BookLife Prize - 2025 Critic Review 

Plot/Idea: Anne Black: Seed of Scotland is an adventurous love story that integrates Scottish lore, magic, history, and immortality, all staged against a modern setting.

Prose: Vaughan's novel features strong, descriptive writing, with syntax and diction that is lyrical without being overwrought. Dialogue reads naturally and the narrative voice is consistent and enjoyable.

Originality: This work is steeped in rich Scottish mysticism, presented with knowledge and authority. While Seed of Scotland draws from familiar genre conventions, the striking setting, sweeping romance, and Celtic history lends it particular substance and allure.

Character/Execution: The character development here is effective, in no small part due to the quality of writing on display. Characters are provided sufficient depth through natural exposition, while the larger romantic arc is both bittersweet and powerful. Readers will immediately feel close to Anne as she embarks on an uncertain journey that will take her further than she ever thought possible but, ultimately, back home.

Readers Favorite - 5 Star Review:

Anne Black by Rosanne Vaughan is wonderfully written, and once you start reading, there is no putting it down.

The steady pacing kept me intrigued and eager to discover the next twist in the seamlessly flowing plot, which was refreshingly unique.

Themes of mythology and timeless romance leave the reader yearning for more. The emotional resonance and vivid descriptions truly capture the imagination.

Characters are well-developed, and the dialogue brings the story to life with authenticity.

The novel also explores thought-provoking ideas around Celtic culture and reincarnation. This was an unforgettable read... 

Readers Favorite Review - 5 Star Review :

Author Rosanne Vaughan's immersive narrative blends romance with high fantasy, weaving historical and supernatural elements seamlessly.

The world-building is exceptional — it draws the reader deep into Anne’s journey, making every moment feel real and resonant.

The looming supernatural war creates a compelling sense of urgency that keeps the reader hooked until the very end.

Anne and Sam’s relationship is beautifully written. I fell in love with them as their bond deepened through love, destiny, and danger.

Anne’s inner struggle — balancing her powers with what’s expected of her — adds emotional depth, while Sam’s loyalty as a mortal partner makes their connection even more powerful.

Character development is outstanding, and the overall feel of the story is brilliant, to say the least.

I’m a sucker for a great romance wrapped in a powerful fantasy plot, and Anne Black is right up my alley. I highly recommend it to fans of epic romantic fantasy.