Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Unfortunately this book is not for me. Whilst a cute concept, the writing style did not work for me.

Was this review helpful?

following closely to the story of ‘pride and prejudice’, ‘stuck up and stupid’ takes the classic and well-known storyline and gives it a modern twist. i think it works well as a ya summertime read, reminding me of ‘the summer i turned pretty.’ there were a lot of characters and it would have been nice to see some of them fleshed-out more and more of lily and dorian once they had settled into a relationship.

Was this review helpful?

I quickly realised that i wasn't the target market for this one but i must say I did actually really enjoy it and feel like this could be one of those books that a young reader would pick up and would have them excited to read more.

Highly recommend, to the right age group

Was this review helpful?

If I rate it as an educator in her fifties, this might be somewhere between 2 and 3. But if I rate it from the eyes of my Y6 students who are maturing so fast that sometimes they write about stuff that I wish they are still ignorant of, then it will be somewhere between 4 and 5. The bottomline is that I am not its target reader at all. The characters sound annoying to me, especially the mom. I am not sure if I see the reference to Jane Austen's work there. I do not hate the characters in Austen's work. But then that mom reminds me of a character my Y6 students created in her writing recently and that character was equally annoying.

So, I will give it a four. I think I need to rate it from the eyes of its target readers whom I am not though.

Was this review helpful?

im not sure on this one. im not sure it hit the write notes. but i never quite new why. i didnt know whether it really was too young so the depth i crave was lost, or couldnt be added because it needed to be plicable for a younger audience.
it felt like it was trying to be a take on the pride and prejudice but in name only. i didnt get many or any of the links really. but again was that to make it relevant for a younger audience.
it wasnt bad. it just wasnt enough or it didnt grab me.
the thing is i didnt not enjoy it. and looking at it now i do think my younger self would have enjoyed it. and it is for that age group so all in all its a success.
i think im far too used to young adult hooking me in.

Was this review helpful?

this was a nice fluffy book to read. I really liked the first half of the book but I do feel like the second half was bit rushed and also kind of random. I very much enjoyed my time reading this book! I also kind of want to go to Pippi beach LOL

Was this review helpful?

“I’m not just your mum, I’m a hot 🔥💯 mum.” Ahhhh😝 (sadly, that was the best part of the book). The first few pages had a strong💪🏽 start (considering the rest of the book), but it all went downhill👎🏽🚫 from there.

The third-person narration completely ruined it for me. It kept jumping between dialogue💬 and third-person descriptions in a way that just didn’t sit right❌. It made everything feel detached🥴.

The perspective👁️👄👁️ changes—if you can even call them that. There’s no indicator💡 at all. One second you’re reading about Lily, and then BAM, next sentence, it’s Dorian🙈. No paragraph break, no warning⚠️. It was so confusing🧠💥.

Like, at one point, we’re told Dorian is up in his house🏠 on a cliff🗻. I assumed he was outside🛣️ or maybe looking out the window🏙️, but then the next sentence is about the local kids diving🏊🏽‍♀️ off the cliff. Turns out, we had suddenly jumped into someone else’s perspective. How was I supposed to know that😤??

I don’t usually DNF books, but I had to with this one. The writing was just not it🌚. It wasn’t an easy or seamless read at all💨. Every few sentences, we were suddenly getting another character’s perspective🕶️—except it wasn’t even a proper perspective because it was all in third person.

I try not to be harsh🗡️, but from the little I read, there wasn’t anything good about this book🪦.

Thanks Netgalley for the ARC🥴💬💥

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute romance targeted at YA, but that could be read and enjoyed by all ages! I love the mother daughter team as I think it helped with insight to make all the ya lingo and references spot on! It was a cute romance about a celebrity coming to town and the aftermath that follows. I found it very cute and sweet! Highly enjoyed

Was this review helpful?