What If It's Us

This title was previously available on NetGalley and is now archived.
Buy on Amazon Buy on Waterstones.com
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.
Send NetGalley books directly to your Kindle or Kindle app

1
To read on a Kindle or Kindle app, please add kindle@netgalley.com as an approved email address to receive files in your Amazon account. Click here for step-by-step instructions.
2
Also find your Kindle email address within your Amazon account, and enter it here.
Pub Date 9 Oct 2018 | Archive Date 5 Nov 2018
Simon and Schuster UK Children's | Simon & Schuster Children's UK

Talking about this book? Use #WhatIfItsUs #NetGalley. More hashtag tips!


Description

From bestselling authors Becky Albertalli (Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda which was made into the film Love, Simon) and Adam Silvera (They Both Die At The End) comes a New York love story with a difference...

Meet Ben and Arthur. Ben is a battered dreamer who’s shipping his ex-boyfriend’s things back to him. Arthur is new to New York and struggling to fit in. After an memorable meet-cute in a New York post office, the boys lose touch only be be brought back together via a 'missed connection' advert. Is it fate? It looks like it. But after a series of disastrous first dates, Ben and Arthur may have to accept the universe should’ve minded its business.

From bestselling authors Becky Albertalli (Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda which was made into the film Love, Simon) and Adam Silvera (They Both Die At The End) comes a New York love story with a...


Advance Praise

‘Romantic, realistic and sweet, this perfectly captures New York, teenage love and life’
Lauren James, author of The Loneliest Girl in the Universe


‘So distinct, so real, that you are immediately sucked in.’ 
The Bookbag


‘This might just be the best book I’ve read all year.’ 
Pretty Little Memoirs

‘I had such high hopes for What If It’s Us and they delivered on every. single. aspect.’
Avid Bibliophile

‘Romantic, realistic and sweet, this perfectly captures New York, teenage love and life’
Lauren James, author of The Loneliest Girl in the Universe


‘So distinct, so real, that you are...


Available Editions

EDITION Other Format
ISBN 9781471176395
PRICE £8.99 (GBP)

Average rating from 71 members


Featured Reviews

Having heard such a lot about Becky Albertalli's successful and young adult novels over the past couple of years, and having been meaning to pick one of them up a lot sooner I thought this was a perfect time to do so. Let's just say I was so enamoured by it that I immediately grabbed hardback copies of Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda (published in 2015) and Leah on the Offbeat (published in 2018) both for myself and my nieces who I know would find this very entertaining but not only that, this book has some important messages for its young readership. I have always thought that the young adult genre is one of the most influential and YA authors have an unspoken duty of care to their young readers almost as celebrities have a duty to be mindful as to how they behave or what they let escape their mouths - role models if you will. I would venture a guess that Ms Albertalli has likely gotten another bestseller on her hands with this beauty!

There is such a lot to love about What If It's Us that it's going to be a struggle to mention them all, however, I will, of course, mention those I deem to be most important. Essentially, this is a beautiful love story between Arthur and Ben but it also explores racism, class prejudice and homophobia too. This is on top of all those pesky challenges that every teenager is subjected to. Both of the boys' friends are people that any teenager would be blessed to have in their corner - they are so supportive and reliable and what I would term "keepers" or "friends for life". Anybody would be incredibly lucky to count these guys as friends! The fact that the book explores the relationship between two gay teenagers in love and dissects their relationship makes this a gorgeous book for those like myself - a huge proponent of equality and LGBTQIA+.

It deals with topics sensitively throughout but doesn't shy away from exploring or highlighting particular issues and always does so with the utmost respect. What really impresses me about this book is that it is a fun, fast and light read that is bold enough to approach many issues that are important in the lives of youngsters but without compromising the story and making it feel heavy - not an easy thing to pull off, it shows just how masterful these authors are. Authentic feeling and realistic, it picks up on many topics that most youngsters will be able to relate to and empathise with. The many references to pop culture are obviously targeting the books main audience so will either hit the spot or go completely over your head depending on your age. I enjoyed this immensely, it is a quick read that has so much substance to it. I feel if you loved <i>Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda</i>, you'll fall hard for this too - just as I did! It captures your attention firstly before swiftly following suit with your heart, Cute, quirky, unmissable and utterly UNFORGETTABLE!

