Stars: 3.25/5
Spice: 1?

What I liked: cozy fall small town vibes; endearing MMC; cast of characters; bit of mystery; creative resolution and interesting storytelling device in that chapter.

What I disliked: the FMC was whiny and self-centered, the sisters and mother were horrible to her, but we're supposed to be okay with it in the end; the town mystery has holes (how does the G&S society book a yearly event at a town they're not supposed to remember? How does the mom have a friendship/maybe more with a celebrity who is supposed to forget the town?); the MMC is maybe a little too hung up; a lot of the story lines were left dangling or just conveniently sorted out.

I have very mixed feelings on this one. By the end i was invested, but I got separated a few times a long the way. It's a nice, cozy idea that's missing something.

Thanks to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for this eARC.

This book should have been an email. There was so much unnecessary filler, the whole book takes place over like a few weeks then all of a sudden the last 5% jumps a whole year? And for what? Something that could have been solved if people would make a search party correctly. Couldn’t stand Scarlett. Violets sub plot didn’t have a resolution so why even put in? Also the whole mystery aspect was solved so quickly and easily with no lasting effect it was hard to wonder why it was such a big deal. This whole book was a big fluffy mess.

This was a super cozy and fun fall read. Definitely Gilmore Girls vibes (with some portions that felt straight out of the show) - with a hint of witchy/supernatural built in. Definitely recommend as a quick read to get in the mood for the fall season!

This book is a good addition to the cozy Fall witch genre, but doesn’t QUITE live up to some of its predecessors for me. It was a quick read and has all of the necessary cozy mystery ingredients- Scarlett has just returned to her magical small town following a desperate call from her family. The magic that usually keeps the town secret and safe and well, magical, is all over the place. The small town has to come together to help the family solve the mystery and get everything back in its place.

As I was reading, I found the family components to be super annoying. We’ve all read books where family drama is a major trope, but this one pushes it to a new level. The sisters are all fighting and snarky and the mother is a narcissistic pain in the butt. The level of snarkiness goes beyond sister feuds and quickly grates on the nerves. Scarlett blaming herself and accepting the blame placed on her by others becomes very repetitive.

With that said, I really enjoyed the ending of the book. The way that the problem is solved (no spoilers!) and then the way it is wrapped up to show the next year was really magical and it was reminiscent of the Practical Magic series. (Not the storyline, but HOW it was written.) I just found it to be the best part of the whole book.

I appreciate so much the opportunity to read this advance copy, thanks to Emily Grimoire and Avon Books!

I tried really hard to get into this book, but I think it ultimately wasn't for me. I loved the autumn/witchy vibes and the overall fall feeling of the story, however the plot seemed to jump around a lot and the dialogue between the characters felt disjointed. It just seemed to move from one character to another in a way that didn't feel natural. I do think the concept of the story was a good idea overall and that it could be great with some minor tweaking.

This was such a fun, witchy read! Perfect for the cozy vibes of the fall season!

This book was filled with lovable characters. The family tension was really well written, and the small town setting is absolutely dreamy. I loved the magic in town, the twisty portals, and I love a mini-trope of magic-in-trouble!

My real issue with this book though is just that I wanted more! More depth in some of the side characters' stories. I wanted more from the reckoning between Scarlett and her mama. Their relationship is so complicated and while they worked through a big trauma point for Scarlett, there was a lot more of their relationship that could have been explored. And finally I just wanted more from the ending. I wanted to feel more before we tied things up so neatly. The ending took place over a long period of time, but we only got to see it on a small number of pages.

Overall, this is a wonderful, sweet cozy fall read. Best enjoyed with an oversize sweatshirt, warm beverage of choice, and crisp autumn air! Bonus points for brightly colored leaves and chubby squirrels. Even if they aren't wearing berets.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this eARC in exchange for my honest thoughts and opinions. <3

such a good book to put you in the mood for fall & halloween!!

i am so glad i read this :) it was a intense mashup of gilmore girls x halloweentown x charmed.

with the scene set in autumn heaven, oak haven new england, the author creates the most perfect town of witches - imagine stars hallow and halloweentown had a baby, but when non-witches leave oak haven, they don’t remember anything. thanks to the forgetting spell that is cast over the town to protect it.

the story follows the melrose sisters, specifically scarlett, and the downfall of their beloved town. the sisters work tirelessly to solve the problem with magic in their town and restore it and all its glory.

the story has elements of romance - which had me hooked. i was rooting for nate and scarlett (as was the entire town). it also had family issues built in the story, with the difficult relationship between scarlett & her mom and sisters.

the storyline and the plot twist all fell into place and i thoroughly enjoyed reading this.

there wasn’t anything that sucked me in and made me obsessed with any of the characters. but overall it was a enjoyable read that took me a week or so to finish.

thank you netgallery for sending me this arc!!

Unfortunately I did have to DNF this book as I wasn't a fan of the writing and the characters within. I really enjoyed the premise from what I read and it had a lot of potential, I just couldn't get on with the childlike dialogue. For the right person though this will be a chaotic and fun read!

2.5/5 ⭐️

I am normally a fantasy reader but have found some great contemporary witchy books. As a super fan of both Gilmore Girls and Charmed I figured this would be the book for me. Unfortunately it wasn’t exactly my cup of tea.

The characters felt a little one dimensional and fell flat for me. The romance happened so fast and didn’t seem realistic.

The fall Halloween vibes were there, but overall I’m not sure I am the target audience for this book. I would have probably given an extra star if there were less pop culture references (muggle?!?) and less dialogue heavy scenes.

I have been in the mood for cute, autumn, cozy reads and was super excited to read this. However, Impractical Magic fell flat. The premise is super promising and intriguing but the execution was poor. It definitely felt like it was written as a young teenager.

