Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A very emotional and heartbreaking story based on fact. Beautifully written, it tells the story of Cora and Caesar who plot their escape from a cotton plantation. Violent, movingand unbelievable what people had to go through to live a free life. For any one who enjoyed Roots this one is for you.

Was this review helpful?

Whitehead's writing is so vivid that it feels like you're in the room/field/tunnel where this book is happening which is good, but also disturbing at turns because there is a good deal of violence in this book (just like there was in real life for people who were enslaved). While it did get a bit long winded at times and some of the backstories felt a little unnecessary (like we knew immediately Ridgeway was horrid, we could have done without learning about his relationship with his dad), I did quickly get through this book, mainly because I just could not put it down. Colson Whitehead is an incredible writer and we are the luckier for having his words in our lives.

Was this review helpful?

The Underground Railroad is extraordinary. The novel reimagines the historical Underground Railroad as an actual, physical railway system, blending historical reality with powerful fiction. Whitehead’s storytelling is both gripping and profound, pulling readers into the harrowing journey of Cora, a young slave who seeks freedom and a better life. The novel’s innovative approach and vivid, evocative prose make it an unforgettable read. Whitehead masterfully combines intense emotional depth with a relentless pace, creating a narrative that is both thought-provoking and compelling. The book doesn’t just tell a story; it immerses you in a brutal and breathtaking world, offering a fresh perspective on a crucial chapter of American history. For readers who have previously read Whitehead's The Nickle Boys, this will feel familiar.

Was this review helpful?

A brutal and engrossing novel about an awful situation. Now adapted into a TV series - the book is well worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to see something in this but ... I just could not. It felt like another instance of literary torture where the reader is required to bear witness to various fictional atrocities as if to somehow show respect to those which have occurred in real life. But honestly, it felt derivative. And I have read this story so many times before. I read Beloved. I read Ruby. I have watched Twelve Years A Slave. And this story didn't feel like it brought very much that was fresh to the genre and it was just *so* depressing. It would have helped if I could have felt some connection to the characters but they all felt pretty cliched to me. I will keep my review private since I was not able to make it more positive.

Was this review helpful?

This is such an amazing, classic book, and by the first few pages, it's easy to see why. This book is so poignant and heartbreaking, and I was hooked the entire way through.

Was this review helpful?

Harrowing. Words came to live in a vivid and compelling manner. This book has been in my to-read list for quite some time, and I’m kicking myself for not getting around to it earlier. A fantastic read.

Was this review helpful?

This book for me is complicated. Maybe it took me too long to read, maybe it wasn't the right time, and maybe it just was not for me. A book so profoundly important and culturally relevant surely does not need my dissenting voice. However, I can firmly say this lived up to the praise for me. I will be inclined to read more of Whitehead's work, but this novel was not captivating and compelling to me.

Was this review helpful?

Horrifying, sickening, tragic and yet hopeful, all rolled into one tale about an incredible woman named Cora fleeing the atrocities of slavery in the American south. It was so hard to read some of the story - the brutality was just laid bare - but I couldn't put it down. I liked the small chapters on the history of some of the ancillary characters and would've enjoyed more of that. Whitehead's twist on the Underground Railroad - making it an actual train with "stations" underneath homes and barns - was really interesting and I wish he would've explored that more.

Was this review helpful?

An important and terrifying read. I tried to write a longer review than this, but I just can’t find the right words. It’s a haunting novel, made worse by the reality behind Whitehead’s fiction. A must-read for everyone.

Was this review helpful?

The underground railroad was an excellent read. I reviewed it on the blog in 2017 (linking below). It dealt with topics such as oppression of woman and slavery. I loved the way Whitehead makes the novel such an engaging one. But overall, I was a bit underwhelmed. I expected more. I read this along side Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi and I seemed to like Gyasi's narrative more. Neverthless, I read The Underground Railroad with a lump in my throat and I'd definitely recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

This book lives up to the hype! Whitehead's underground railroad is a real, if slightly mysterious/fantastical railroad which carries slaves on the run from plantations in America's southern states in the nineteenth century.

The setting is unique; historical but with a dystopian twist so that each state depicted functions semi-independently and has its own way of dealing with slavery. This allows Whitehead to expose the insidious nature of racism, the abhorrent cruelty of slavery and its legacy in a genuinely new way.

The novel's protagonist, Cora, undertakes several journeys on the railroad, and her journey brings us to a whole range of other characters from fellow slaves, to plantation owners, slave catchers, sympathetic white allies, doctors, and even grave robbers. Some of these characters appear only briefly, others have are more developed, but all are used to show the impact of slavery on America as a nation, and on Americans.

Was this review helpful?

This book is not usually my normal kind of read, but I do like to read an award nominated or winner book every now and then! It was a very difficult book to read. Not just for the fact that it was to do with the subject of slavery and the horrific treatment that the African American slaves had to endure but also because I couldn’t really get into it and found it all a bit depressing. Now I understand it’s not supposed to be an all singing and dancing book but I wasn’t expecting it to be as difficult a read as it was. I was initially really interested in the railroad and the history behind it and this for me was the difference between finishing and not finishing. The rest of the book, whilst true, was horrific and uncomfortable reading.

It did have some beautiful parts in it, but I’m afraid the book wasn’t really for me.

Was this review helpful?