Many thanks to Simon & Schuster UK Children's for an ARC. I was not required to post a review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The story of Ben and Arthur and young love. The problems of a teenager in love while overcoming social issues of race and discrimination and homophobia on top of being a gay teenage boy dealing with being a teenager in a world of confusing times.

The part I loved about this book the most was the supporting friendships of both Arthur and Bens friends but especially of Dylan as his love for Ben was unconditional and brutally honest!

If you loved Simon vs. The Homo-sapiens (Love, Simon) you will love this book!

Was this review helpful?

I'm a sucker for Becky Albertalli's particular brand of bittersweet romances, but had never read anything by Adam, so came into this cautiously optimistic. And what a read! I think this might be one of my favourite reads so far. There's some beautifully sweet romantic moments, I loved all the musical references far too much and Arthur and Ben are brilliant main characters. Really sensitive issues like money problems and feelings of academic failure are covered brilliantly too. I liked the ending too, felt very realistic rather than very romantic.

Was this review helpful?

I have been waiting for this novel since the day it was announced and, as you can probably imagine, it did not disappoint.



☾ the writing:
I have to admit that I was a little unsure about how Becky and Adam’s styles would mesh, because Becky is known for her light, relatable contemporary, while Adam’s books can get a lot darker and generally pack a punch or two. I’m so happy that all my expectations in that regard were exceeded. They were able to co-author it very seamlessly, all the while giving the characters very distinct personalities by including their respective writing styles. So if you love Adam’s and/or Becky’s writing style, I’m sure this will be right up your ally.



☾ the characters:
Another thing that we are used to seeing in both author’s books is the amazing diversity of their characters. While it obviously features gay romance, that is not where they stop. Ben is Puerto Rican (and struggles with being white passing!!) and Catholic and Arthur is Jewish and has ADHD. There’s a girl who wants to get into programming apps and a character who suffers from panic attacks.
It’s one of those stories where all of the characters are so easy to love, but not because they are two dimensional or ‚perfect‘, but because they are the kind of people you would like to be friends with and they might just feel a bit too real at times. Their flaws and the fact that not everything was as smooth sailing as it usually is in YA romance was a big winner for me!

I really related to Ben and he’s definitely a character that will keep his special spot in my heart and will not be forgotten soon, if ever.



☾ the plot:
Now look, of course this was gonna be predictable to some degree. All of us knew that they would somehow find their way back to each other after their meet-cute at the post office (OR DO THEY?). But what I did not see coming was that this story would not only be about a beautiful romance, but would also focus heavily on friendship. I completely adored the friendship dynamics in this and honestly, I should not have expected less from Becky, who does friendships better than anyone.
I loved how it challenged the friends to lovers trope with the simple question of: „What if it does not work out?“ („But what if it does?“). It was also SO refreshing to not see another villanized ex-boyfriend.

Probably my favorite part of this novel was the fact that pretty much nothing was smooth sailing. Just when you think that it’s gonna turn into another cliché YA contemporary romance we hit another bump in the road and, god bless, not only because of miscommunication (although there’s some of that as well, I’m looking at you Ben), but just because they’re written to be so painfully human. I love the big role that ‚do-overs‘ play in this book and the fact that it might be able to teach people a thing or two about when to keep trying, even if things don’t immediately work out perfectly.

I personally really loved the ending (more about that in the spoilery section of this review!) and am so happy that we actually got to see true character development.



☾ the setting:
This isn’t usually a separate category in my reviews, but I would do this book a huge dishonor if I did not explicitly mention it. It’s set in New York City, only my favorite city on earth, no big deal. If you’ve ever been to New York, this is a treat. The references are so seamlessly woven in that it doesn’t feel obtrusive, but super duper enjoyable. Think: the exact right amount of delicious chocolate chips in a very good cookie.

