This book explores a topic that is not often discussed in depth, which I found particularly fascinating. I've always been curious about the brief mentions of attempts to persuade Canada to join the American colonies, and this book provided a much-desired deeper dive into the subject. The author's extensive research and clear presentation of this obscure topic are commendable. I believe this book would be an excellent resource for students.

.Interesting and detailed book looking at the early history of Canada and the capture by the British and its relationship with its southern neighbours USA (13 colonies) however complex and Franklin moves to incorporate it within the newly established united states but looks at the reasons why he failed. found the book overall insightful and interesting

This is a fascinating, little-studied topic and a very easy read, making it perfect for students writing history papers and casual readers as well as historians. I loved the simple section headings which made it easy to find what I was looking for in the text. The general context is extremely helpful and make the book self-sufficient for introductory research purposes. My own interest in the American Revolution has little to do with Canada, but I learned a lot from this book regardless. I definitely recommend it for institutional libraries.

By the way, nothing to do with the book itself, but it is frustrating to see another NetGalley user review this book using AI-generated nonsense text.

He Did Not Conquer by Madelaine Drohan is a compelling blend of historical narrative and investigative insight that challenges the conventional glorification of colonial figures. Centered on General Charles Gordon, the book critically examines his military exploits and imperial ambitions, particularly in Africa. Drohan skillfully peels back the layers of myth surrounding Gordon, revealing a man driven by personal conviction but also blinded by arrogance and a distorted sense of mission. Through rich archival research and balanced storytelling, she exposes how his actions, far from heroic, often left chaos and suffering in their wake.

What sets this book apart is its timely reassessment of historical "conquerors" in light of ongoing global conversations about colonialism and historical accountability. Drohan does not just critique Gordon; she interrogates the entire colonial mindset that enabled and excused his failures. The writing is both accessible and rigorous, making complex historical dynamics understandable without oversimplification. He Did Not Conquer invites readers to think more critically about who we choose to celebrate in history and why—a necessary and thought-provoking read for anyone interested in imperial history or modern debates about legacy and justice.