This was a great book! It was the perfect mix of romance and paranormal. The story was so fun to read and the banter was great!

Reality dating show but make it supernatural?? Take my money- take it all 🤚

This was so unexpectedly fun and interesting. The drama? the secrets? the twists? I fear this was just as entertaining, if not more than actual reality tv shows.

Caliope was hilarious lmao her giving each contestant a nickname had me cackling. I like that she was goal oriented and had a solid head on her shoulders even if she was kinda naive at times.

ARC Review - Supernaturally Perfect by Quinn Zamora

Thank you to Quinn Zamora and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC and give my opinion!

This book was so much fun - a supernatural dating show! Caliope had me giggling and I enjoyed Vance. Looking forward to the next book!

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Tropes:
* Supernatural romance
* Sexy game show
* Forbidden romance
* Secrets and drama

Thank you to NetGalley, Quinn Zamora, and Three Amigas Press for this eARC! This was a great first book of this series!

I’m a big fan of shows like Love Island and Too Hot to Handle, so I loved this paranormal spin! The mystery of Vance, and how that caused tension and chemistry to ignite between him and Calliope, was such a good combination for this type of romance. It sets up the next book so well and I can’t wait to read it!

I also enjoyed the other contestants on the show, and felt their supernatural types and personalities were good foils for Vance and Calliope, who seemed so perfect on camera-and for each other.

The pacing of the book was well done, and each challenge and elimination was exactly the right amount of drama and excitement, just like watching the real world shows that inspire this!

Reality dating show but make it supernatural?? Take my money- take it all 🤚

This was so unexpectedly fun and interesting. The drama? the secrets? the twists? I fear this was just as entertaining, if not more than actual reality tv shows.

Caliope was hilarious lmao her giving each contestant a nickname had me cackling. I like that she was goal oriented and had a solid head on her shoulders even if she was kinda naive at times.

Vance was kinda boring until he wasn’t. Hot damn but his loyalty makes me wanna cry 😭

I’m soooo invested in the series pls I neeeeed the second book 🙏

ೃ⁀➷ Thank you NetGalley and Three Amigas Press for the ARC! ♥︎

Thank you NetGalley and Three Amigas Press for this ARC.

Unfortunately this was a miss for me. Interesting premise but there was no real plot or character development whatsoever??? Everything went in circles and so many ideas brought up but nothing was adequately addressed. I felt the book was longer than it needed to be since nothing really happened.

I get no-communication/miscommunication would be a big barrier based on the whole set up of a supernatural reality TV show, but what we got was diabolical. A handful of opportunities to move the plot along but the couple would face setbacks and quickly turn on each other with the slightest breeze without even bothering trying to hash things out whenever they did get an opportunity to talk.

I did appreciate the little interview snippets at the start of each chapter which adds to the reality TV show bit, but they were pretty useless and didn't really reveal anything substantial. Side characters were vague and I just stopped remembering who was who. Also thought there would be more on the supernatural side of things but it was all quite surface-level.

Personally, I'm just confused. Other readers would probably enjoy this more than me.

Would not read again.

Overall rating: 0.5/5

📖
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
🌶️🌶️/5
📆 Pub Date July 28 2025
♥️ love island meets sci-fi romance
♥️ steamy challenges
♥️ supernatural reality dating show

I truly loved the unique concept of “Beach of Bliss,” a mix of Love Island meets sci-fi romance. The drama is dramaing in Supernaturally Perfect, offering a raw look at what the characters are truly feeling behind the scenes, questioning the reality of the show’s true intentions. I truly loved all the main characters and the found family and friends that Calliope acquires within the season. I also really appreciated the confessionals at the beginning of each chapter, making it truly feel like you’re reading an episode of the show. If you love reality TV and modern magic, then this book is for you!

This book was not only incredibly fun to read, but the plot had me hooked right from the start!
I love how our FMC is a strong, confident woman. You don't need to be a warrior to show strength, and this book proves it. Callie is amazing—smart, flirty, and always one step ahead. I honestly didn’t expect to love a character like her so much, but the author did a fantastic job bringing her to life. She’s intriguing, and I just want to know more about her!

Vance is perfect. He’s moody, grumpy, and emotionally closed off... just the way I like them. But we also get to see his POV, which is brilliant—it really helps us understand him better. Without that insight, I probably would’ve been pretty frustrated, lol.

PNR usually isn’t my thing (I tend to roll my eyes at the plots), but this one totally surprised me. It’s fresh, funny, smart, and so addictive—I just wanted to keep reading!

Great story! This isn’t my first Quinn book, and she did not disappoint.
When does the second one come out??

This book was so much fun and it was exactly what I expected from the title and description: Paranormal romance? Yes please! Reality dating show? Uhm, that’s my guilty pleasure. WHY ARE THERE NOT MORE BOOKS LIKE THIS!?

This was just way too much fun. I felt like I was not only watching and enjoying the drama of reality TV, but also getting the behind the scenes of the production and games. And mixing in all the supernatural elements? This was just too much fun.

The story ends on a cliffhanger and that’s my only complaint, that I have to wait for book 2! Ugh! But it sounds like book 2 will release soon after this one, so I’m ready for it!

Supernaturally Perfect blends the seductive tension of paranormal romance with the voyeuristic chaos of reality television, creating a story that’s addictive and emotionally grounded. I am a sucker for some vapid reality TV... so I signed on. And I'm so happy I did.

Beneath the glitter of camera lights and carefully curated personas is a cast of supernatural creatures—demons, vampires, werewolves, and a djinn roommate whose power isn’t sanitized or soft. I appreciated that hint of darkness. The magic in this book still feels dangerous, and the stakes are high—emotionally and literally.

The main character, Calliope (yes named for the muse of legend) is vibrant, sharp-witted, and unafraid to flirt or push boundaries, which makes her a compelling foil for the brooding, secretive Mr. Perfect. Their chemistry shines throughout even in the quiet moments, and the slow unraveling of his secrets is deeply satisfying.

Between the forbidden magic, the high-stakes challenges (yes, including truth-or-dare and those infamous dance competitions), and the threat of banishment to hell for breaking the rules, there’s a lot to enjoy. But what lingers is the way this book balances spectacle with sincerity, attraction with vulnerability.

If you enjoy supernatural romance that doesn’t shy away from the darker edges of its world—or its characters—this one is worth picking up.