You may love this but it just wasn't for me.

Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review :)

This book wasn't for me. The Gilmore Girls reference isn't really accurate. The writing was too hard to follow. Thank you, NetGalley.

If Gilmore Girls, Halloween Town, & Charmed had a baby it would be this book!
When I tell you I ate this story up!!!!!
If Stars Hollow was full of magic and witches it would be Oak Haven!
This story gave all of the La La Lalalalala La La feels! ( this is for the Gilmore girls girlies )
Our story follows Scarlett who is returning home after 10 years to help when her sister calls her with a crisis, magic has been going wonky back home and they don’t know how to fix it. Of course, once Scarlett gets there she comes face to face with the boy next door, the never quite snagged love of her life, Nate!
Of course in true cozy fantasy romance form she and Nate are constantly being thrown together in awkward situations that neither of them are too happy with…
It’s been 10 years!! Did Nate wait around pining for her?
Will Scarlett because able to work through the trauma that made her flee 10 years ago??
Will she be able to fix magic and save the town?
I can’t wait for you to find out!!!!
5 stars!!!!! Must read of Fall!!!!

This book was cute. I love a charming town and a story about witches. It felt like Hocus Pocus meets Gilmore Girls.

Scarlett is a spunky witch that comes back to her hometown after being away for ten years. She comes back to help her family with the chaos that’s running through the town. Magic is unreliable and is getting dangerous, and Scarlett has to fix it before her town becomes the next Jacksonville. Can she fix it all while maybe getting her second chance with her high school crush??

This book was a fun read, but nothing crazy. It’s definitely worth the read!

This book had the perfect witchy vibes I was looking for in a read. I loved the storyline of this book and how it had witches vs magicians. I also really liked the sisters and how they were each so different in their personalities. The end of this book had me all kinds of excited/worried/and a little stressed.

Overall I'm giving this book a 4.25/5 stars. I would recommend this book for anyone looking for something with witches in a small town.

Impractical Magic by Emily Grimoire is an enchanting read that perfectly captures the cozy essence of fall. Set in the charming town of Oak Haven, the story evokes a delightful nostalgia reminiscent of Stars Hollow, making it an ideal pick for Gilmore Girls fans.

The narrative revolves around Scarlett and her family as they delve into the intriguing mysteries surrounding the magic in their witchy town. I thoroughly enjoyed the rich character development, which made me feel like I was right there with them, navigating the unique challenges of their magical world. The vibrant setting and endearing community dynamics brought Oak Haven to life.

At the heart of the story is a sweet second-chance romance between Scarlett and Nate. Their chemistry is palpable, and their journey toward rekindling their relationship adds depth to the narrative. The blend of romance and the magical mystery keeps the reader engaged, making it hard to put the book down.

Impractical Magic is definitely for you if you enjoy heartwarming tales set in small towns, with a sprinkle of enchantment and a compelling love story. The mix of cozy vibes, romance, and mystery creates an inviting atmosphere that's perfect for curling up on a chilly evening.

I would rate this charming read 3.5 stars. It’s an excellent choice for book clubs ( I will absolutely be recommending it for my book club", sparking lively discussions about the characters, the setting, and the enchanting elements woven throughout the plot. Whether you're looking for a light-hearted escape or a feel-good story to enjoy with friends, this book delivers on all fronts. Don’t miss out on the magic of Oak Haven!

This book was really good, I found that the different themes in it were so well done and made me want to read more by this author.
I heard mixed reviews about this book before I picked it up but after I've read it I can see why people had negative reviews but I also see why people loved it. I read this book so quickly I thought it had only taken an hour when really I had been in my room all day stuck in their world.

They got me on Gilmore Girls meets charmed and while I feel that is somewhat true this book was not it. I expected more honestly. The writing was terrible and seemed just thrown out there.

The book fell flat for me and felt a lot of stuff was put in for filler.

I think this book had a lot of promise, but unfortunately, some story aspects did fall flat for me. It was still a fun read, but having the story be fleshed out more would have made it more enjoyable and easier to follow. I was left with more questions at the end, and wish that the main conflict had a bit more to it. The romantic lead was very sweet and down bad, which is something that I love to see, but the actual progression of the romance fell flat.

Thanks to Avon Books UK and NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book.

This book was exactly what I needed as a pallet cleanser after some very hard going books. The book itself had a great storyline and there was some definite grumpy male character vibes - the ending had me concerned for all Scarlett and Nate but I am very pleased with how it ended! Highly recommend for a halloween/:autumn read as it definitely makes you feel festive!

if you’re looking for a fun autumn read filled with witches, cozy small town vibes, and entertaining plot lines, look no further.

impractical magic is like if you took the vibes of halloweentown, gilmore girls, and maybe a little bit of hocus pocus (three sisters who are witches) and made it into a cozy fall book. it follows scarlett melrose, who is returning back to her small hometown after ten years, because her eldest sister has called her for guidance and help to save their town. magic has run rampant, things are not going right and it’s up to the melrose sisters to get to the bottom of it. we follow the the three sisters as they figure out their estranged relationship to each other and also building a new sense of community to help recover the magic in their town.

it also has a sweet subplot of a second-chance romance, which i also enjoyed. i was more entertained and curious about how scarlett would be able to save the town as opposed to her and nate’s reconnection but it was still cute.

i really enjoyed the pacing and the overall fun aspects of problem solving but make it witchy! the only thing that sort of took me out of it was the fact that it is set in modern times so we saw some references to uber and tik tok but it was still funny to read! i highly recommend impractical magic if you’re looking for a quick but cute autumn read this season!

thank you netgalley and avon publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!