Another thing that Adam and especially Becky are both masters at is referencing pop culture and that’s another aspect that did not let me down.

And the most obvious one: if you’re a Broadway fan you probably already have this on your radar for the title alone, but let me just tell you, it only gets better. You will not be disappointed, Arthur has your back.



☾ spoilery thoughts:
Boy, oh boy. I was pretty sure that I was going to absolutely like this book, but I ended up absolutely loving it, which is even better. The beginning was pretty cliché in my opinion, with them trying to find each other, but always barely missing each other. But that does not mean that I wasn’t immediately rooting for them, because I was.
Arthur is the type of character that’s right up my ally: no chill, funny, a bit dorky. He was so fun to read about and instantly lovable. As already mentioned I really enjoyed Ben from the get-go, because I really relate to him and the way that he thinks.
Dylan is another character you just have to love. He gave the book the perfect amount of comic relief (with a lil help from Arthur’s dad). The only thing that bothered me a little about his character was the fact that he would constantly make jokes about him and Ben being somehow sexually involved and I although it was funny to an extent, I do think that it did get too much at some point. If this were a f/m friendship, people would probably frown upon it a lot more and I think that we should treat all friendships the same, no matter if it’s two girls, two boys or a boy and a girl, ya feel? I just think it was unnecessary.

Where I really started to loooove this book was when the boys did not immediately click on their date and had to try again and again to actually build a connection, because that’s real life right there. It wasn’t as picture perfect as most – especially YA – books make love out to be.

Another really strong part of the book was the Epilogue. I feel that is where people are either gonna say they love it or they hate it, but I obviously loved it. I think it was amazing to see Arthur and Ben having this strong friendship and talking and still having a soft spot for each other. BUT they did not build their whole life around each other. They did not completely disregard every other aspect of their life to be with each other. They stayed their own person and continued on with their life, because that is the most important thing. And Arthur’s character development? AMAZING, my baby, I CRY. He’s so distinctly different in his last chapter than he is in his first and that is great writing right there. I love that he gets to make his own experiences and grow as a person without anything or anyone holding him back.

Of course I’m rooting for them to get together in the alternative universe where these boys actually exist. But I’m also rooting for them to become the people they have to become to be happy and do their thing. I feel like a lot of YA novels do not send the right message when it comes to this and it was SO refreshing to see an ending where it wasn’t all about the love. It wasn’t a picture perfect happy ending, but it wasn’t tragic. It was an ending and everyone was happy and that’s that.

All in all, well… what more can I say? I enjoyed this even more than I thought I would and I cannot wait for all of you to finally read it in a few day.



☾ rating: 4.5/5 stars


Tw;cw: homophobia, panic attacks, racism, cheating

Was this review helpful?

Highlights

Cuteness levels

Both main characters

Dylan 😍

Overall

I just had a really stressful week which ended on a bad note, and I came home to this book. It was totally what I needed and I loved every single piece of it. I completely forgot time on Friday evening and ended up reading until 1am which is a very rare occurrence for me. I loved this book! ❤️

This book made me very happy and fluffy 😊


The Story

The story is dual perspective between Arthur and Ben, and follow their summer in New York trying to find each other, figure each other out, and figure out what the universe is planning for them.

There are sociologically interesting elements touched on in this books too. The is a homophobia scene, a racial moment, a clash of religion moment, and the meeting of two economically different families. All of these scenes and moments were done very well.

The Characters

Arthur is staying in New York for the summer working as an intern for his mom's law firm. He is a musical buff and is a person who loved life and feels the universe is on his side. I really liked Arthur as the little naive, inexperienced, cute boy in the big city type.

Ben is the New Yorker in summer school. I prefer Ben to Arthur, or sure why but he was probably my type of guy. He is Porto Rican and from the more middle-class area of New York.

