masterfully balances sizzling heat with humor and emotional nuance, crafting a story that’s as heartfelt as it is bold. The push and pull between friendship, desire, and personal growth adds layers of complexity to an already fresh and playful premise.

On the character front, Vivian, the heroine, was likable though somewhat overshadowed by the guys. Bennett stood out as the most grounded and genuinely good match for her. Grayson impressed me with his loyalty, especially when he backed Vivian through her pregnancy reveal. Theo's journey dominates much of the story, making things a bit uneven at times. Despite this though, I found his growth to be satisfying. Pacing wobbled here and there, but the ending wrapped everything up in a satisfying and heartfelt way.

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the ARC!

This is a book you HAVE to read! It has everything that says it has, and much more. Three hot men, college hockey players (mature for their age), a librarian, an unexpected pregnancy. YES, PLEASE!

I have read this book in two days straight despite an upcoming test I have not prepared for.
Three Pucks and a Baby is a book that you will love if this, already mentioned, plots are what you wish for. This period of time is, for me, stressful because of tests, work and life generally, so this book was IT for me.

Funny story, great characters, so many different personalities that complete each other so well. I love how capable the author handled polygamous relationships, how she gave each of the characters their '5 minutes of fame'. Nobody was neglected.

I was scared of Theo and his comments. I didn't want him to make this reading unenjoyable, and I was worried about nothing. His character development was great - for someone scared and rude, he became open-minded and loving. AND Theo and Bennet, as a couple, were on fire with their pretending to not love each other.

​Steam, too. I enjoyed all of their smut scenes. It was on fire.

First of all thank you for approving my request!

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! The authors writing style had me hooked throughout this book.

I didn't want it to end, a book I really couldn't put down.

*Thank you to Netgalley, Victory Editing, and Katie Ashley for letting me read and review this story.*

**Book Review: *Three Pucks and a Baby* by Katie Ashley.**

**Rating: ★★★★★(5/5)**

Katie Ashley’s *Three Pucks and a Baby* is an irresistible reverse harem hockey romance that delivers on every front—heat, heart, and humor. Set against the backdrop of Southeastern University, this spicy and emotionally rich novel is the kind of book you pick up for a few chapters and accidentally finish in one sitting.

From the very first page, Ashley hooks you with a brilliantly written prologue that’s both clever and compelling. Using Vivian’s vision board and her word-of-the-year ‘Live’ as a narrative anchor—complete with delightfully quirky puns—she sets the tone for a story that’s not only sizzling but also had me laughing out loud.

At the heart of the novel is Vivian, a college librarian who breaks the mold in all the best ways. Older than her love interests and refreshingly grounded, Vivian celebrates her thirtieth birthday with an impulsive and slightly chaotic foursome involving three hockey players—and what follows is messy, funny, emotionally charged, and completely addictive. Ashley avoids info-dumping by allowing the characters’ dynamics to unfold naturally through their interactions, a choice that makes their relationships feel authentic and alive.

Each of the men in Vivian’s life brings something unique to the table, and their individual personalities, along with Vivian’s own compelling arc, drive the story forward. There’s thoughtful personal growth within the characters and the friendship between Vivian and her best friend Carlee adds depth and levity to the narrative. The dialogue sparkles with wit, the banter is top-notch, and the chemistry is absolutely off the charts.

And let’s not forget the steam—this book is undeniably spicy, with sex scenes that are not just hot, but exceptionally well written.

Overall, *Three Pucks and a Baby* is a fast-paced, feel-good, unputdownable romance that’s as fun as it is heartfelt. Katie Ashley crafts a world and a cast of characters so vivid, you’ll find yourself wanting more long after the last page. Whether you’re a fan of reverse harem, sports romance, or simply love a book that makes you laugh, swoon, and maybe cry a little too—this one’s a must-read.

Three Pucks and a Baby was a decent three star read for me. The story delivered on the spice and also had some fun cute moments. There was decent chemistry between the characters but I wish there was more lead up to the relationship and more development of it.

That being said, Theo is a problematic character. The way the author presented him was problematic, even if trying to build character to go through an arc of growing and changing. He just said too many misogynistic things for me and his reaction to Vivian being pregnant almost had me DNF-ing. I wanted to enjoy the bi-awakening storyline for Bennett and Theo but it didn’t really feel authentic and could have used more time for me.

Overall, this one may not have totally been for me and I don’t want to dissuade people from reading it cause I’ve definitely seen reviews where people enjoyed Theo’s character more - this is just my opinion on it.

Thank you, NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the opportunity to read and review this ARC!

Three Pucks and a Baby was a solid three-star read for me. It definitely delivered on the spice and had its cute moments. I really liked most of the characters, and the dynamic between the leads was enjoyable, though I do wish there had been more development and yearning(?) between them.

That said, there were several points where I seriously considered DNF-ing. Theo, in particular, was a character I really struggled with. His misogynistic comments, toxic behavior, and hints of internalized homophobia made him hard to tolerate. While I get that the author was going for a certain arc with him, it just didn’t work for me. Even with a slight redemption arc, I still disliked him.

There were also moments where it lost my attention, felt the plot getting kind of lost. And near the end, a certain twist about the baby’s paternity left a strange aftertaste that I didn’t love. Plus, the guys felt so immature for being 23, I feel like they were kind of annoying sometimes.

That said, I can’t say I didn’t enjoy it. It had its fun, entertaining moments and some sweet dynamics. <3 Would definitely read more from the author.

Ooh yikes. This one wasn't for me. From the misogyny to the slut shaming, and the weirdness about bennett being bisexual, not to mention the Harry Potter references, I just could not bring myself to love it. It was cringey and poorly written, and made for a less enjoyable book overall. I was really stoked at the idea of this one too, but it didn't pan out, which was really disappointing.