A lot was written about The Underground Railroad, it was Oprah's Book Club selection, made it onto the list of Barack Obama's favourite books and author won many awards for this book, including Pulitzer Prize for Fiction and National Book Award. I finally read this book and I can appreciate and truly understand why so much was written about it. It's an excellent book, and to be honest I can't formulate my opinion on this book in an easy way. Because of the tough topic of the book, it's extremely hard for me to write a review on it, I'm not well equipped to write about horrors and hardships that are hard for me to image and understand and just cannot translate to any hardships in my life.

When it comes to books that cause tumultuous emotions in me, there are books that are hard to read because they hit close to home, and there are books like this, with such horrible crimes that aren't personal, but are just so devastating to read about and to image.

The main character, Cora is not fully developed character, we never learn much about her. We learn about her experiences, what she goes though, but her inner life is never truly show. I think this is a clever play on the slavery narrative, on how the experiences define the character, how Cora never has a chance to live freely and actually have a serious chance on experiencing new and enjoyable things in life. America is preventing her from being a free person, so we also never really get a fully developed character. As a reader, I become a witness to all the horrors and little joys of the story, witness who's detached from the story, who can just see what's happening but can never truly understand the characters. I never connected to the characters, but I didn't need that connection to care about them.

The idea behind the underground railroad it interesting, the concept of an actual railroad is fascinating and I wish we were given some history behind the railroad. Like Cora, I wish we got to learn how it was built.

Was this review helpful?

The concept was cool, but didn't strike me as particularly original. The main character, however, was engaging and well-written, and I think this would be a good book to handsell to many people.

Was this review helpful?

An intriguing way of describing the underground railroad that slaves used to escape from their hellish situations. It is very well written - sometimes hard to read - and an important book to keep reminding us of the terrible crimes committed by one race against another.

Was this review helpful?

I'm in the minority of people who didn't finish this book - I found it extremely depressing / unrelentingly grim (not entirely surprisingly, given its subject matter. However, given the awards it's won/been shortlisted for, I would give it to friends - although with a warning that it's a far from upbeat read.

Was this review helpful?

The Underground Railroad is an instant classic - it's up there with The Colour Purple and other greats. I'll be pushing this into the hands of everyone I know!

Was this review helpful?

Colin Whitehead is a new discovery for me and what an exquisite book he has written with “The Underground Railroad, one of the finest I read all year. Do not miss reading this novel.
I have to confess I was very reluctant to read this Pulitzer Prize winner as descriptions of cruelty usually stay with me for days. A book dealing with slavery in 19thcentury America I knew would contain scenes that I would find difficult to digest and I was right. But for some reason Whitehead’s writing did not affect me this way. The cruelty committed by the white population and American Southern plantation owners towards their black slaves was truly incomprehensible. One of the sentences in this book that really stuck with me is that “evil soaks into the earth”, an explanation why I always felt many countries and former colonies that have treated some of their citizens in the most brutal manner are unable to shed this bloody heritage, racism and hate still sticking in people’s behavior and minds. As one of the critics I read said so correctly, Colin Whitehead perfectly portraits “a road movie into the heart of America’s darkness”.

“The Underground Railroad” is a literary but highly accessible novel telling the story of Cora, a slave runaway and the history of the American Underground Railroad aiding slaves on their way into freedom up North or into Canada. Cora’s odyssey and her journey from inhuman plantation life in George in the mid-19thcentury and her escape with Cesar , a fellow slave, left me often almost in tears and despair for their plight. The journey she undertakes trying to stay ahead of Ridgeway, a slave catcher, experiencing passages of utter misery but also encountering selfless abolitionists and members of the Underground Railroad risking their own lives to help others, make for unputdownable reading. The cruelty and brutality human beings can inflict on others in this novel are sometimes unimaginable including other slaves telling on their own kind, behavior we encounter worldwide into the present when victims side with their oppressors. “The Underground Railway” and all the characters in this book captured my heart and mind until the very last word, particularly that of Cora’s fate

Was this review helpful?

Cora’s grandmother, Ajarry, had been taken from her village, in chains, marched for miles and sold a few times before even reaching American soil. Once reaching land she was again sold at “markets” before finally arriving at the Randall Plantation. It was here where Cora’s mother was born and from where she made her dash for freedom, leaving her, Cora, still a small child, in the care of her grandmother.

At first, when Caesar, a fellow slave, suggests to Cora that they try to escape, Cora is terrified, but then, because of circumstances that made her realise that staying was worse than attempting freedom, she changes her mind and the two, using the underground railway, running for miles, manage to get away from the Randall Plantation.

What they had not taken into consideration, was the Slave Catcher, Arnold Ridgeway, who had taken it as a personal insult when Mabel, Cora’s mother, had escaped all those years before.

Colson Whitehead has been criticised for very graphic scenes of violence. Without a doubt, reading how slaves were captured, raped, sold like any other “product,” beaten – often to death, disfigured or even burned alive is not light reading but it is unfortunately necessary to include simply because it is based on fact. Truth definitely hurts and reading this has given me nightmares.

What reading this book has taught me is that history, regardless of how ugly, must be told. By creating this novel, with Cora as the protagonist, the author has recaptured how harsh times were, but that, amidst all this horror, we’re introduced to people who are prepared to take on the might of these plantation owners and slave catchers to help slaves find freedom.

Treebeard

Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review.

Was this review helpful?