Arthurs friends and Bens friends are also there. They all give you a better understanding of who the main characters are. Arthurs friends from home set the scene of who the trio is at home. Same with Ben and Dylan. But Dylan is very funny and I absolutely loved him as a character. Come to think of it, Dylan might be one of the reasons Ben was my favourite character, I would love to have a friend like Dylan.

LGBT+?

Oh, Holy Hell Yes!! The entire book is centred around a m/m romance and it's the cutest 😍

Writing

Loved it. On occasion, I found it difficult to differentiate between the two narratives and I got confused to who was talking/narrating sometimes, especially in dialogues between Ben and Arthur.

Apart from that, I loved how the texts are displayed and the overall writing was very easy to read.

Considered this book is co-authored, I couldn't tell whilst reading. I don't really know either of these authors books or writing styles, so I wouldn't know them anyway. 

Summary

Loved it!

I will totally live on this cuteness for a while.

I've already pre-ordered a copy for myself

Hey! Netflix! You looking for something else to adapt? Look no further!! I demand you to adapt this!

Was this review helpful?

A love story but also so much more than a love story - that's what Becky Albertalli and Adam Silvera wrote here. And I loved all of it so very much.

These two authors, brilliantly on their own and even more so together, wrote a story about two gay teenagers falling in love that somehow both manages to be very cliché and adorable but also distinct and unexpected.

The main characters, Ben and Arthur, jumped up from the page immediately and I felt connected to and interested in them from the very beginning. Their adventure is fun and heartbreaking and dramatic and everything I expected from these authors plus a lot more.

Ben and Arthur try to have a perfect romance but it doesn't work out that way. Nothing is perfect but they still find something so beautiful that helps both of them grow and accept some of their flaws and it connects them more or in a different way to people that are very important to them.

I did not expect to read so much about complex friend groups that aren't what they used to be and complications with all parts of life but here we are.

This book really is the best of both worlds - Silvera's sad love story and Albertalli's sweet teens who make way too many pop culture references. What If It's Us made me smile like an idiot and nearly cry and it never let me go. I always wanted to know what happens next and where the story ends.

This book has some very unexpected twists and that makes it such a unique and even more wonderful story than all the other amazing things about it.

Was this review helpful?

What a perfect story. I always love books that have multiple perspectives. And what a joy these characters are.
The story is full of hope, joy and a dash of realism for those wanting it.
It would make the perfect Christmas present for the teen in your life x

Was this review helpful?

Two of my favorite authors have come together to create MAGIC! This story is sweet, engaging, adorable and well crafted MAGIC. I can't think of another word to describe it right now. We need more stories about gay men in love and they need to be read by everyone! I'm so happy i got to read this and i'm telling all my friends to read this because it's such a wonderfully written and moving story.

Was this review helpful?

This book was honestly so cute, but also an emotional roller coaster!! But to be honest, I didn't expect any less of these two authors! I really enjoyed it and definitely recommend it :) However, there were some little things that frustrated me and got me a bit disappointed (like the ending).

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely read!
I had only read one of Becky Albertalli's books before and none of Adam Silvera's but this cute fun read made me want to rush out and get them all.
There are lots of fun references to pop culture and fancoms which i think will appeal to anyone and the friendship dynamics are realistic and sweet.
This book tackled some difficult topics but did so tastefully and respectfully.

I enjoyed this immensely and recommend to all.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! I am a fan of both Adam Silvera and Becky Albertalli and personally I thought that their voices blended together to form this narrative.

There is so much to love about this story, but what really captures your heart is the love story between Arthur and Ben. They are both such engaging and empathetic characters and you find yourself cheering for them to succeed.

As well as being a touching love story, What If It’s Us also touches on more serious issues of racism, homophobia and class prejudice. Both authors deal with these issues in a sensitive manner that is woven into the main body of the story so they are brought to the reader’s attention in a subtle way.

If you are a fan of either of these authors I would definitely recommend this read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for sending me an e-copy of this book, I also managed to grab an physical arc in a trade!

Okay, so, I gotta begin this quick review by saying that this is such an amazing, adorable book! I absolutely loved it and I want more!

There are two points of view in this book, Arthur and Ben. They have their meet cute in a post office in New York but they never get each others contact details so they both end up trying to look for each other, Arthur does try a hell of a lot harder than Ben does though but they finally get to meet and have their summer of romance!

I was so excited to read this book that I actually ended up hesitant for a hot minute because what if I didn't like it? What if it didn't live up to my expectations? TURNS OUT IT WAS EVERYTHING I WANTED AND MORE! I've not actually read a single Adam Silvera book before this so I know I need to get to his other books (I only own History is all You Left Me) but I have read all of Becky's books prior to this!

I very highly recommend this book, I just flew through it, it was absolutely everything! You are all going to love it!! The ending was perfect, wasn't predictable in the slightest as it wasn't how I thought it was going to end whatsoever so I love how well rounded the ending was :3

Buy it. Read it. LOVE IT! I'm excited for my full cover copy to come next week and I'm hoping to eventually read Adam Silvera's books soon.

Was this review helpful?

Well, that was a rollercoaster and a half of a read. Since the announcement that Becky and Adam were going to write a book together, it seems like every YA reader has been desperate to read the end result. I was fortunate enough to have an awesome friend who booked us tickets to meet both authors in London later this month [so stay tuned for that] and we get a copy of the book with the event. I was planning on just waiting it out, but then Netgalley had e-book ARCs to request and I went and hit the button…

Anyhow. Prepare for all the feels. Honestly, this book will make you laugh and then sob and then repeat that process over and over again. Honestly, I was expecting it a bit, especially considering Adam has a knack for messy-cry books, but I feel like Becky has gone and joined the dark side of authors who wish to crush my heart with feelings.

The book is very funny, I’ll give it that. I loved seeing so many nerdy jokes in there, alongside about a gazillion Hamilton references. There was so much culture packed into the pages, that you really couldn’t help but be swept along by it. I almost felt like I was in New York right alongside the characters. And then there’s all the meet cute bits that made me die a little inside [in a good way] because it seems like Arthur is the most cinnamon roll character ever. Like, I thought Simon from Simon Versus… was a cinnamon roll, but this reaches new heights and OMG. Obviously, as with every other Adam and Becky book, the characters are one hundred percent awesome and lifelike and you kinda just want to wrap them up in a giant blanket and smother them with affection [again, in a good way]. I liked how they seemed so like real people, in fact they reminded me of my own friends.

Also, I just love that this book is simply about two boys having a romantic relationship. Sure, there are moments when issues like ‘coming out’ and homophobia are tackled, but it’s clearly not a book that’s meant to deal with that. Which I am really pleased about. We have lots of books about characters discovering their sexuality, or about them braving telling parents etc, and while I love those books too [including ones written by Adam and Becky] I’m also pleased that there’s an LGBTQ book which is just about the gloriously fluffy romance. Both characters are already ‘out’ in the book, both sets of parents already know. And that’s just great really.

On the slightly more critical side, I do think some of the drama was a bit overblown. I won’t get into it too much in this review, because the book is only just coming out now and I don’t want to have spoilers for people, but some of it made me roll my eyes a bit. I’m not sure if its just that I’m jaded and that I’m now in a long-term relationship, but some of the arguments and the secret-keeping and the jealousy just seemed… unnecessary. Some of it really wasn’t a big deal, but the book turned those molehills into mountains. I get that its a YA book, and that almost guarantees a certain level of angst, but maybe dialing it down a notch would still make it a brilliant book.

Overall, I’m giving What If It’s Us? 9/10 stars. I loved the fluffy romance and the characters, but I do wish that there was a touch less drama going on.

I’m definitely recommending this book if you want your dose of cute, fluffy LGBTQ romance with a big scooping helping of ugly crying. Trust me, keep the tissues handy. What if It’s Us? will be released in the UK on the 18th October.

Was this review helpful?

Readers who liked this book also liked: